Engadget Podcast: Why the Windows 11 2024 update is all about Copilot AI

This week, Microsoft started rolling out the Windows 11 2024 update, but it quickly became clear that the company was far more eager to unveil new features for its Copilot AI and Copilot+ AI PCs. In this episode, Devindra and Cherlynn chat about Microsoft's current AI priorities, and what it means for people with older PCs. Also, we discuss the death of HoloLens and Microsoft giving up on AR as Meta, Apple and even Snap build for an augmented reality future.


Listen below or subscribe on your podcast app of choice. If you've got suggestions or topics you'd like covered on the show, be sure to email us or drop a note in the comments! And be sure to check out our other podcast, Engadget News!

  • The new Windows 11 update goes all in on Copilot integration – 1:25

  • Amazon announces Fire HD 8 tablet line along with a few (pretty boring) AI features – 28:28

  • Tech debt led to Sonos’ disastrous app relaunch, will they be able to win users back? – 37:48

  • Google is making Gmail summaries more useful and adding a “happening soon” tab to your inbox – 41:11

  • Harvard students hack together facial recognition for Meta’s smart glasses that instantly doxes strangers – 44:00

  • Reddit introduces a policy change that will make site wide protests harder – 46:58

  • Around Engadget: Dan Cooper’s reMarkable Paper Pro review – 51:31

  • Working on – 55:53

  • Pop culture picks – 57:08

Hosts: Devindra Hardawar and Cherlynn Low
Producer: Ben Ellman
Music: Dale North and Terrence O'Brien

Devindra: What's up, everybody, and welcome back to the Engadget Podcast. I'm Senior Editor Devindra Hardawar.

Cherlynn: I'm Deputy Editor Cherlynn Low.

Devindra: This week it's all about Microsoft. I guess Techtober has officially begun, Cherlynn, even though it feels like We've been doing Techtober since August, thanks to Samsung and Google and everybody.

yes.

Cherlynn: Yeah, it

Devindra: just never, it never freaking ends. But yeah the wave of tech news, which we used to call Techtober, which is now just TechFall, I guess, the fall of our lives and our productivity. Yeah. That is all happening. Microsoft announced that the Windows 11 2024 update is going out this week.

But I honestly think Microsoft is way more interested in the AI capabilities that it's bringing to CoPilot and also CoPilot Plus systems. And I think that's kind of funny. I think Cherlynn, you and I as Windows nerds and PC geeks I think it's something worth exploring because more so than even last year, this feels like a major shift for Microsoft.

So that's our first topic. We'll talk about a couple other things too, including HoloLens [00:01:00] 2 and basically the entire HoloLens family dying. As always, folks, if you're enjoying the show, subscribe to us on iTunes or your podcatcher of choice, leave us a review on iTunes. That's always appreciated. Drop us an email at podcast@engadget.com.

com and join us Thursday mornings, typically around 10 45 AM Eastern on our YouTube channel for our live stream. If we have gadgets, we'll do you know, sometimes we'll show them off. We'll do Q and A's. It's a fun time. Join us. Sherilyn, I'm sorry that I basically threw these giant stories at you ahead of ahead of the.

Big news announcement this week. A lot of big stuff happening from Microsoft Windows 11 2024 update, but also new features coming to co pilot plus AI PCs including more information about privacy and recall new features for the co pilot AI assistant. How did you notice something odd?

About these stories as I sent them to you, Cherlynn.

Cherlynn: Beyond it seemed like Microsoft might have given you the information incredibly close to the deadline. Well, there's

Devindra: that there's at least we got a heads up, but something that I don't know if you've noticed because I think you had [00:02:00]access to these docs too The news was essentially, Hey, this update is coming.

Everybody get ready for it. We love windows. We love windows updates. And then my entire, the entire document was like, Oh, by the way, copilot plus AI PCs, that's all we care about. So I got this document that was just like all new features. And then one little paragraph at the end, Oh, by the way, when this 11 update, you get HDR backgrounds, you get all this stuff, like literally 10 sentences.

But the entire like presentation for Microsoft is we love Copilot plus AI PC systems. Did that feel weird to you?

Cherlynn: I mean, I know that there was this the main post that you filed was like at the end where you said, Oh, by the way, there are these Windows 11 updates as well coming. And I think it didn't feel weird to me, I guess, because I was like, yeah, of course they're all in on Copilot and everything is about AI.

And maybe that's why, maybe I'm so over You're just so used to

it.

Right, the incremental cadence of every platform update being like little things, even though you know, before 10, we had a big significant jump to 10, and then 10 to 11 just felt kind of [00:03:00]minor because it was built for like better arm based improved performance, and then Now AI seems to be the mad rush here.

So I agree with you. It is weird, but it took you pointing it out for me to realize or feel it. You know?

Devindra: I mean, I totally agree with you. Like typically when we talk about windows updates, especially the annual cadences, like they're not huge things. And even windows 11 itself felt like a weird half step update where the most compelling thing was like, Hey, we put the task bar in the middle of your screen.

Rather than the side of your, that was the only thing people were talking about. I think, yeah, Microsoft is aware that the thing that could be more exciting now to people is Copilot Plus, first of all, and I think that's also key. I think more so than the Copilot AI Assistant, which is going to be in, you know, pretty much most Windows 11 machines, the Copilot Plus stuff, that is for the newer systems basically released this year.

So stuff like with the new snap track and processors, go ahead.

Cherlynn: Yeah no, I mean, the thing you're pointing out is exactly the thing that, got me questioning while I was reading your pieces because it wasn't about the windows 11 updates. It was more [00:04:00] you clearly have a distinction between co pilot and co pilot plus, and I was like where?

And then I had to like, I sussed it out for myself eventually, but I was like, Oh, so there is co pilot versus co pilot plus, and there's a bit of a difference here, right? There's, I mean, there's a total,

Devindra: yeah. So when I covered, I went to Microsoft's campus in May, right. Head of WWDC and everything.

That's when they announced the co pilot plus. PC initiative. And that was these custom, not custom, but these like systems that had a certain level of quality, right? So they launched with the new Qualcomm Snapdragon X elite and X pro chips. But basically there was a minimum standard of 16 gigabytes of RAM, right?

40 tops NPU. So really powerful NPU for AI work. So it could do a lot of stuff locally rather than sending AI stuff to the cloud. You know, decent amount of hard drive space too. But that's the thing. It's like a certain level of computing quality. And that's the sort of thing Microsoft had to basically launch as an initiative with Qualcomm, AMD, Intel, everybody.

Whereas when Apple did their big push for ARM [00:05:00] based and new chips and everything, they could just be like, well, here's our new thing. We did it all. We did all the work and developers just have to catch up with us. So the copilot plus features are things like recall, but also new things that they talked about.

There's something called click to do, which if you hold down the windows button and right click, there will be contextual things you could be doing within that dropdown menu. So if you're in the photos app, I believe you can like, you can have it like just blur the background. Just remove this object if you click on an object.

So that's kind of useful. We're kind of getting a sense of what Microsoft wants to do with these new NPU powered features in the photos app, you can also super resolution photos, which is something you could do in Adobe stuff and Lightroom and other apps Pixelmator does that on the Mac too, but.

That's kind of cool. If you have a Lowr resolution photo and the AI basically interpolates a lot of stuff in that image to give you a bigger file that also looks pretty sharp. I've used that in Pixelmator. It's pretty good. Yeah, just a couple improvements down the way the recall stuff is interesting [00:06:00] too, because Microsoft also basically held a call last week to be like Hey, Recall privacy.

This is actually very important to us. And we're going to be very clear about this. And this follows the whole debacle after the recall launch where the recall announcement where everybody was like, there are gaping security holes here. Security researchers found things like where if you were an administrator, or actually, no, if you were able to hack into a computer, even without admin access, you could get access to the recall database, which is the screenshot of everything it's recording that you're doing on your system.

So Microsoft had to. Delay that feature by several months. Didn't even release it to testers to really lock that down. So the whole it sounds better now. It sounds like they're encrypting the entire database. Recall itself is running in what they're calling. Let me see here. A VBS enclave. So not even just like an encrypted thing, but like a virtual package of like where the program is too.

So hackers can't like directly access it. Windows Hello biometrics is necessary by default. And [00:07:00]also, Oh, the feature is not turned on by default. You have to turn it on. And these all came from complaints from everybody. I also asked Microsoft specifically, so what did you learn from this whole mistake, like this whole situation, which is they announced recall and they were like, this is one of the coolest things you can ever do.

You can remember anything you've ever done in your computer. Was completely mired in controversy. So, I talked with, or I sent a question to Pavan Devaluri, which is the head of windows. He's the head of windows. He knows we had an interview with him on this podcast months ago. He knows our complaints and our criticisms of surface and windows and everything.

And he basically said that they realize now that users want to have. Extra confidence with anything involving like their sensitive data, or especially AI things that are recording all their data. And also AI involves a rethinking of how Microsoft and other companies think about security on a Windows system, right?

Typically, if you have an administrator account on a Windows computer, The thinking is you could just go in and do anything, right? You could [00:08:00] do anything on any other accounts. You are an administrator of that PC. You have really like basically broad privileges, but now if you're using these AI features, which are sucking in a lot of data and a lot more data than windows PCs used to, maybe there's a good.

excuse for not giving the administrator full access to that, you know, to whatever that database is. So there's just things that they're thinking of that they didn't think of before. And that's a shame, but they're saying like that basically this whole fiasco they're taking into consideration. I don't quite know if I trust them yet, but how do you feel about their turnaround I

Cherlynn: think it took quite long.

And I re I realize it's more than just allow people to opt in. There's the holes they had patched the access to admin versus like user. Encrypting everything

is an encryption.

It still felt like it took a little long, but I mean, It just goes to show how little Microsoft had any forethought, right, about this sort of [00:09:00] privacy concern.

That it took public backlash to be like, Ah, crap. And that they had to, it felt like a ground up attempt to fix all these issues. And it doesn't bode well for me for any of their future sort of features based around your information. Like I think they are, I tend to think of Microsoft as the most engineer brain of the top three, like AI companies out there.

They're very engineer brain. They're very like, Oh yeah, this is convenient. Oh, it works. Let's ship it. They don't think about what about all these other things? What about people who are using your product that are not engineer brain that are going to break it in some consumer way, right? So I think it took a while, but I'm glad they're at least considering, and I hope it's a lesson, to be considering these things ahead of time, you know?

Devindra: Yeah, most definitely. They're also like, let me see here. I like the security things. Revamped copilot apps are getting some interesting features too. I think this is all kind of interconnected. So they basically announced this whole new [00:10:00] strategy called copilot labs, where they're going to talk about where they're going to let people play with new features ahead of time.

Let me see here. Copilot vision is one of those, and this is a weird thing. This is like literally the thing we're worried about. That's. It's going to basically see everything you're doing in your web browser showing and be able to basically give you tips on it. It's basically involving constant eyes on what you're seeing.

That's a lab feature. And also think deeper. Which is the ability to just give it a task and have it process a little longer to maybe get you some more helpful advice. These are all Copilot Labs features, these are like extra experimental if you think about the old Google Labs stuff. And right now only people paying for Copilot Pro subscriptions, so those are the 20 a month thing.

Only those folks can test it for now. I think at the very least, Microsoft is being very careful about how it's rolling this stuff out. It is showing it to people, but also a very small audience and taking that feedback before it rolls out broadly. And the thing about recall, they were just like, Hey, here it is.

Look, everybody, this is so [00:11:00]cool. We're capturing everything you're doing on your computer. And they were more excited about it than I think they realized. P other people would be because they didn't realize how little people trusted Microsoft, right?

Cherlynn: Yeah, I think the conundrum of having to pay for access to some of these extra features ahead of time is Both like a joy and a risk that you're taking and I guess we talked about this early adopter mindset a lot on the podcast which is Yeah.

You pay a premium to get to access things like prototypes, right? And these features in the labs are basically prototypes, but then you're also risking exposing yourself to a lot of potential, like, vulnerabilities. I guess. I don't think the word is exploits. I don't think the word is like bad. Like it's not bad.

It's just you have to be aware. The vulnerabilities is

Devindra: the world. Yeah. Is the word.

Cherlynn: Yeah. And, you know, I guess, cool, pay for that but at the same time, these are people who are paying there for early adopters, probably already much more on top of their security and knowing the risks they take.

It's just like Microsoft selling it to people [00:12:00] who are paying, meaning they're selling it to people who are fans, who are less likely to question is, you know, curious, in my opinion.

Devindra: I think it makes sense just being careful and also not too long after the show when we both went to Apple's campus and they announced Apple intelligence and it seemed like even Apple intelligence was launched with, The awareness of everything that went wrong with recall, right?

Like even Apple and other companies are kind of learning from all this. It's a learning experience for everybody, but the people going first usually take the first hit. So in this case, it was Microsoft. It's often open AI. We saw Google bar, you know, stumble right out of the gate too. And Apple at least is able to sit back and just watch and see how it can make things more useful.

Speaking of So this is the CoPilot app itself. CoPilot on the web, CoPilot's mobile app. There are some new features coming there too. CoPilot voice, which gives it a more personable assistant like voice. So you can actually have a back and forth conversation with it. That's kind of cool.

I think that's, that just makes it feel more more [00:13:00] useful to a lot of people. Copilot Vision, we talked about, they're going to do this thing called Copilot Daily, which that voice will also give you like a daily rundown of news and also things you may have scheduled or on your calendar. They want you to think of Copilot as like this thing that you can basically always turn to.

It feels like Copilot is your new computing interface in a way. And that's also probably why they're a little more excited about it rather than A Windows update, even though the Windows update is pretty big according to Microsoft, it is a full OS reconstruction. So it is not just like a minor step up.

It is like a full re installation and a full re architecture of Windows. Maybe following along the lines of what they did for the ARM stuff, back around the Copilot Plus launch, that version of Windows that went out with the ARM systems is very different. They had to rebuild Windows a lot.

To deal with arms. So I feel like we're going to see more of that basically on the Intel and AMD side. Any questions for one? This is, I see the chat is talking about this too. [00:14:00]This is just kind of wild to me. Cause last year we went to the Microsoft event and ended up being a surprise event about AI and we were all very confused.

How do you feel about like their standing now around AI and windows and everything?

Cherlynn: Yeah, I think you're pointing to the fact that Simon B. in the chat asked who is leading in AI, Windows OpenAI or Google for the consumers. And I mean, the rest of this episode. Windows is OpenAI

Devindra: at this point.

Cherlynn: Yes. The rest of this episode I think talks sort of about that, right?

We're getting to some Amazon news later in this episode that was announced this week as well. But what we're seeing, and to your point, Devindra, compared to this time last year or like last year in April or February, I forget. It was being AI. It was like the first time we had to contend with like consumer facing versions of these features.

But now here we are a year and a half after the fact, and every company has pushed out their own version of writing tools, summaries, basically, Chad GPT. And then we've got other companies doing their own implementations, you know, co pilot, we've got Google stuffing AI [00:15:00] into literally anything it makes.

We've got Apple with the redesigned Siri, which is still in classic Apple style, not actually here yet, right? Apple intelligence, slow to the party. And Amazon will see in a bit, gave us kind of, a teaser at what AI on it's going to look like. And it's much more of the same, but here's what you said got me to thinking, right?

You say that it's a, their new, basically the new interaction mode is the new interface, right? Well, how people are going to interface. I think I saw this trend when Tik Tok started becoming more of a thing, like short form videos started becoming more of a thing and I was like skeptical of it ever really taking off.

And yet you see. That generations for example, that, that story from the verge a while ago, where kids don't even use directories anymore, they just search in their file, explore for the file they're looking for. I was like, Oh crap, I guess. Yeah. You don't need to organize how

Devindra: files work. Yeah,

Cherlynn: I did. And I thought that was the way and these things are changing.

I think we're at. The start of [00:16:00]maybe gen alpha, whenever they get their first laptop, whenever they start using these Google services are going to be so used to AI that they'll use it in a way that we never thought, you know, and I, it's disappointing to me because I think it's even more critical thinking or kind of offloading to a computer as opposed to having our own brain process.

But I could also see human beings finding new, unique, creative ways to interact with AI. So I don't know, it's, Ooh it's

Devindra: it's

Cherlynn: weird, you know?

Devindra: It is weird. I am, I'm still unsold on the idea of the AI stuff taking over everything. Like I think at the end of last year, I wrote like Microsoft is really all in on copilot AI, but doesn't really have a vision for what it is going to be.

Now we're kind of seeing more of that, but also at the same time, like the basic copilot search is not super useful to me, I would rather search the internet and get actual results from, and go look at those results rather than have this. Machine feed information back to me and me not under, like it playing a game of telephone and us [00:17:00]not knowing if that information is actually accurate.

And then I have to go back and check that. Meanwhile, the actual Bing search is still as useless as ever. Which is funny to me I use edge a lot because I use different browsers for work and personal stuff, so I sometimes stumble into Bing search and it's still man, I wrote, I literally know I wrote this article about this thing.

It is at Engadget. com. And Bing just doesn't know it exists. I can put almost the full title of the whole thing there and Bing can't find it. And yeah,

Cherlynn: Not to okay. So disclosure, our parent company is Yahoo, which is owned by Apollo. Right. And even on yahoo. com

come on. Yeah.

Yahoo. No I've used Yahoo because I was forced to because of my corporate machines to hold to Yahoo as a search engine.

Sadly. Even Yahoo is I'll be like Engadget iPhone review or something. And the first result is not. Engadget, Yahoo, iPhone review, it's something else. And I'm like, what? Thankfully, because we know the people at Yahoo, we can be like, what is going on? This [00:18:00]search is bonked. And then they're like, oh, let's fix it.

So they'll, they can fix it. To your point though, like Bing AI, Bing search is pretty useless still. I think we're going to get to this later in the episode too. But I think Google search, Is also getting worse and worse. I've seen this online for a very long time, right? Yeah. With the ads placements up top, with the shopping modules up top, with the top stories and the discover boxes up top, it used to be helpful.

Now it's just getting the actual results further down the page, the things that I actually want to do. I don't care what Google wants to put in front of my eyes. I want to go and look into the results myself, maybe because I was born in the eighties, but

Devindra: This is why I like, I'm not so chilling on this AI driven future because Google is forcing it at us.

Microsoft is the Google search right now. You will see generative AI stuff at the top, usually then sponsored topics and other ads and stuff, maybe Google shopping. And then towards the bottom, you get to the results you want. So all these things are making our. Computing experience is worse. And I wonder like there it's high time [00:19:00]for some sort of user revolt on this stuff.

Like we looked at one look at recall and we were like no, thank you. Not like this. And Microsoft had to scramble back into its cave and fix it. Society took one look at Google glass and was like, no, thank you. That's not going to fly right now. We are just not ready for this, but also there are so many problems with this tech.

I do think we're going to get see a lot more pushback now, personally,

Cherlynn: I will say to be contrary. And I will point out that in our chat, Lee Woods says they use Gemini advanced several times a day just to summarize articles. You're hoping that they figure out a way to integrate Gemini into the Chrome browser.

Look, I think summarize is could be one of the easiest, like the best things that I can do if it's accurate and reliable. And I think For a lot of people who've been trying out the Apple intelligence stuff on betas, they found notification summaries to be quite accurate and super helpful. Yeah. There are tools that are going to be helpful.

We're just going to figure out and weed out, you know, the bad from the good. Yeah.

Devindra: Yeah. I mean, it's all about how we use this information. [00:20:00]Yeah, notifications. You know, what sucks right now in modern life and modern computing life is notifications. Too many notifications solve that problem for me.

Thank you. Less of a problem. Is finding stuff on the internet, but also making it harder for me to find stuff on the internet because you want to sell me this service that you, Oh, I'm so glad you love Gemini Google. That's cool. Nice. Good for you, Google. I would just like to use Google. I would just like to use Google search.

So yes. There is a point where it's getting in our way and these companies care more about it than we do. And then I think there are companies that are being, trying to be a little more thoughtful. Apple is doing some of that. Microsoft is getting there with some of the Copilot plus AI features, but we shall see.

I don't want to sound like an old man shouting at the clouds, but sometimes when things are dumb and things are stupid, I think you have to be like, the emperor has no clothes here. You know, last year at that event, Trillian, I distinctly remember talking to Microsoft executives and being like, how can you have this thing, which you know, is not always accurate, is not [00:21:00] always correct.

How can it be the basis of all these new interactions that are going to be a big part of windows and they're just like, this is a learning experience. I think people will understand if we make mistakes, that's not. It's not how computers should work, folks. Like I don't, you don't want to calculate or to have a learning experience as you're trying to, you don't calculate a critical figure for you.

You want me to just do the specific task. And even Microsoft was unaware of that. We shall see how all this goes kind of related to this. We also saw the news that Microsoft is killing HoloLens too. And there's no plans for a followup device. It's going to be using I think I heard. That they may be going to Anduril's headsets.

Like they're going to be doing software for that for military uses or something, but essentially HoloLens is dead, which is funny to see after literally last week, Facebook was just like, this is the future of augmented reality computing. Here are Orion glasses. [00:22:00]We saw Snaps glasses. We saw Vision Pro last year.

It seems like finally this category is heating up and Microsoft's response is okay, no, thank you. No, once there's

Cherlynn:competition, we're out. Sorry.

Devindra: Yeah. I mean, it doesn't help. Remember the HoloLens guy, Alex Kipman, I believe was booted out of Microsoft for being kind of a dirt bag. Just like we, he was like a weird sexist horny guy who really liked his AR.

Glasses. So that was the story going around. He just did not make that team a really good environment. So if you lose the guy who's like leading that technology, that's one thing, but also if you have Facebook, if you have meta, who's willing to spend tens of billions of dollars to really get ahead and Apple, who's clearly thought harder about vision pro than I think Microsoft has about HoloLens when it comes to making a consumer product.

It just seems like Microsoft was here early, but it can't compete. This is such a pocket PC situation for Microsoft. They had some Hardaware, they had some ideas. This is a web TV moment, but. Ultimately, they just [00:23:00] couldn't make it work and that's a shame. I liked HoloLens too. Like they, if they were willing to, I think there is space for Microsoft to play here.

I don't know. Did you ever try a HoloLens too? Or do you

Cherlynn: have feelings

Devindra: around this? I,

Cherlynn: I can't remember if the one I tried was an old one or the two, the second, I believe it was the second gen and it was like an event in Times Square. It was one of those art events and they were really trying to steal it.

So I'm going to be talking about how you can sell the potential of HoloLens outside of industrial and workplaces. I mean, I remember when the first few demos of HoloLens were just so interesting, where you could use these hand gestures, you could like, collaborate with teammates on this virtual diagram or whatever.

And I got to say, like in the headset wars, right? I mean, everyone made their own. There was the Mirage, the Quest. I mean, the Quest obviously with Meta having bought them became kind of the front runner right now, in my opinion, for more consumer friendly devices but HoloLens did stick around for a while there as something that people used in like factories or like more industrial places and commercial uses, and it [00:24:00] definitely had.

Felt to me for a while that Microsoft won in that category, even if it was very niche. And like you said, the defense category is somewhere where they can probably make a lot of money out of, but I, it's sad to see that just as it's getting, you know, to a point where the race seems to be properly heating up that like Microsoft's no, we're good.

Thanks.

Devindra: No, thank you. Yeah, we're it's a little, it seems like you guys are far ahead of us right now. So we're just tapping out. I did a demo. If you go back and read about I think it was called Microsoft mesh, which was their like virtual meeting software. And they sent me a HoloLens too. And I sat here in my office and I had a group Call with Microsoft executives and like 10 other journalists.

And it felt like they were all just, we were all just sitting near each other, even though we were all at our own homes. It was like 2021 maybe. So pandemic was still like keeping people away from each other. And that's, it felt good. It felt like it worked. It wasn't super clunky, but the Hardaware was just too expensive and I [00:25:00]don't think they wanted to do the work to like really make that cheaper.

They also had the whole like, you know, Windows mixed reality stuff for them to try to get into VR, but that felt like a little too late. Because Oculus was doing stuff before HTC Vive was doing stuff before. So Microsoft was too late to VR, too early for AR. And now everybody else is just like trekking ahead for maybe in 10 years, we'll get like the true AR glasses that everybody's dreaming of.

And honestly, I also feel like we as a society are not ready for those either. But yeah, just kind of, kind of sad to see. So RIP HoloLens. Maybe the, They look so cool is the thing. I kind of do want one when they're like 50 bucks being thrown out in a couple of years, I would love a HoloLens just to put on my shelf, just like I have a Microsoft Kin.

I have both Microsoft Kin phones in a drawer somewhere.

Cherlynn: I continue to hold on to Engadget's Google glass. So I understand

Devindra: the aliens are going to find our drawers full of like old tech and be like, [00:26:00] well, no other humans have these things. Why do these people like, what is the story here? What happened here? Anyway. Yeah. A shame for HoloLens, but yeah, we'll see. We'll see what happens.

Cherlynn: Maybe they'll come up with co pilot glass.

You know what I mean?

Devindra: They're going to do, they're going to work on integrations for everybody else. So that's the thing. Microsoft rather than. Being the platform being the Hardaware. They're gonna try to work with everybody else's stuff That's why we're seeing Xbox and quests and everything right now.

So yeah, just a shame to see and Let us know what you folks think I mean I feel like maybe just because I'm a 90s PC kid who grew up on Windows like I have an affinity for old Windows I think about the way it works a lot If you have thoughts about Microsoft's new trajectory Drop us an email at podcastsandgadget.

com.

All right, let's move on to some other news. We got some stuff from Amazon and, oh boy, [00:27:00] is this, Sherilyn, we make fun of Amazon for being really boring when it comes to Hardaware, except for like their crazy random stuff, this is a nothing burger of a news hit. We got a new Fire HD 8 tablet, everybody. It's slightly faster.

It has a better camera. It's still a fire HD eight. I guess the crazy thing is it is available for 55 on sale. If you go for the ads and everything. So that's not, that's pretty good for a tablet with just free to sit down and watch stuff and it's faster than before. So there's that, but also like they want to do AI stuff with it.

Sure. Okay. Of course. Everybody wants to do AI summaries and whatnot. Is there anything special about these tablets, Rowan?

Cherlynn: So to be clear, Amazon announced the Fire HD 8 and two variants, the HD 8 for kids and I think like Pro is the other version. Anyway Alongside the launch of the Fire HD 8, it also announced some AI features are coming with the HD 8, but we'll also be rolling out to compatible Kindle tablets that already have been in the market for a very long time.

So [00:28:00] I was most intrigued by that. I want to do clarify that the HD 8 normally will retail at 99. 99, so 100. And right now it's on sale up until the end of Prime Day, which is from today. I, I don't know if you've opened your Amazon app, you'll see the big ad October 8th, October 9th, Prime Day.

Yay. I guess we needed another one. And up until then, the HD eight will cost, I think closer to 50, I forget if it's 55, but like somewhere in that ballpark. Anyway, what did jump out at me when I saw the press release was A, this is not the Amazon Hardaware event we've been waiting to happen in October, right?

This is just a drop ahead of Prime Day. And B, the AI tools. So, I was looking at it, I was like, first thing that came to my mind, I was like, Have we heard of AI? Amazon's AI features like this because it was like writing summer. It was summaries, writing tools and that sort of stuff. Yeah. I was like, Oh, this might be our first look at Amazon's own AI for devices.

Right. We've heard about some of their chat [00:29:00] bots. We've heard about, you know, it's improvements coming to its voice based assistant, which I will not say the name of right now, but like this for devices is basically rehashing what we've seen before, except for with an Amazon spin. So the only thing that stood out at.

To me was that you can get the AI to generate new wallpapers for the tablet, which cool. I guess the Alcatel idol four could do that. You know, it's just so many Android's material. You to quote a more recent example. So nothing super groundbreaking. But the fact that it's going to be available on a cheaper device, the fact that it's coming to a tablet.

Just to recap, like last week Samsung had the its FE event where it said it was bringing Galaxy AI to all, right? Samsung hammered home the point that with its new Galaxy Tab S10 series, that now you've got Galaxy AI on a phone, a tablet, and a watch. It's, you know, Samsung. It's, quote, bringing its AI to all, I guess, form [00:30:00]factors.

And Tab S10 starts at, I want to say, 650, maybe 700. So it's, yes, it's coming to a different form factor, but it's not necessarily super accessible. And so now, if you want to get a cheap little tablet for your kids for 50, you can. can get one that has AI, or if your existing fire tablet, I have a list of what's compatible.

If you want to upgrade that software, you can also get access to Amazon's AI tools, which are basically like every other chat GPT clone we've seen in the last year and a half. And that just brings me back to the point we were making earlier in this episode that it's becoming more and more prevalent.

We don't know how people are going to use it, but now that more people are going to be able to use it and kids. Ostensibly using a lot of fire HD tablets. We got it. We're gonna start seeing people Mass adopt these I guess I don't know. That's where I'm at with. Yeah.

Devindra: Yeah I mean, it's compelling because these are such cheap tablets.

I don't know about like base model You're giving up a [00:31:00] lot by staring at those Amazon ads folks, but it's hard to deny The usefulness of a 55, eight inch tablet. The kids stuff is cool because they keep saying first of all, there's ad free content, their parental controls. Amazon says that they are going to, they will still replace those tablets if they break, which is like the number one nightmare for a parent.

It's that. Tablets are just screens, like giant screens with glass, and they will be destroyed by your kids. The kids version of the E Fire HD puts them in a nice protective case. They have this guarantee from Amazon, so you feel a little better about it. I still have not done this for my kids.

Like we, I basically buy iPads on sale. I buy old iPads on sale and that's really what we've used as a family. So my son is using an iPad from like 2017 with a cracked screen, but that's what he uses, like in the car, if he needs to watch a video or something. My daughter has a 10 inch, one of the more recent 10 inch iPads.

But we, she wants to play Minecraft. She wants to play like a games from Apple arcade. And you can't, you are very limited [00:32:00] in what you get in a Fire tablet. These are sLowr machines. They have a limited library of games. They can't access all the apps that Android tablets can too, because of the Google stuff is not included.

So just be aware of what you're losing with a cheap tablet. That's all.

Cherlynn: Yeah. And that's why they're good for, I guess, kids, but to Dpro9's point in the chat, this is e waste right out the gate. Yeah,

Devindra: kind of, kind of. No, you're

Cherlynn: not wrong. I don't, I can't argue.

Devindra: It's a digital catalog. For buying stuff on Amazon, also for watching stuff on Amazon prime.

That's really what they want you to be doing. And then, oh, by the way, it can also do Netflix. It can also do these other things, but they just, they care about their own stuff. I

Cherlynn: see. I see the appeal of it being like a cheaper Kindle with a not great screen. And I can only imagine what a summary AI tool on a Kindle book might do.

Like it's not, I think, going to work with Kindle titles, but one day, Final Evolution, don't read books. Just read these AI summaries. I mean,

Devindra: the AIs can already summarize books. So I do. Yeah. [00:33:00]I don't know if you'll get it all within text, but it'll, they'll do it through the cloud or whatever. And then who needs to read who needs to really engage with content and wrestle with complex moral choices like just let's Smooth brain all the way AI brain means no tough choices for any of us And that's where we're going as a society.

Love it. Love to see it

Cherlynn: I will point out that a person in our chat. I think it was I've missed it, but you pointed out that you were you're doing your master's Tom Rogers or Someone that you're using the Kindle scribe and that's the like Tablet that Amazon makes you can write on which like this week, you know We are also gonna talk about a bit more about writing tablets.

And I think For me, that's where Amazon's Hardaware is still intriguing. And to be clear, no new Kindle has yet been announced this year season slash whatever. So we could still be waiting to see stuff from Amazon. And I wonder what would happen if they decided to stuff AI into a Kindle. Like I have no clue.

Devindra: It's mainly the [00:34:00] ink technology that keeps Kindles the price that they are. They occasionally go down, but they, those do not have super fast processors. Those are like really like basic devices. I would imagine they could easily get some cloud AI stuff. So like cloud source, Hey, some interesting topics that, you know, that these people have, or also when you go on Amazon now, you get AI crowdsourced user reviews.

I can imagine that being a thing. In the kindle like store when you're browsing around. Yeah,

Cherlynn: I could see that I could see also with the kindle scribe Like I said being a writing or drawing tablet like they could not only give you prompts for drawing. They could also Start an outline for you teach you calligraphy or teach you show like I used When I was reviewing the Kindle scribe originally, I used it a lot for Japanese, you're not going to practice.

So like handwriting practice for a different language. I could see if AI would just generate worksheets for me. That would be interesting. Hire me, Amazon. I will think of these ideas for you. That would be actually useful.

Devindra: I don't think [00:35:00] you want to work with Amazon. No, I don't know very few people don't work at Amazon.

I want to point out a thank you, Mark Dell for this wonderful comment, because it also fits into a bunch of things. But he says somebody needs to make an AI pin that just listens to everything and makes every decision in your life. Perfect. For those who are bad at decision making, it'll be the last decision you ever make.

That is a black mirror episode just waiting to happen. That certainly is going to be a thing. Also, Yeah shout out to the Yorgos Lanthimos movie, Kinds of Kindness, which is sort of about that too, which is sort about the idea that humans, we kind of all just want to let go a little bit and let people make decisions for us and then be like little subservient little slobs.

So depending on your view of humanity, you don't even need AI for that. You just need you just need a Dom to basically build your entire life. Let's move on to some other news. How about that?

Cherlynn: Did you see, did Sonos stuff,

Devindra: Sherilyn?

Cherlynn: I did not, but please explain to me. I mean, I saw it floating around and I kind of [00:36:00] have the TLDR, but I'd love to hear your details.

The

Devindra: TLDR is that Sonos released an app overhaul earlier this year. It was supposed to be a big redesign for them and it was a disaster. It was buggy. It crashed a lot. I honestly had trouble like connecting to my speakers properly. It lost features, including things like setting alarms that the original app did.

Disaster. Like literally Sonos, your only job is to give us the software to send music to your speakers. That's all you have to do. And what came out is that basically Sonos is a company that's been sitting on a lot of technical technical debt over the last few years. So there's a lot of stuff.

The old app was. Basically built on a lot of things and there were things they never cleaned up. The kind of underlying technology is something they never cleaned up. As Sonos was racing ahead to launch this app, a lot of people inside the company were complaining about it and kind of raised the alarms and saying this is not up to snuff, we should not release this.

And people were ignored. People were kind of bullied for even bringing up issues. So [00:37:00] that's a great corporate environment that you want to see. And now Sonos is at the point where they're just like fully fully. Apologizing and basically saying that they're going to do everything it can to fix this.

So, the quota here is our priority since its release has been and continues to be fixing the app. There were missteps and we first went in, went deep to understand how we got here and then moved to convert those learnings into action. I love when everybody said, anybody says learnings, by the way. Such wonderful corporate speak.

The quote continues. We are committed to making changes to get us back to being the brand people love by offering the best audio system for the home and beyond. And the quote I believe the Sono CEO so they're saying they're going to do a lot of changes. They're going to do a lot more testing.

And they're extending the manufacturer warranty for all home speaker products, including home theater gear and plug in speakers. I saw the news that the CEO is also declining to take a bonus this year, which is like the least you could do. You're still going to get paid millions, tens of millions of dollars.

Cherlynn: Rejecting this little bonus on top of my multi million dollar salary. Okay.

Devindra: Yeah. But at least [00:38:00] it's more than most CEOs do often when a company screws up, either somebody gets fired but rarely is somebody like, Hey, like I'm just going to take a direct hit for this. So, Hey, that's something good to see.

I would love to know what your stories are. With with Sonos speakers at this point, folks, I still use them, but it's stuff for sometimes I'm within Spotify and I like to send audio from Spotify straight to Sonos that's hit or miss these days. The Sonos app itself is still all over the place. I still like Sonos speakers cause they sound so much better than a lot of them in the actual networking.

The actual synchronization stuff is great. But just kind of a mess. I feel like they should discount some of these things. Be aware of the ARC whatever the new headphones are too. That was kind of the thing they were rebuilding the app for. And

Cherlynn: the

Devindra: ACE headset. Yeah. Those also don't seem like they're really worth buying at all too.

So check out our review of that whole thing. Yeah, Sonos is still keeping it real, I guess, trying to fix all these mistakes. You have something you want to mention from [00:39:00]Google, Cherlynn. Yeah, just a

Cherlynn: really quick bunch of news from Google. There was this is like a drive by recap, really, because the stuff that I want to talk about apparently isn't happening yet.

Gmail is getting better summaries, and Google is adding a happening soon tab to its Gmail service. I like that. I mean, like sometimes Google has really improved Gmail. Like I think Inbox was an app we all loved for a time and then they killed it. But the Inbox was really where they surfaced a lot of these good features.

Oh, there's a pack you know, like notification. You say

Devindra: we all very broadly, but it was certainly, I mean, the people

Cherlynn: online at that time,

Devindra: I remember Inbox. being launched. I'm like, what the hell is this? This was like when Google had 10 different video conferencing apps and couldn't decide on it either.

So I was mainly confused by Inbox, but yes, those designs did come over to main email. Yeah.

Cherlynn: I think there were some really interesting features that debuted on Inbox. And then finally when they did get integrated into Gmail and then, you know, cohesively bringing all of them into one app is the choice to make.

I agree with that. I just think there was some [00:40:00] nostalgia for Inbox. I still see online sometimes. Anyway. I mean, I like when like for example, last two weekends ago or something like that, I was watching James McAvoy movie that I cannot remember the title of anymore. Speak No Evil or something?

Devindra: Yeah.

Cherlynn: Okay I bought the ticket on an iPhone and had a Pixel 9 Pro next to me. Both had their SIM cards in them. And the Pixel 9 Pro had the SIM card. Tickets just like the instant I hit pay and it pulled up the tickets on Google pay because gmail was so good at parsing the receipt That I got in my inbox and just pulling that information.

I mean, yeah, it's a little creepy, but it's also very convenient for me whereas like You know, other features like track your packets, there's an event in this email, I will add it to your calendar that sort of stuff is really helpful in Gmail. And honestly, I think it's not a bad thing. I don't know if there's a net loss overall in terms of security and privacy, but we'll see.

So anyway Google also updated its Chrome Plus Chromebook Plus Slate of products this [00:41:00] week. Go to Engadget. com for all the details. Nate covered it for us, but yeah, I mean, as we continue to see all the big companies fight it out over AI it's nice to, you know, I guess, see what else is being put out there.

Devindra: That's something. I mean, it's also, I guess we're still waiting for are we waiting for like a Google Hardaware event again?

Cherlynn: No, thank God. I hope to God. No, if they did, I would be very upset.

Devindra: I mean, looking forward, we were waiting for possibly an iPad event slash Mac book event from Apple. Something more from Amazon.

Cherlynn: Exactly. I'm just waiting on Amazon.

Devindra: It's a whole bunch of that. There was a cool story. Did you see this one? It's really about a pair of students put facial recognition technology onto meta smart glasses basically to instantly dox strangers. They're not going to be releasing this code. This is more of like a project they did to prove what is possible.

And things that, that basically are kind of trivial to add to something like smart glasses. Did you see the story?

Cherlynn: I saw the headline, but what you're describing sounds a lot like that black mirror contact lens situation, right? Where you like scan people face [00:42:00] recognition and immediately pull up their like profile info.

There are social network and it's not just black mirror, right? It's a lot of science fiction movies have done that, but yeah, I, that's what it sounds like they're doing. I don't know if I'm mistaken.

Devindra: So essentially like they, it looks like it's going through the glasses, but also going straight to the information is going to a smartphone.

We're actually seeing it too. So you're kind of getting more information there. I will say there is a certain. Especially from a company like Meta, which I'm sure has looked at this stuff. Like we have all your, we have all your friends. We know who your friends are. We have all these databases of faces and names.

So we have that information too. I'm sure once Meta is ready to do like true AR stuff, this is going to be something that they do. I also think, and I think I learned this later in life is that I'm probably a little face blind. I used to think I was just bad at remembering people. But I personally think Oh, I have, I genuinely have a problem like deconstructing a face, unless you're somebody with like really distinctive [00:43:00] hair or something like that, or like a really distinctive face, things just kind of blur together for me.

So just professionally, I could see it being kind of useful or socially, I guess. So I see the uses, but yeah.

Cherlynn: Like that scene in Devil Wears Prada where like Anne Hathaway and Emily Blunt are instructing, walking out to her. That's your like nightmare.

Devindra: Which is which?

Cherlynn: Yeah, but then like with the glasses, you never have to worry maybe, but again, AI has to be like reliable.

What if it recognizes, what if AI is also face blind and it's this is the governor or of, I guess, I don't know, Minnesota. I think I already

Devindra: know to distrust my brain when it comes to faces. So now it's just okay, you're just helping. Maybe I distrust you a little bit too, but you probably. You are probably better than me at some of

Cherlynn: this stuff.

However, to be clear, it's not as if Emily Blunt was all that reliable in the movie as well. Anita and Hathaway, the update pack to help her. So we, that's

Devindra: a great movie.

Cherlynn: You know, I saw that in

Devindra: theaters. It's a great movie. Anyway, this is a story from 404media. So yeah, check them [00:44:00] out at 404media. co. Love their work and love that they picked this whole thing up.

I also love to see like students doing this sort of work because this is what you want to see people doing, like not being like, I can't wait till I get a job at Google or Meta or wherever, but also taking this technology and like pushing it to its limits and like showing what is possible and what could be dangerous about it too.

So this is super cool. Did you have any thoughts, Cherlynn? Cause I know you went to talk about this before, but Reddit's policy changes to make site wide protests nearly impossible. We saw this story float up too. Kind of interesting there. Maybe a little disappointing from Reddit. Yeah.

Cherlynn: I am a chronic Reddit.

So I am

Devindra: as well. Yeah.

Cherlynn: Yeah.

Devindra: Yeah.

Cherlynn: When I'm not playing match factory, I am trying to rot my brain by doom scrolling Reddit, and I know that Reddit has had a lot of issues recently too that's got a lot of us up in arms. There was like that, that, you know, what is it called? Boycott. Thank you.

There

was a boycott last year or earlier this year.[00:45:00]

Time is a blur, but there was a boycott earlier because Reddit was being just. Awful. And, but now today or this week, I guess on Monday it, Made it harder to site wide protest. Basically it's changed his rules so that moderators of subreddits need admin approval to switch it from public to private.

It is, that's one of the rules that's being changed and is being interpreted as a way to kind of curb subreddits from protesting and, you know, have being able to do so all at once. Multiple subreddits cannot all go private at once without Reddit. Admin approval. It is very strange. It feels as if this was related to the protest from last year because a post on subreddit, our mod news written by the VP of community said the ability to instantly change community type settings has been used to break the platform and violate our rules in the past.

Right. So. It seems as if this could be one of the [00:46:00] reasons. It's only,

Devindra: yeah, I mean, Reddit, a site which is full of content that is created by the company Reddit, right? Fully editorialized content from edit. No, Reddit is a company that exists because people love to just post their own stuff. You exist because of the users.

So now they're afraid of the users, basically. This is what this is showing once again,

Cherlynn: there's a lot of other issues with reddit recently. I mean, the fact that the initial protest was in reaction to the API changes that forced third party apps to shut down. That also led to a lot of accessibility problems.

And then the company during those. The boycott just went in and took complete control of one of the big subreddits that had participated and then also recently licensed its content to train AI models So red has been making a lot of missteps lately. This seems one of the more recent ones anyway, it won't I don't think stop people from protesting in creative ways for me [00:47:00] My funny reaction to this is people will just keep posting more pictures of Sexy John Oliver.

That's it.

Devindra: Flood the zone. Flood the zone with Sexy John Oliver. I've also started doom scrolling Reddit, Cherlynnn, because sometimes it's or Twitter is terrible, especially when it gets I still see random right wing ads on Twitter, but it's also, that's where my friends are, so that's why I can never fully leave Twitter.

Blue sky is kind of up its own butt sometimes with some of those users and Mastodon is fine, but it's just the tech nerds. Like I don't have as like engaging conversations there. So sometimes you just want to like the internet as it was somebody asking, am I the asshole? Like that's,

Cherlynn: am I overreacting?

Am I overreacting?

Devindra: It's okay, that's addictive stuff, but it's all user generated content. And that is the danger. Reddit, when you build your entire company. I. On contributions from your users. So at some point, yeah,

Cherlynn: just a quick note too, that I don't actually think a lot of the advice given on Reddit is good.

Like some of them like default to run and I'm like what are you reading? Two paragraphs and deciding that this person's entire life is boiled down to one word. Stop, [00:48:00] but Reddit is also a very fun place. Like I just, I enjoy a lot of the inside jokes. Some of them get a little overused and stale, but.

It is a very fun thing. It is a thing.

Devindra: And also we've talked about how Reddit has basically taken over parts of the internet where rather than googling questions often like people just search in Reddit to learn how to fix something. Yes, exactly. Often when I'm googling things, like I end up going back to Reddit threads because that's what Google indexes.

Yes. Yes, exactly. Because there's

Cherlynn: multiple people with different expertise going in and giving you the answer on something and maybe one answer is wrong, but some other answer below is probably correct. We should talk more

Devindra: about Reddit at some point.

Cherlynn: We really could. I love Reddit.

Devindra: Alright, let's move on to some stories from around Engadget.

And speaking of writing on e paper, Mr. Daniel Cooper wrote about the Remarkable Paper Pro. It's a color ink tablet that you can write on. It seems super cool. Are you, and he gave it, he scored it 90. Hehehehe. So that's pretty high. The only thing is this thing is super expensive. So I think that's the main problem here, but the actual tech, like color ink is something I feel like [00:49:00] we've been waiting for a long time.

Price, let me hear it's 579 with the standard marker, 629. If you want the marker plus, and you can add a case for 89 and the leather one for 179. So this is a very expensive e ink tablet. Are you compelled by this, Cherlynn?

Cherlynn: That was the first thing I told Dan after I finished editing his review. I was like, I want to buy one of these and I might have to save up for it.

Yeah, 570. I look, I am a Kindle scribe user. I pick it up once a month to jot down my thoughts. Do I think once a month of scribbles is worth 570 as a starting price? I don't know, but it's cool as hell. And it's a, this, one of the pitches and one of the reasons we gave it a high score is that it is a distraction free writing tablet, right?

It's again, like the ink tablets, like the remarkable, like the Kindle scribe you know, books, I guess is another competitor. You don't have that. It's not as easy to just go over to Reddit, right. And in a minute. As it would be on a regular tablet. So [00:50:00]that's appealing. I think Dan was a little nervous about giving such a high score because, you know, it's not a tablet, it's limited in functionality but in its category, I think Dan firmly believes this is the best.

And for me, it's like a 90 means it is the best in this category. I can

Devindra: firmly also see Dan, lovely, funny, British man, just really quaking in his boots about this course. Oh man, is this, am I showing too much emotion here? Is this too effusive for me?

Cherlynn: I will say he was wavering between 89 I was like, no, the only difference here is that we give it a different color award.

Devindra: Yeah. Yeah. But I'm glad. I'm glad Dan likes it. It looks, I've looked at the remarkable stuff for a long time. Does this one also require a subscription? Because that was like a sticking point for me before.

Cherlynn: So, Dan doesn't mention the subscription in his review. And that is a good point. He does mention that the software has been meticulously fine tuned to make it easy Kindle scribe.

I will point out that Amazon has done a [00:51:00] lot of good hard work to improve some of its syncing over the year or months. It's been like six years since I reviewed the Kindle scribe so that like you can now, you know, sync your notes across your Amazon app toting devices, but you can, it's editing them is still tricky.

I don't know. It's not an easy space to be in. Let's say

Devindra: yeah. Oh, I see. So the subscription is required for clouds thinking. That is like a requirement for me. If I have something like this, like I want to be able to access my digital notes anywhere. So

Cherlynn: anywhere, exactly.

Devindra: Put that into the price too.

But I've been intrigued by the remarkables for so long. And this one is just like the dream of color ink. We're almost there. It's super expensive, but it does exist. So. That is, that's super cool. Yeah. Maybe we'll all get to play with it at some point. Also want to shout out Mr. Team Stevens has written a test drive for us of the Polestar 3.

They're a long awaited SUV. They're it's a compact SUV. But it's like a flagship one for Polestar. I'm sort of intrigued by this too, because Polestar is sort of like a sister brand to [00:52:00]Volvo and I'm into like what all the Volvos are right now. Tim also did the Volvo EX90 video for us a couple of weeks ago or months ago.

That's also worth checking out, but this one looks really cool. If you want a premium luxury electric, have you driven an electric car yet? She'll end. Cause I know you're in the process of learning how to drive.

Cherlynn: Oh, I don't know. Electric. I've driven plenty of gas cars, electric fuels.

Devindra: I feel like we get to record that video of just you, like having that experience of the instant torque.

And it feels real different. Things can go bad really quickly with an electric car.

Cherlynn: Yeah.

Devindra: We shall see. We gotta get Trillian on video. That should be a video series at any gadget. That'd be cool. That

Cherlynn: might be, yeah. It can happen. Anytime.

Devindra: All right, let's move on to what we're working on. I reviewed the Asus ZenBook S14, the new one with Intel's Lunar Lake AI chips.

Really liked it. So it's a nice laptop. I wish we had more access to the to the Copilot plus features that it, that update is not fully out yet. So I can't test recall. I can't test all those things, but this is sort of Copilot [00:53:00] ready. It is a nice piece of Hardaware. They're using like a weird ceramic metallic top two at the top of the lid, which I think feels good, looks unique and yeah.

Just really dig it. So pretty solid ultra portable. We're going to have a whole slate of like really decent laptops coming soon. So looking forward to that. Anything you want to shout out, Cherlynn?

Cherlynn: We just continue to plan for upcoming events and reviews. Not a lot of gadgets will be coming in. We just can't really talk about a lot of them yet.

And then I'm hopeful that I'll be taking some time off in October. All right. Maybe you might not hear me for a couple of episodes on the podcast. I know. It's always every time I put requests for a time off, it's always like maybe a tentative request. Cause the only reason, it's not that my team doesn't want me to go off, it's the tech companies that are like, surprise event.

And there goes my, like I could still take it off.

Devindra: Yeah. All right. Let's move on to our pop culture picks for the week. What do you have, Cherlynn?

Cherlynn: So mine's not so much a pop culture pick as a just like general life tip. And not anything that should surprise anyone. So I've been [00:54:00]spending a lot of time watching YouTube more than anything.

So I think I sort of already talked about this. The last time I was on that I canceled Hulu just cause it was getting way too expensive. And I also already have Disney plus. And then, you know, watching more YouTube, I paid for YouTube premium. So that's something that, you know, as a piece of advice that everyone's been giving YouTube premium is actually a pretty good, solid thing to pay for.

So much stuff to watch

Devindra: basically. Yeah,

Cherlynn: exactly. There's a lot to watch by creators, but also even from you know, filmmakers that are Hollywood titles out there. There's I was watching, bring it on the other day again for the 300th time on YouTube. But I don't really generally like to like recommend things that we cover.

So I tried to stay away but we have a really good. necessarily cover this. I just recently started a course on Coursera. It's the, I can't remember if it's the Harvard course or the Yale course, but one of the IVs, they have a course on psychology. So it's intro to psychology. So far I'm really enjoying it.

I think yeah. This program was designed very nicely. [00:55:00] The modules are a mix of recommended readings on the internet, and they're all free by the way, but also these like specially created videos by the academic institution itself and the lecturer who teaches the course at Yale, they've combined it with this voice, a transcript, as well as these animations that make it very digestible.

So I really liked that. And I think. My tip isn't Coursera specifically, but it's more like lifelong learning. I think you're never too old to keep learning. And it's so much more information's available out there, whether it be YouTube or Coursera or any number of learning platforms, I have been finding it really fascinating to dive into those.

So instead of, you know, and I'm not binge watching.

Devindra: You're doing something constructive with your time. First of all, Trillian, of course, for you to relax. You give yourself schoolwork. You're literally assigning yourself homework. So this says a lot about when I'm

Cherlynn: not, when I'm not doom scrolling, read it to learn about people or playing match factory.

I am sitting on the toilet on Coursera. So you're doing fantasy

Devindra: schooling [00:56:00] right now because you just miss the homework and the pressure and everything. It's great. But I agree. You never stop learning. I watch a lot of documentaries on YouTube. I, this is, I've just been like consuming stuff over audible more now too.

So like I found like nonfiction books are work really well for me over audible. So that's been a good way to digest a lot of that stuff. I'm glad you're digging this Shrillen. I'm glad it's been helpful for you, but yeah, I cannot get over, of course this is how Shrillen is unwinding. She's just giving herself more work.

Overachiever

Cherlynn: vibes. Yes. Overachiever

Devindra: vibes. Totally. Speaking of overachievers, I feel like you should go to the theater and check out Megalopolis, which is the Yeah,

Cherlynn: I have been wanting to. Yeah.

Devindra: Because this movie is kind of a, it is a spectacular disaster of a film, but it's also like a very singular, weird type of thing.

It's a Francis Ford Coppola movie that we've been waiting for decades, literally decades, he's been talking about. Yeah. He has spent, I think, 120 million of his own money to make this thing happen. This is a movie about a man who's trying to build a magical utopian city because he thinks [00:57:00] his country, or New Rome, his city, is kind of falling apart, like America today, and New Rome is also New York, and the imagery is all really blunt, the performances are all over the place, but it is kind of fun to watch.

Just how wild it is. Like Adam driver stars is essentially a Robert Moses stand in this architect who is destroying parts of the city to build his utopia built with a new new material. He discovered children. It's called Megalon. It's a living, it's a living building material. Isn't that.

Something. This movie is just all over the place. Tonally performance wise. Aubrey Plaza is in it as a character named Wow Platinum. She is a financial journalist slash broadcaster, and she's also bringing her like her, like spunkiness to this. I enjoy the interesting people to cast less a fan of it.

Like bringing people like Shia LaBeouf, who I don't want to see on movie screens anymore because he's a piece of garbage, but. The movie itself, like you have Lawrence Fishburne monologuing also working as like the assistant to Adam driver. [00:58:00] His voice just lends so much gravitas to this. It is a big, dumb thing.

That is it is a wild swing is a wild performance swing. I think for theater kids. I think maybe for you too, Cherlynn, like, I, I think you fit within the theater kid mold, but

Cherlynn: I'm kind of a theater kid. It is,

Devindra: it is very much within that. It's a wild swing about Oh, society is crumbling and what can save it?

Maybe one genius man. If we just follow him, maybe this could be it. At one point Adam driver does the, to be or not to be soliloquy and just. Does the whole thing because he does that to prepare, like it's a thing he does to get into his acting mode. And I think at one point, Francis Ford Coppola was like, yeah, we're just going to keep it in the movie.

We're just kidding. You're walking around the set. The to be or not to be has nothing to do. With what is actually happening in the movie, he likes, he liked it. So they kept it in this movie is all over the place. It's not going to, it's doing terribly in theaters. It may go away soon, but it sure is a spectacular thing to watch on a big [00:59:00]screen.

And yeah, talk about overachievers, like Mr. Francis Ford Coppola, who, you know, was tasked to do the Godfather at the age of 29. He was a really young man when he started working on that movie to make some of the best movies ever made and then to. Basically have a really weird late stage career where he is continually trying to reinvent cinema.

This is his big dream project. It's a mess, but it is it's not boring, you know, it is a really interesting thing to see. You can see clips of the performances. Just a thing I'll recommend, especially if you have time and you want to see like a wildly ambitious thing. Something I do think you'll showing, because I know you've watched anime in the past and you're a fan.

There is a new show that everybody's been waiting for. It's called Dan Da Dan. It is premiering today, or yeah, it's premiering today on Netflix and Crunchyroll. This show is like watching FLCL for the first time. It is just a big dose of wild anime energy. It's crazy. It is about, it's about two high school kids, a girl who [01:00:00]believes in ghosts and doesn't believe in aliens and a boy who believes in aliens and doesn't believe in ghosts.

I think I talked about this last week too, but I wanted to recommend it to you specifically Sherwin. Wild anime. I've I'm going to check out more episodes. The animation is fantastic. It's from Science Saru. But mainly for you, Cherlynn, because we did talk about this before. It is fantastic stuff.

I also finished season two of Interview with the Vampire, which is also good stuff. Amazing stuff. And I'll talk more about that. And I'll try to convince Cherlynn to watch that series to see some what is on Netflix right now.

Cherlynn: Well, that's it for the episode. This week, we're Week everyone. Thank you as always for listening. Our theme music is by Game Composer Dale North. Our outro music is by our former managing editor, Terrence O'Brien. The podcast is produced by Ben Elman. You can find DRA online at

Devindra: Oh yeah, I'm at DRA on Twitter, mastodon blue sky, all over the place.

I'm also talk about movies and TV at the film cast. At the film cast.com.

Cherlynn: If you have any great ideas for what actually useful things AI can do, you can send [01:01:00] them to me. I can take credit for them and pitch them to the big companies. I'm at Cherlynn Low on Twitter or X. C H E R L Y N L O W I am at Cherlynn's Instagram on threads.

You can also email, um, Cherlynn at engadget. com. Email us your thoughts about this show at podcast at engadget. com or any questions really you have that you want us to answer. Leave us a review, please, on your podcast platform of choice and subscribe anywhere you get podcasts.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/engadget-podcast-why-the-windows-11-2024-update-is-all-about-copilot-ai-113026863.html?src=rss

Microsoft delivers new Copilot+ AI PC features with Windows 11’s 2024 update

Now that we're a few years into Microsoft's obsession with AI and its Copilot assistant, it's clearer than ever that Windows 11's role is to show off the company's artificial intelligence prowess. At least, that's the message I took away from today's announcement that the Windows 11 2024 (version 24H2) update is now beginning to roll out. While the OS itself is getting a few new features, like long overdue File Explorer tweaks, Microsoft is far more eager to hype up new Copilot+ AI PC capabilities.

There's "Click to Do," which triggers Copilot to assist you with whatever is on your screen, like removing an object in the Photos app, or summarizing a long article. It's seemingly easy to use — just hold the Windows button down and click your target — and Microsoft says it'll offer contextually relevant tips. As with so many of the company’s AI features, you can think of Click to Do as an on-demand super-powered version of Clippy, its infamous software helper from years past. But since Click to Do appears at your whim, and there are actually some potentially useful AI features, it should hopefully be far less annoying than that damn paperclip.

Windows 11 2024 update
Click to Do in Windows 11.
Microsoft

You'll also be able to upscale pictures in the Photos app by up to eight times their resolution. A slider will let you adjust precisely how much you'd like to increase the quality. This isn't particularly new—Adobe has its own AI-powered Super Resolution capability, as does the popular Mac photo editing app Pixelmator. But at least it's helpful to have it built directly into your OS. Generative AI-based fill and erase options are also coming to Paint, allowing you to remove objects or easily create new ones.

Microsoft has hinted at some AI-powered search improvements in the past, and it looks like those are finally arriving with the Windows 11 2024 update. Now you can find files using your own words, without worrying about esoteric search syntax. If you want to find pictures of your dog by the beach, you can just type that.

And of course, there's Recall, the company's debut Copilot+ feature for retrieving anything that happens on your computer. It was immediately criticized for being surprisingly insecure — researchers discovered that hackers could access the Recall screenshot database without administrator privilege. Microsoft immediately delayed Recall to revamp its security model: It's now making the feature completely opt-in, instead of flipping it on by default. Windows Hello biometric authentication is required to use Recall, and it's also encrypting the screenshot database and other interactions.

Windows 11 2024 update
Recall timeline in Windows 11.
Microsoft

Last week, the company detailed more of its security methods, including using VBS Enclaves to further isolate Recall from hackers. David Weston, Microsoft's VP of OS and enterprise security, noted in a blog post that "you are always in control" of the Recall experience. That reassurance may not be enough for users turned off by Microsoft's initial security flubs, though. If anything, Recall's rollout was a clear example of how the company was cutting corners to move quickly and be seen as an AI industry leader.

"Copilot will be there for you, in your corner, by your side, and always strongly aligned with your interests.," Mustafa Suleyman, the company's head of AI, wrote in an overly enthusiastic blog post. "It understands the context of your life while safeguarding your privacy, data and security, remembering the details that are most helpful in any situation."

Security will undoubtedly be a major concern for Copilot users moving forward, and according to Microsoft's Windows head, Pavan Davuluri, the company has learned from its troubled Recall launch.

"Ultimately, users want to have confidence with anything happening with sensitive data caches," he said in a briefing with press, adding that he believes the company has "gone above and beyond" to create that confidence. He also acknowledged that AI features enable "new attacks and defenses." For example, Windows has traditionally allowed administrator accounts to have total access to everything on a machine, but now users may want to see "additional rings of protection" with AI features.

Surface Pro Copilot+
The Surface Pro Copilot+ AI PC.
Photo by Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

Davuluri stressed that community feedback helped Microsoft make Recall more secure for users, and the company will continue listening as it carefully rolls out more AI-infused capabilities. That's also why all of the above Copilot+ features won't be rolling out to everyone immediately — they'll be available to Windows Insiders first, and then arrive via a phased rollout to "select devices and markets" in November. The Windows 11 2024 update will also have a staggered rollout starting today. If you're eager to snag it, make sure you've enabled "Get the latest updates as soon as they're available" in Windows Update.

And what about features from this Windows 11 update that don't require Copilot+ PCs? They appear at the tail-end of Davuluri's blog post today, almost as an afterthought: There's Wi-Fi 7 support, HDR backgrounds, Energy Saver improvements to prolong battery life and better hearing aid support using Bluetooth LE. They sound like the Windows upgrades we used to see before Microsoft became completely AI-pilled, but they're certainly not as exciting as something like Click to Do.

Of course, that's all intentional. If you want to join the Copilot+ AI PC party, you'll probably have to get a new computer. And that's precisely what Microsoft and PC makers want.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/microsoft-delivers-new-copilot-ai-pc-features-with-windows-11s-2024-update-140048807.html?src=rss

Microsoft’s Copilot AI gets a voice and the ability to see websites you browse

Beyond debuting new features for Copilot+ AI PCs and Windows 11's 2024 update, Microsoft is also giving its Copilot AI a makeover on the web, mobile and desktop. That includes a slightly friendlier interface wherever you access it, along with new capabilities like Copilot Voice, which allows you to talk conversationally with the AI assistant. Ultimately, Microsoft is aiming for Copilot to be seen as more than just a party trick for generative AI search and image creation — it's trying to make it a core part of your daily workflow.

That starts with a cleaner and simpler UI that makes Copilot look different than a boring old search engine. That new look hits Copilot on the web, iOS, Android and Windows today. You'll also be able to access Copilot from within Whatsapp, which could be useful if you want to avoid Meta's AI assistant.

Microsoft also plans to release more experimental AI features via Copilot Labs, similar to the way Google has given users access to early features with its own Labs. There's Copilot Vision, which lets the AI see everything you're viewing in Edge, and Think Deeper, a method for letting Copilot work harder on more complex dilemmas. Both features also have the potential to create new privacy and security issues, but Microsoft appears to have learned a bit from its messy rollout for Recall on Copilot+ PCs. Notably, these Copilot Labs offerings will only be available to people paying for Copilot Pro subscriptions.

Microsoft says Copilot Vision sessions are "opt-in and ephemeral," and nothing is stored for AI training. Any data related to your session is deleted once you're done. The feature also won't work on all websites, only a "limited list of popular websites." And Microsoft notes that Copilot only interprets images and text that you're seeing on a website; it's not doing any major content processing. The company also plans to take feedback from early users, refine safety measures and "keep privacy and responsibility at the center of everything we do."

There's no doubt that Microsoft has to re-establish trust with its users after the botched rollout for Recall, a feature that was meant to help you find anything you've done on your computer, but had some gaping security holes early on. "Ultimately, users want to have confidence with anything happening with sensitive data caches," Microsoft's Windows head, Pavan Davuluri, said when we asked him about the lessons the company learned from the Recall fiasco. He added that he believes the company has "gone above and beyond" to create that confidence by establishing new security standards for Recall.

Microsoft Copilot
Copilot Discover
Microsoft

There are less controversial features coming, as well: Copilot Daily uses Copilot Voice to delivery a summary of news, weather and potentially reminders about tasks every day. Based on the demos we've seen, it's a lot like an early morning podcast built just for you. Copilot Discover, meanwhile, will give you tips about AI features to use (pictured in the screenshot above), depending on Microsoft services you've used in the past.

Personally, I'm still a bit ambivalent about Microsoft's near-instant transformation into an AI company. That's particularly true since we're still dealing with inaccuracies and other issues from OpenAI's ChatGPT, which Microsoft relies on to power Copilot. These Copilot features seem a bit more useful than being a souped-up search engine, but the company still needs to prove it can build AI features with bulletproof security and privacy.

As with practically any AI product these days, Microsoft is also staggering the release of these Copilot features. Copilot Voice and Daily launch today, but Voice will only be available in English in the US, Canada, Australia, the UK and New Zealand. Copilot Daily, meanwhile, only works in the US and UK for now. Copilot Vision will head to Labs over the coming days for a "limited number" of Copilot Pro subscribers, while Think Deeper is available for Pro users in the US, Canada, Australia and New Zealand.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/ai/microsofts-copilot-ai-gets-a-voice-and-the-ability-to-see-websites-you-browse-140030003.html?src=rss

ASUS Zenbook S14 review: A showpiece for Intel’s Lunar Lake AI PC chips

ASUS's latest Zenbook S14, much like the Zenbook 14 OLED we reviewed last December, is a solid ultraportable with one major selling point: It's among the first laptops to use Intel's newest CPUs. In this case, it's the Core Ultra 7 258V, a processor that sits in the mid-range of the company's "Lunar Lake" lineup. While Intel touts these chips as its most efficient ever, I've been curious about what that means for raw performance, especially since they top out with just eight cores.

Based on my testing, I can confirm that the Zenbook S14 delivers the best battery life we've ever seen from an Intel laptop. It reached 16 hours and eight minutes in the PCMark 10 battery benchmark. In comparison, the Zenbook S16 powered by AMD's new Ryzen AI 9 365 chip only hit 12 hours and 47 minutes. The Intel system's timing is close to the 17 hours and 45 minutes we saw from the Dell XPS 13 Copilot+ , which is powered by Qualcomm’s Snapdragon X Elite.

While it's astounding to see how much progress Intel has made with battery life, that does come with some compromises. In a few benchmarks, the Zenbook S14 doesn't score much higher than Intel's last-gen Core Ultra chips, and it's often bested by AMD's Ryzen AI on multithreaded tasks. But, as we often say, benchmarks don't tell the entire story.

When I reviewed the Zenbook 14 OLED a year ago, I couldn't help but point out how dated it looked. It was practically the same as ASUS' laptops from a decade ago (albeit with slimmer screen bezels). Not so with the Zenbook S14. It's impressive the moment you open it up and feel its lid, which is built with a material ASUS calls "Ceraluminum." As the name implies, it's a combination of ceramic and aluminum, and it feels almost uncanny, like something between high-end plastic and smooth metal. It's still premium, but it's also distinctly different from most other laptops.

Combining ceramics and aluminum isn't exactly new — ASUS notes that it's a popular option for aerospace and watch designs — but we haven't yet seen it deployed in laptops. It's not just for looks, either. The material should also be more durable than standard metal. The rest of the Zenbook 14 S's body is made out of a solid block of metal, but ASUS added some unique tweaks there as well. The lower part of the case features a geometric grille above the keyboard, consisting of 2,715 circular cooling vents. ASUS claims this design enhances airflow while also keeping dirt and dust out.

ASUS Zenbook S 14 (2024)
Photo by Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

ASUS 14-inch 3K "Lumina" OLED display dominates the Zenbook S14, and it delivers everything I want from a modern laptop screen. It sports a fast 120Hz refresh rate and 500 nits of peak brightness. While its bezels are relatively thin compared to older ASUS systems, they're still noticeably chunkier than Dell's latest InfinityEdge screens on the XPS 13 and 14. The system would look much sleeker if ASUS could shave off more of its bottom and side bezels. Most importantly, though, the OLED display looks glorious, with deliciously dark black levels and colors that pop off the screen.

The Zenbook S14 is surprisingly sturdy for a 14-inch laptop that weighs 2.65 pounds and measures 0.47 inches thin. It's slightly lighter and a hair thicker than the most recent 13-inch MacBook Air, and feels similarly polished. Notably, it also offers many more useful ports than Apple's ultraportable. The S14 includes two Thunderbolt 4 USB-C connections, a full-sized HDMI 2.1 port, a headphone jack and even an old-school USB Type-A port. The only thing it's missing is Ethernet and an SD card slot.

Unfortunately, ASUS couldn't get everything right with the Zenbook S14. Its quad-speaker audio system is serviceable, but the sound loses any sort of depth and detail as you ramp up the volume. And while it's nice to have a Windows Hello-compatible webcam for fast logins, the 1080p sensor looks far grainier and less detailed than Dell's XPS line and the MacBook Air.

ASUS Zenbook S 14 (2024) keyboard
Photo by Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

Its keyboard also feels merely serviceable, with little responsive feedback while typing. That’s a particular shame, since that’s been a constant complaint we’ve had with ASUS keyboards. At least the touchpad is large and responsive to swipes and multi-finger gestures. You can also adjust the volume and other settings by sliding your finger along the sides of the touchpad.

Thanks to Intel's Core Ultra 7 258V chip, the Zenbook S14 felt impressively zippy from the start. I breezed through the Windows setup process, downloaded the latest updates and installed my usual testing programs in just a few minutes. It didn't sweat whenever I needed to jump between apps like Spotify, Slack and Evernote, and I didn't notice any of the lag I often see on Windows notebooks bogged down by third-party bloatware. It was always ready to get work done.

PCMark 10

Geekbench 6 CPU

3DMark Wildlife Extreme

Cinebench 2024

ASUS Zenbook S14 (Intel Core Ultra 7 258V)

6,688 (Base Test)

14,215 (Applications)

2,569/10,442

7,158

121/482

Dell XPS 13 Copilot+ (Qualcomm Snapdragon X Elite)

14,024 (Applications)

2,621/14,194

6,191

122/748

Dell XPS 13 (Intel Core Ultra 7 155H, Intel Arc)

6,806 (Base test)

2,276/11,490

4,579

90/453

Apple MacBook Air (M3)

N/A

3,190/12,102

8,310

141/490

In PCMark 10, the Zenbook S14 scored almost exactly the same as the Surface Laptop 7 for Business, which uses the last-gen Core Ultra 7 165H. It also matched the XPS 13 Copilot+ edition, which had a Snapdragon X Elite chip, in the PCMark 10 Applications benchmark. The Zenbook's multithreaded performance was noticeably worse than either of those machines in Geekbench 6, likely due to the reduced core count this generation.

The big selling point for Intel's Lunar Lake chips is their dramatically improved NPU (neural processing unit), which can reach up to 47 TOPS (trillions of operations per second) of AI performance. In comparison, the previous Core Ultra chips had a significantly less powerful 11 TOPS NPU, while AMD's new Ryzen AI chips reach up to 50 TOPS. (More powerful Lunar Lake chips can hit up to 48 TOPS.) Higher TOPS figures means Copilot+ PCs like the Zenbook S14 will be able to tackle demanding AI workloads more quickly, without impacting overall CPU performance.

Unfortunately, there still aren't a ton of AI features to test at the time of this review. Microsoft's Copilot+ Windows 11 update for Intel and AMD systems isn't arriving until November, and even that will only include a beta version of the controversial Recall feature. It's also hard to find apps that take advantage of a local NPU — most entries in the Windows Store "AI Hub" rely on cloud AI processing.

ASUS Zenbook S 14 (2024) rear case
Photo by Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

At least there's Audacity's OpenVino plugin, which Intel developed to show off its AI PC hardware. It offers NPU-powered features like noise suppression and transcription, but it also requires an involved setup process that may be confusing to Audacity novices. I was able to completely remove incessant jackhammering from a five-minute clip in one minute and eight seconds using the NPU alone. That's not very fast in the world of audio editing (CPU rendering can tackle a noise-filled 90 minute file in three minutes and thirty seconds), but what's key is that the NPU handles the same work using very little power. That could be important if you're stuck editing on battery in a plane or remote location.

I was also impressed by Intel's latest Arc 140V GPU, which let me play Halo Infinite between 35 fps and 45 fps in 1080p with low quality graphics settings. That's far from a smooth experience, but it's fascinating to see it from a built-in GPU. Intel's graphics also scored well above the Snapdragon X Elite across the board, especially in the Geekbench 6 GPU test.

ASUS Zenbook S 14 (2024) showing the Windows 11 login screen
Photo by Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

ASUS launched the Zenbook S14 with a starting price of $1,500, but it’s already slightly discounted at Best Buy for $1,400. That configuration gets you a Core Ultra 7 chip, 16GB of RAM and a 1TB SSD. That’s not too shabby, considering the XPS 13 Copilot+ system with a Snapdragon X Elite costs $1,800 when equipped with 16GB of RAM, a 1TB SSD and an OLED display. The Zenbook also doesn’t have the compatibility issues inherent with Snapdragon systems, which have to emulate older Windows apps and can’t run many popular games at all.

As usual, ASUS also delivers far more value than Apple. A MacBook Air with 16GB of RAM and a 1TB SSD costs $1,700, and that’s also stuck with a 60Hz LCD screen.

The Zenbook S14 leans more on efficiency than raw power, but it’s still an incredible achievement for Intel, a company that used to be infamous for energy-devouring mobile chips. While the Lunar Lake chip’s NPU makes the Zenbook ready for Copilot+ and AI features, its true selling points are its excellent battery life, slick ASUS design and gorgeous OLED display.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/laptops/asus-zenbook-s14-review-a-showpiece-for-intels-lunar-lake-ai-pc-chips-171642261.html?src=rss

Microsoft explains how it’s tackling security and privacy for Recall

The condemnation of Microsoft's Recall feature for Copilot+ AI PCs was swift and damning. While it's meant to let you find anything you've ever done on your PC, it also involves taking constant screenshots of your PC, and critics noticed that information wasn't being stored securely. Microsoft ended up delaying its rollout for Windows Insider beta testers, and in June it announced more stringent security measures: It's making Recall opt-in by default; it will require Windows Hello biometric authentication; and it will encrypt the screenshot database.

Today, ahead of the impending launch of the next major Windows 11 launch in November, Microsoft offered up more details about Recall's security and privacy measures. The company says Recall's snapshots and related data will be protected by VBS Enclaves, which it describes as a "software-based trusted execution environment (TEE) inside a host application." Users will have to actively turn Recall on during Windows setup, and they can also remove the feature entirely. Microsoft also reiterated that encryption will be a major part of the entire Recall experience, and it will be using Windows Hello to interact with every aspect of the feature, including changing settings.

"Recall also protects against malware through rate-limiting and anti-hammering measures," David Weston, Microsoft's VP of OS and enterprise security, wrote in a blog post today. "Recall currently supports PIN as a fallback method only after Recall is configured, and this is to avoid data loss if a secure sensor is damaged."

When it comes to privacy controls, Weston reiterates that "you are always in control." By default, Recall won't save private browsing data across supported browsers like Edge, Chrome and Firefox. The feature will also have sensitive content filtering on by default to keep things like passwords and credit card numbers from being stored.

Microsoft Recall Security Architecture
Microsoft

Microsoft says Recall has also been reviewed by an unnamed third-party vendor, who performed a penetration test and security design overview. The Microsoft Offensive Research and Security Engineering team (MORSE) has also been testing the feature for months. 

Given the near instant backlash, it's not too surprising to see Microsoft being extra cautious with Recall's eventual rollout. The real question is how the the company didn't foresee the initial criticisms, which included the Recall database being easily accessible from other local accounts. Thanks to the use of encryption and additional security, that should no longer be an issue, but it makes me wonder what else Microsoft missed early on.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/microsoft-explains-how-its-tackling-security-and-privacy-for-recall-170059383.html?src=rss

Engadget Podcast: PS5 Pro hands-on and Meta’s wild Orion AR glasses

We've finally had a chance to try the PlayStation 5 Pro and Engadget's Jessica Conditt has come away impressed. In this episode, Devindra and Jess chat about what the PS5 Pro does well, and discuss who a $700 console is actually meant for. Also, coming off of Meta Connect 2024, Karissa Bell joins to chat about her time with the Quest 3S, as well as her thoughts about Meta's Orion AR headset and AI plans.


Listen below or subscribe on your podcast app of choice. If you've got suggestions or topics you'd like covered on the show, be sure to email us or drop a note in the comments! And be sure to check out our other podcast, Engadget News!

  • Jessica Conditt’s PS5 Pro hands on: 60fps makes so much difference – 0:42

  • Karissa Bell’s dispatch from Meta Connect 2024 – 27:04

  • Meta Quest 3S: an impressive and affordable step forward in consumer VR – 28:55

  • Orion AR glasses are a big swing, just don’t expect to buy them any time soon – 32:50

  • Ray-Ban Meta smart glasses – 38:28

  • Pop culture picks – 58:24

Host: Devindra Hardawar
Guests: Jessica Conditt and Karissa Bell
Producer: Ben Ellman
Music: Dale North and Terrence O'Brien

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/gaming/playstation/engadget-podcast-ps5-pro-hands-on-and-metas-wild-orion-ar-glasses-133029580.html?src=rss

macOS Sequoia review: iPhone mirroring is more useful than you think

Apple's macOS updates have been so dull lately, the most interesting part of last year's macOS Sonoma ended up being widgets. Widgets! Thankfully, macOS Sequoia has a lot more going on — or at least it will, once Apple Intelligence rolls out over the next few months. For now, though, Sequoia delivers a few helpful features like iPhone Mirroring, a full-fledged Passwords app and automatic transcription in the Notes app. At the very least, it's got a lot more going on than widgets.

Heading into WWDC earlier this year, I was hoping that Apple would let Vision Pro users mirror their iPhones just as easily as they can mirror their Macs. Well, we didn't get that, but iPhone Mirroring on macOS Sequoia is close to what I'd want on the Vision Pro. Once you've got a Mac (with an Apple Silicon chip, or one of the last Intel models with a T2 security chip) running the new OS, as well as an iPhone running iOS 18, you can easily pair the two using the iPhone Mirroring app.

Once that connection is made, you'll see a complete replication of your phone within the app. It took me a few minutes to get used to navigating iOS with a trackpad and keyboard (there are a few new hotkeys worth learning), but once I did, I had no trouble opening my usual iPhone apps and games. If you're spoiled by the 120Hz ProMotion screen from an iPhone Pro, you'll notice that the mirrored connection doesn't look nearly as smooth, but from my testing it held a steady 60fps throughout games and videos. I didn't notice any annoying audio or video lag either.

macOS Sequoia
Apple

While it's nice to be able to launch my iPhone from my Mac, I was surprised at what ended up being the most useful aspect of this feature: Notifications. Once you've connected your phone, its alerts pop up in your Mac's Notification Center, and it takes just one click to launch the app it's tied to. That's useful for alerts from Instagram, DoorDash and other popular apps that have no real Mac options, aside from launching their websites in a browser.

iPhone Mirroring is also a sneaky way to get in a few rounds of Vampire Survivors during interminably long meetings or classes. (Not that I would ever do such a thing.) While many mobile games have made their way over to the Mac App Store, there are still thousands that haven't, so it's nice to have a way to access them on a larger screen. Not every game works well on Macs — it's just tough to replicate a handheld touchscreen experience with a large trackpad — but mirroring is a decent option for slower-paced titles. I didn't encounter any strange framerate or lagging issues, and sound carried over flawlessly as well.

I typically always have my phone within reach, even when I'm working at a desk. But picking it up would inevitably disrupt my workflow — it's just far too easy to get a notification and find yourself scrolling TikTok or Instagram, with no memory of how you got there. With iPhone Mirroring, I can just keep on working on my Mac without missing any updates from my phone. It's also been useful when my iPhone is connected to a wireless charger and I desperately need more power before I run out the house.

If you're the sort of person who leaves your phone around your home, I'd bet mirroring would also be helpful. The feature requires having both Bluetooth and Wi-Fi turned on, and the connection range is around 50 feet, or what I'd expect from Bluetooth. Thick walls and other obstructions can also reduce that range significantly. In my testing, I could leave my iPhone in my backyard and still be able to mirror it in my living room 40 feet away. Naturally, the further you get, the choppier the experience.

Sure, Apple isn't the first company to bring smartphone mirroring to PCs. Samsung and other Android phone makers have been offering it for years, and Microsoft also has the "Phone Link" app (formerly Your Phone) for mirroring and file syncing. But those implementations differ dramatically depending on the smartphone you're using, they don't seamlessly integrate notifications and simply put, they would often fail to connect. Once you set up iPhone Mirroring, getting into your phone takes just a few seconds. It just works. And after testing the feature for weeks, I haven't run into any major connection issues.

Apple macOS Sequoia
Photo by Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

It's 2024 and Apple has finally made it easier to position Mac windows around your monitor. Now you can drag apps to the sides or corners of your screen, and they'll automatically adjust themselves. It's allowed me to quickly place a browser I'm using for research alongside an Evernote window or Google Doc. Similar to Stage Manager in macOS Ventura, the tiling shortcuts are a significant shift for Mac window management.

And, of course, they're also clearly similar to Windows 10 and 11's snapping feature. Given that much of Apple's UI focus is on iOS, iPadOS and VisionOS these days, it's easy to feel like the Mac has been left behind a bit. I don't blame Apple for cribbing Microsoft's UI innovations, especially when it makes life easier for Mac users.

Apple macOS Sequoia
Photo by Devindra Hardawar/Engadget

Apple has offered lighting adjustments and portrait background blurring in video chats for years, and now it's using that same machine learning technology to completely replace your backgrounds. Admittedly, this isn't a very new or exciting feature. But it's worth highlighting because it works across every video chat app on your Mac, and since it's relying on Apple's Neural Engine, it looks much better than software-based background replacements.

Apple's technology does a better job of keeping your hair and clothes within focus, but still separated from artificial backgrounds. And best of all, it doesn't look like a cheap green screen effect. You can choose from a few color gradients, shots of Apple Park or your own pictures or videos.

Here are a few other upgrades I appreciated:

  • The Passwords app does a decent job of collecting your stored passwords, but it's clearly just a first attempt. It's not nearly as smart about plugging in my passwords into browser fields as apps like 1Password and LastPass.

  • The Notes app now lets you record voice notes and automatically transcribes them. You can also continue to jot down text during a voice recording, making it a useful way to keep track of interviews and lectures. I'm hoping future updates add features like multi-speaker detection.

  • Being able to jot down math equations in Notes is cool, but it's not something I rely on daily. I'm sure it'll be very useful to high school and college kids taking advanced math courses, though.

  • Messages finally gets rich text formatting and a send later option. Huzzah!

You’d be forgiven for completely ignoring the last batch of macOS updates, especially if you haven’t been excited about Stage Manager or, sigh, widgets. But if you’re a Mac and iPhone owner, Sequoia is worth an immediate upgrade. Being able to mirror your iPhone and its notifications is genuinely useful, and it’s stuffed with other helpful features. And of course, if you want to get some Apple Intelligence action next month, you’ll have no choice but to upgrade. (We’ll have further impressions on all of Apple’s AI features as they launch.)

Sure, it’s a bit ironic that Apple’s aging desktop OS is getting a shot of life via its mobile platform, but honestly, the best recent Mac features have been directly lifted from iOS and iPadOS. It’s clear that Apple is prioritizing the devices that get updated far more frequently than laptops and desktops. I can’t blame the company for being realistic – for now, I’m just glad it’s thoughtfully trying to make its devices play nice together. (And seriously, just bring iPhone mirroring to the Vision Pro already.)

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/macos-sequoia-review-iphone-mirroring-is-more-useful-than-you-think-140008463.html?src=rss

Engadget Podcast: Reviewing the iPhone 16 and Apple Watch Series 10

Our reviews of the iPhone 16 Pro and Apple Watch Series 10 are up, thanks to one very tired Cherlynn Low. In this episode, Devindra and Cherlynn discuss her final thoughts on Apple's new hardware, including why the iPhone 16 Pro’s photo processing is particularly interesting. In other news, we also chat about Snap's fifth-generation AR Spectacles, as well as HTC Vive's new Focus Vision headset.


Listen below or subscribe on your podcast app of choice. If you've got suggestions or topics you'd like covered on the show, be sure to email us or drop a note in the comments! And be sure to check out our other podcast, Engadget News!

  • iPhone 16 Pro and Pro Max reviews: great cameras, but incomplete without Apple Intelligence – 0:59

  • Israel linked to coordinated pager and walkie-talkie explosions in Lebanon – 42:29

  • Snap’s 5th generation glasses with AR look chunky in a bad way – 48:17

  • HTC’s Vive Focus Vision: an intriguing VR headset at a price between the Quest 3 and Vision Pro – 51:35

  • Lionsgate films made a deal with the AI devil – 52:40

  • Pop culture picks – 55:48

Hosts: Devindra Hardawar and Cherlynn Low
Producer: Ben Ellman
Music: Dale North and Terrence O'Brien

(Note: This transcript was produced with help from Descript's AI.)

Devindra: [00:00:00] What's up, Internet? And welcome back to the Engadget Podcast. I'm Senior Editor Devindra Hardawar.

Cherlynn: I'm Deputy Editor Cherlynn Low.

Devindra: This week we'll be talking about the iPhone 16 Pro reviews from Cherlynn. And also, also the Apple Watch Series 10 review. And you're just so busy, Cherlynn. I'm so sorry.

Cherlynn: Yeah.

Devindra: Cherlynn slowly dying. Also joining us is podcast producer Ben Ellman. Hey, Ben.

Ben: Good morning, everyone. Usually we're trying to sell Cherlynn on video games. I think now you're going to have to sell me on the iPhone 16.

Devindra: You know? We will, we will do that. As always, folks, if you're enjoying the show, please be sure to subscribe to us on iTunes or your podcatcher of choice.

Leave us a review on iTunes. Drop us an email at podcast@engadget.com. Also, if you could join us Thursday mornings on our YouTube channel, typically around 10:45 AM Eastern for our live stream. You can see our, our faces. You can see us do some Q and a, and you know, we'll show off some devices too.

So check that out. Cherlynn, I was really excited to see what you thought of the iPhone 16 pro [00:01:00]because based on our previous conversations.

Cherlynn: are you trying to upgrade?

Devindra: No, I'm not. I'm not actually, I am very firmly. I'm like, I actually don't need to do this at all. It's great. It's a good year for anybody who has a 15 pro because just not much of a reason beyond the button.

But I also know. You had conflicting feelings about the camera button. And also, Hey, we can't really judge. It's we can't fully judge this device because so much of it is going to depend on Apple intelligence, which will not start rolling out until next month. The new Siri won't fully arrive until early next year.

So what do you think of it so far? This is just the pro and pro max.

Cherlynn: Yeah. I mean, we, I also, I personally also have been testing and spending time with the iPhone plus. I can talk about them. Our, our, our review may be coming later. Right. It's coming. Nobody can blame you.

Devindra: You just shipped an Apple watch review and an iPhone review.

And last week you had the pixel watch review. So yes. To give everyone

Cherlynn: a sense of the cadence here. So Apple's event was Monday. Tuesday I was there for meetings where I've then left with devices which [00:02:00]to disclosure, they're all owners. We returned them at the end of the review period. Okay. And then there was, then we had Monday morning, the, at 8 AM Eastern, the AirPods for review.

Was published was the embargo and then Tuesday 8 a. m. Eastern was the Apple watch series 10 review embargo. And then Wednesday, yesterday 8 a. m. Eastern, the Apple iPhone 16, all of them, the review embargo lifted. So it's been, it's been wild because it involves a lot of weekend work for some of us.

And, so pardon me if in this episode, I get some names and words and numbers mixed up because it's bound to happen. It happened in our video review a couple times, which sorry, but my brain is, is there. Anyway so I really adore the iPhone 16, the base iPhone 16, because we got the cutest colors. We got the pink and the teal the teal iPhone 16 plus and the pink one.

Now. The, the reason I was actually, I'm going to start with the iPhone 16 because we, we haven't really put out our [00:03:00] formal thoughts out there yet, but I, I, I have spent some time thinking about them. This is the first time you've basically for a while now that you've got the iPhone 16s that are basically close to parody with the pros.

I mean, these are not, not pro phones by any means. But, you know, Apple didn't skimp on like bringing the camera button over to the base iPhone 16 for once. Right. And they're getting new chips, like

Devindra: all the fun stuff. Yeah, exactly.

Cherlynn: They're getting 18, a 18 instead of the last year's a 17, for example. And then, you know, yes, the pros get the 18 pro, but that makes sense.

You're paying quite a lot more money. Those are more powerful phones. And then you've got also the camera button this time brought down to the. The action button might be brought down to the iPhone.

Devindra: The plain iPhone, the base iPhone. Yeah.

Cherlynn: Plus, yeah. So these names are not great. And then you've, one of the things holding back, I guess, the base iPhones is the screen, right?

I mean, okay. They don't have the like same big 6. 3, 6. 9 inch screens as the pros do, but they also don't have [00:04:00]promotion. You're just getting like their retina XDR, I think super retina. So they're good in terms of color and resolution, but you're missing a high refresh rate, some differences in size.

And then of course the cameras aren't as powerful, but you will get spatial audio recording, which means you will get access to features like audio mix in the video recording tool set. So, or the video editing tool set. So I

Devindra: just want to point out here, Sherilyn, as you were holding up those iPhones, it seems like the big difference is.

iPhone 16 pro party in the front, good screen, iPhone 16 party in the back. I

Cherlynn: quite like that. They're so

Devindra: bright and the color is like everything

Cherlynn: you, when I talk about these at some point on our website later, but yes, this, the iPhone 16 keeps the party in the back while the iPhone 16 pro keeps the party up front.

I guess you know where the party isn't

Devindra: the

Cherlynn: party isn't on the sides. It's so sad. I really liked the idea of camera control, which I think we'll just dive right [00:05:00] into camera control. I mentioned already last week that it's, you know, a real like button that you hopefully heard me clicking into the mic just now.

It is awkwardly positioned in my opinion. When I try to hold it up Depending on the size of the phone I mean, I think i've already learned how to grip this so that my thumb sits right on the camera control when i'm holding It up In portrait mode with one hand. In landscape mode, the way that I used to grip my camera to take photos or my phone to take photos is to place my index finger kind of lightly hugging the bottom corner.

And then my little finger at the bottom to kind of brace it. And in this way, You had to

Devindra: Relearn the way you were holding a phone, basically. Absolutely.

Cherlynn: You had to relearn that camera grip that everyone was talking about maybe three years ago. It's Oh God, our camera grip. You know, that's a, that's a thing we learned to cope with this, Modern day technology things.

And now you kind of had to relearn it again. If you're, if you have an iPhone 16, because now too, if you want to press the camera control and you want to swipe on the thing, you have to [00:06:00]hold the phone differently. Your thumb's going to be on the bottom. If you're holding in landscape mode, you have to have your three fingers on the right side to kind of like balance the thing to hold it stably.

And then put your index finger on the sensor to be able to move it without Completely dropping the phone. It is in my opinion, a little clunky. However, I do love that Apple's finally brought Hardaware based shortcut access to the camera app. Let me fix my. Sure, let's pour a microphone.

Devindra: It's okay. I mean, I think the more I hear about the camera button and everything, it does seem compelling.

Like I do kind of feel Oh, that would be kind of nice to have that control, but also, yeah, yeah. I invested, I also invested in the 512 gigabyte 15 pro last year. So it's it's, it's just not worth it. I am interested in what people think of the base model. And I guess once consumers like start getting their hands on it, because yeah, as you were saying, and as we talked about, like you're missing [00:07:00]the zoom camera, you're missing the, you know, faster promotion screen, but beyond that, like that's a pretty capable, it's a pretty good phone for 800 bucks.

I guess as it should be, but then compared to most Android ones, you know, you'll get faster refresh rates on the Samsung's and the pixels. So I don't know how long Apple can justify that. Here's my other thing. Mm hmm

Cherlynn: One of the biggest selling points that I guess Apple made about the iPhone 16 is that they're purpose built for Apple Intelligence, and there's none of that in here yet.

I mean, we could and can run a developer beta to get our A taste for Apple intelligence, but I I'm sorry to announce that we don't review devices based on developer slash whatever beta shouldn't.

Devindra: It's not real. It's not

Cherlynn: stable. It's not the same. It could be very similar to the experience that finally ships.

But it's just not, I'm not, I'm not testing a beta and telling you, yeah, buy this thing. No, I, there's just, it's not no, even [00:08:00] though I think that the line between beta and like public release is quite like gray right now, it's just not very clear because sometimes they release so many software updates after the fact that the one that they released initially might as well be the beta.

But anyway I, I do think that for now there's a lot but the base iPhone 16s are still, they still seem like really solid upgrades for anyone on the base iPhone 15. Now the pros are a different matter altogether. Okay, so I almost immediately switched over to the base iPhone. iPhone 16 pro as my main.

And the smaller,

Devindra: the smaller, the

Cherlynn: smaller one by base. I mean the smaller one, not the max. And before that I had been meaning the gray, the magnesium, the natural titanium, not magnesium, the titanium 15 pro max, and like my hand is a lot happier. For having switched over to the smaller one, even though I didn't, I got like the white iPhone 16 pro and I have the desert iPhone 16 pro max.

[00:09:00] So honestly, the nicer color is in the bigger phone from, from me.

Devindra: I

Cherlynn: don't mind it. And they gave me this like bright yellow case to use with it. I was just like, all right, I don't want to look like. But the, the sad news is that like my main takeaway with the iPhone 16 pro, other than all that camera control stuff I talked about the battery life is quite disappointing.

Devindra: You're going from the big, the big boy battery. Sure. Yeah.

Cherlynn: But when you consider that the pixel nine pro. Made like 25 hours on our battery test and basically generally last two days I would say in real more realistic use probably closer to one and a half days because two days with this thing was more like I Didn't use it as much as my iPhone that I would use my phone.

It's more of a secondary device I you can't you just can't Say, yeah, barely last a day and that's fine. That looks bigger

Devindra: though. The Pixel put them side by side. The iPhone 16 Pro and the Pixel 9 Pro. Okay It's a little bit

Cherlynn: [00:10:00] bigger. It's a little thicker. I

Devindra: feel like they could fit in a bigger, a bigger battery in the Pixel.

Cherlynn: So the, the, the Pixel 9 Pro, to be clear, is only maybe less than an inch taller. Yeah, and then, a bit ever so, nope, ever so, look, it's about, they're really

Devindra: going the harder, the trying to replicate that. Yeah.

Cherlynn: So, yeah, no. So, so here's the thing I, I wrote this in my review too, and I'll mention it on this podcast, which is that I've been surrounded by phones these last few days on my couch And it has been very difficult to figure out to reach for the correct phone, I have to do a big like game of which phone am I holding up?

I, I sort of got, these are,

Devindra: I really do sometimes.

Cherlynn: And then hang on, hang on. That's just one hand. So for the audio version of the podcast. These, these are all on my couch right now. There's about, I don't want to say, how many is that? Seven? Ten? I don't know. [00:11:00] There's a pixel fold here. That is a

Ben: lot of phones.

Devindra: This is the version of fanning you know, a big stack of bills. You're fanning a stack of phones right now.

Cherlynn: So anyway,

Ben: I mean, and it is kind of a big stack of bills, monetary value.

Cherlynn: I will say instead of going to the gym, I've been just lifting these phones. No the, the, by feel, I cannot tell which one is which.

They all feel roughly the same to me, especially when I touch the Pixel 9 Pro and the iPhone 16 Pro. They all feel the same. By touch. In fact, sometimes when I'm using the 16 pro, I start to try to use Android gestures because I'm like, Oh, I'm using the pixel nine pro. Aren't I? So I swipe in from the side to go back and it's ridiculous.

But yeah, it's, they're very similar in terms of build and it's not a bad thing for anyone, but I do think that. Maybe now is the time to start pushing companies to do a bit more with design or their camera bumps. I think I saw somewhere that I think MKBHD did a bit of a wobble test, which is something that Sam Rutherford on our team has been pitching as a [00:12:00]series for like years, but I feel bad we never got around to doing it.

The Pixel 9 Pro, because of its camera bar, doesn't wobble as much, but iPhone 16 Pro certainly does. It's modules. We're going to

Devindra: make an excuse to bring the wobble dance into an iPhone video. Now, is that, that's what's happening here, I guess. Yeah. So

Cherlynn: anyway, I'm sorry, iPhone 16 Pro held back a little bit by its battery life.

I will also point out that I've had some issues with some, what seems like buggy software. I wonder if that has to do with the, in the setup process when I ported my Phone from the 15 pro max over to the 16 pro that like I don't know something is not complete in the setup just yet But I definitely noticed certain glitches here and there I've mentioned To someone that can do something about it that my lock screen just refuses to save the crop aspect ratio sometimes

Devindra: That's interesting.

This is more of a

Cherlynn: [00:13:00] telegram app issue, but the telegram app, which yes, sadly, I still do use every now and then will still resurface the one notification badge on this icon. I'm just like, there's no unreads. There are no unreads. And that's apparently a known issue. You gotta,

Devindra: you gotta go Zen, Sherilyn. You gotta go just ignore all the badges.

Numbers, there will always be numbers.

Cherlynn: Well, yeah, so there's, but there are other And you can

Devindra: just turn the badges off too,

Ben: right? You can turn

Devindra: the badge off completely. Yeah.

Cherlynn: There are other glitches like, When sometimes when I press the camera control and then I flip over to landscape, it just blinks and then just half the screen's gone.

But I've, I've certainly had that with older iPhones before. So it's not like unique to the iPhone 16 pro and which is why I didn't make a big deal of it in my review.

Devindra: Yeah. How do you like the 5X zoom on the base? I love smaller 16 pro. Cause that is a nice upgrade. That's why I went max last year too.

It was like. It's nice to have a 5x zoom. Yeah.

Cherlynn: I love having the 5x zoom on the smaller phone. And that's one of the things I'm like really happy about with the lineup this year, because yeah, that's the reason I upgraded to the 15 [00:14:00] pro max upgraded, sacrifice my hands for the 15 pro max last year, because I wanted that 5x telephoto zoom.

This year I did most of my testing with the 16 pro and yeah, I mean, it compares pretty well with Google's, but I did a lot of my photography comparison and again, it's a pixel nine pro because. To me, that's the gold standard. Google is really a lot better at cleaning up mess at the higher level zoom and also Google just gives you a little bit more digital zoom.

So you can go up to 30 X with a combined telephoto and digital. Whereas on iPhone 16 pro or pro max, you go up to only 25 X. Google's image

Devindra: processing, I think it's a little better. The computational image processing.

Cherlynn: Yeah. If you,

Devindra: okay.

Ben: But let's talk about that for a second, because Devindra and I were talking like during the show planning meeting yesterday, that I'm looking at.

the side by side iPhone 16 and Pixel 9 Pro pictures in Cherlynn's review. [00:15:00] It's the image of the tree and the LED strip. It looks like it's in some kind of transit hub. And I know everyone says the Pixel 9 photos are so much better all the time, but to me, the picture from the 16 Pro looks so much more vibrant.

Is that just A me thing? Is that how I perceive colors versus other people? What's going on here?

Cherlynn: It could be. I will say that I did notice, in general, in general, right, and this has been for years now, I've noticed that pixel photography tends to be a little bit more muted compared to something from iPhone or Samsung phones.

Especially compared to Samsung phones. They tend to oversaturate a little bit. What Apple has tended to do in the past is I don't, I think this is just their color preference, but they give what they call, but I don't say they call it. It's just warmer, right? It looks warmer sometimes to the point of looking almost yellowish.

But yeah, their colors are a bit warmer and I think you can compare this to this. [00:16:00] this to the difference between a Nikon and a camera, a Canon camera in terms of the processing. Just like a

Devindra: tasteful aesthetic difference. Exactly.

Cherlynn: I think that's a preference or tasting, Ben. So I don't know that you're necessarily seeing it differently, but it could be a tasting, right?

The, the thing I do want to point out in that picture and also back to your point, Ben, one the picture on the left of the tree in, by the way, Moynihan train station, which is Penn station in Manhattan. Yeah. Okay. Is the, the one on the left, iPhone 16 pros picture is a little bit blurry. Right. And I think that's because I have been so focused on testing camera control that every single photo I took with it was with the button push.

Whereas like on the pixel pro, sometimes I would use the volume key trigger. Sometimes I would use the onscreen button. That's the way I normally use it in daily life anyway. So I think that some of that,

Ben: they would compensate for that. You would think,

Cherlynn: but I do, I don't think they did. So I think that the button push.

Definitely introduce shake. Deepak Murthy in the chat also asked a really good question. Is the 48 [00:17:00]megapixel Ultra wide. A big upgrade from last year. I don't know that I've been pixel peeping the ultra wide pictures, but I will say this reminds me of a fact that the 48 megapixel fusion camera on the iPhone 16 pro and pro max is wild.

Like I at first was like, they keep saying zero shutter lag, right? Apple has used this Phrase a lot. And this time it said zero shutter lag and said, it was like faster. So my dumb ass brain was like, Oh, does this mean I can take like photos of people, like moving around and then freeze motion and just take, right.

So I just doing that for a while. And I was like, none of them seem very like what I thought they were going to be. So I got our video producer for this review video, Brino. I was like, can you throw something at me? I'll, you know, catch it in midair. And then. All the photos that I was trying to take with the zero shutter lag environment, it was a cushion, something's off.

Devindra: That's what zero shutter lag is supposed to be. So, so hang on. So then I was like, okay,

Cherlynn: let's do that. And then I was like, why is it not working? So I, then I told Brian to do me throwing things around. So he took photos of me and [00:18:00]we were both like, All our pictures came out of us holding on to the thing and not of us throwing the things.

When I finally figured out what was happening, I was like, Oh, that's how fast the fusion camera is now. It's actually taking the photo when you press the camera on shutter button or trigger now, not, you know, a slight fraction of a second lag before the movement happens. So you actually don't have to like, the reason we were so like, Like catching not the movement we want it and so confused is because as people who have a lot of experience with cameras, Brian and I have trained ourselves to become like sensitive with the camera trigger timing, right?

If I know if something I want to capture is going to happen in the split second after I press the button, that's when I trigger it. That's how I time myself to press the button. And that's why our pictures were coming out a little too early. We were like, we were hitting the button, but instead we should have just waited till the thing was in midair to then press the button because that's how fast the camera

Devindra: is now.

Cherlynn: I didn't know, finally [00:19:00] figured it out. Felt really smart for a moment there.

Devindra: I think due to Deepak Murthy's question, the big upgrade is that before it was a 12 megapixel ultrawide, now it's a 48 megapixel ultrawide. So,

Cherlynn: and that enables. Yeah. Even more of that 2x zoom croppy situation that they talk about.

Devindra: It's also the thing where if you lean too much into a subject, like last year, it would just like shift to the, to like almost macro mode. Right. Right. Lose so much detail. If you want a high resolution photo, like then you have to fight that automatic process. That was annoying last year or so.

Cherlynn: Yeah.

Devindra: Yeah, less of a problem this year.

Cherlynn: And then my final note about colors here is, oh my God, how awesome our photographic style, photographic styles, photographic, photographic styles. Photographic

Devindra: styles. So

Cherlynn: awesome. So those let

Devindra: you choose different like color profiles and give you more finely tuned.

Stuff like just more tweaking on your photos. I, I want to point out like a couple of reviews also noted that they like the image processing of the 16 pros compared to the 15 pros. And I think this is kind of a common [00:20:00] complaint that a lot of iPhone users have been having is just that pictures look kind of flat sometimes because Apple's processing.

Tends to crush shadows and kind of like the depth of an image kind of goes away. So I noticed the Verge's review, they pointed this out a lot and I, a couple other folks did too, like you get, you can get better shadow control, better skin tone control, and you can leave

Cherlynn: it there, right? Like you can leave it, set it to your preferred and leave it.

So every photo you take then doesn't have to be edited. It comes out with your preferred shadow and contrast settings. Yeah. So here's, here's. To add my thoughts on that. When I discovered in my testing that photographic styles is freaking awesome. I was like, what happened? Your depth, your depth map just seems wildly improved.

And so what Apple does in general is every year. And I heard this last year too, actually, which is they, they, they work on their algorithm every year. They refine their depth map sensitivity, accuracy, this sort of stuff every year. This year, there seems to be a noted, marked. Improvement. And so in every single [00:21:00] photo even with last year with the 15 pros, when you take a photo that has a face inside Apple automatically takes like captures depth information.

So you might've seen that I've noticed this before when I'm like taking photos of myself and it suddenly switches to portrait mode. I'm like, I don't need a portrait mode picture. I just wanted a flat one, but then they want to capture depth information. And in using, in doing that this year with photographic styles, they're able to like, Maintain a person's face, skin tone, whatever.

Keep that a natural looking, as natural looking as possible, and then apply color changes and contrast changes and whatnot to the background. And it is wildly effective this year. And then the fact that you can. Set it, leave it, every single one of your photos will turn out that way. Or you can go in and post process and post and change it up.

There's just so many more controls and customizability options now that to me, that is actually the low key highlight this year. Things that like they've introduced, like photographic styles, you can leave alone and do nothing with, right? Action button, you can leave as your mute slider. The camera control.

If you don't like it, turn it off. [00:22:00]You have all these controls. I Apple doesn't make a big deal because I don't think it wants to market that you can turn off camera controls. But the fact that you can, and the fact that you can tweak its sensitivity as part of accessibility controls, is it's all adding to the idea that Apple is understanding that it needs to let users be able to change and choose what they want.

And to me, that's the most important thing with the iPhone 16s or just iPhones in general. I

Devindra: kind of wish some of that came down to the earlier phones. Like I know part of that is the image processing pipeline that there's a whole lot of new Hardaware in the 16s. scenes, but also you, you've got, you still got MPUs on these older phones.

Like there, there's some stuff you could still do. It sort of reminds me of the way people complain about like the way MCU movies look, right? The Marvel movies tend to look flat, don't really have much depth. You can almost feel the artificiality of like when they're on the the giant led screens, you know, when something doesn't feel real and then.

You shoot something in real life with real color depth and everything and shadow depth, and it [00:23:00]looks dramatically different. I guess that's sort of what people are noticing. So any, anything else you want to shout out about the, the iPhone pros or, or the base ones, Rowan?

Cherlynn: I mean, I agree with you that especially on photographic styles, they introduced it on the thirteens, right?

That's the first time it came out. And so it, it's not. But then the idea back then, I don't think was as fully fleshed out. So I don't think that back then they were capturing as much information. And I also had to wonder about storage size, right? Which brings me to the 4k 120 support on these pros with shooting 4k 120 content, you can slow things down a lot more for like way more dramatically slowed down and cinematic loading content as well as like HDR support in those.

situations. Of course, if you keep recording in those sort of high quality situations, you're going to run out of storage soon. And then speaking of video recording, I am, I was so excited for audio mix. I really was very excited for the ability to use that spatial [00:24:00]audio file that's recorded in all your videos now, and then kind of like drown out environmental noise or isolate and highlight the.

Voices of people speaking in the scene and frame in my admittedly limited testing so far, like the switch between standard and studio is the best. So you really just kind of get rid of a lot of ambient noise and make your, you know, subjects sound like they're talking in a podcast, like we are now.

Like my microphone is now Yeah,

Devindra: your microphone sounds great when trillin's like you're there in front of microphones turned on we're all we're all golden this week I do feel like um, yeah, you can certainly fill up even if you have a terabyte iphone I feel like If you're shooting 4k 120, you're going to be sucking up some space, but they are making it more so that you can record and shoot directly to storage devices.

So I can imagine I see so many of those like little rigs that people are putting together. Like you put your iPhone in there. It's also stabilizing rig. You could attach a microphone up top. But you could put a small SSD [00:25:00] there too. Like it is making the sort of Hey, you can have a little production studio built entirely around your iPhone and it'll cost a lot of money, but there are some users, certainly pro users that would be into that, you know?

So it's kind of, it's cool to have that. That's how they shot this. That that weekend video, right? Like with a rig a whole special thing, making him sing the song extra fast to slow down. That was fun.

Cherlynn: I think the idea of the iPhone 16 pros as like a, yeah, portable creator rig is a good way to think about them because a lot of the upgrades that at least drew my attention were for multimedia content creation.

Another thing that I was intrigued by, but that isn't available yet is the multi. Layer or multitrack recording on voice memos. And then speaking of features that are still not yet here that half step sort of lock focus feature on camera control isn't available yet. And then, of course, everything with Apple intelligence isn't fully available yet.

I think that. It is not the first time Apple's held back some marquee features at launch, but it is like, [00:26:00]it, it makes reviewing these things right now, the week that they go on sale a little trickier than usual. You will see the note on our review cards with about the score that we had to review them as is, and as is they, They seem to score lower than last year which I think is very fair.

I think especially, I actually had to flip the position of the pro and the pro max this year, just because the battery life to me was that much significantly lower. I, I actually almost dinged it quite a few more points and then was convinced to be like, okay, A bit more, a bit less angry about battery life.

I mean, it's a

Devindra: fair comparison, but I do, I do want to know, like people like me who used to hate the Pro Max phones, like the titanium change last year was a huge difference. Like 10 to 15 percent change is noticeable. And if you care that much about battery life, it is still probably worth going for the big phone.

I also find myself. I don't know about you Cherlynn, but I also I'm watching stuff like often in picture in picture mode at night while I'm cleaning up the kitchen and stuff like, or [00:27:00]while I'm just like browsing Twitter at night to like the ability to multifunction more on a bigger screen phone.

I see it. I see the point of that. You can't do that as much on the smaller 16 pro.

Cherlynn: Yeah, I, I like being able to reach across the screen and hit something all the way on the other side anyways, as a person cursed with smaller hands, I think the smaller one is the ideal size for me. However, I might, I, I, I have this odd luxury of being able to carry two phones, right?

So maybe I'll just Carry both the Pixel 9 Pro and the iPhone 16 Pro. Now, a lot of people have asked me this, actually. Am I tempted to go back to Pixel? I am. I am very tempted by the Pixel 9 Pro. We did score it as of right now, a little higher than the iPhone 16 Pro. And trust me that that factored into my scoring decision.

I think. The competition from Google is stiffer than ever, is extremely stiff this year. I am in love with pixel UI, I've been for a very long [00:28:00] time. Especially on the call screening, especially on some of the call assist features. For some reason Google really understands how to do that stuff. I think, like I wrote in my review, it's not that Apple is not considering these things, it's that Apple is extremely cautious.

Apple's more sensitive to being caught with egg on its face, perhaps, whereas Google's probably we can just say, sorry, and Apple's more, let's not. Nobody's buying these

Devindra: phones anyway. Nobody will notice. That's what Google's thinking. Nobody's buying these Pixel phones. I don't

Cherlynn: know. I, I think it's, I think Google is a bit more a bit less risk averse.

And I, I get that vibe from the like Silicon Valley area in general.

Devindra: It does, it does come down to there, there were reports people are pointing to the flight tracker. You know, site is now tracking like the, the planes filled with iPhones coming to employee to, to customers, those planes have billions of dollars worth a single plane has billions of dollars of phones worth on them.

And it's that is the function. That's why Apple has to be safe. Whereas [00:29:00] for Google. How much of a percentage of Google's revenue are Pixel phones?

Cherlynn: I get that. I get, I get that like it's not a huge part of their revenue. Yeah, it's definitely not as significant. I will say to, to Apple's credit though, that like I said in my review, it's more careful.

And its approach tends to be more well rounded. So when it comes to things like call screening or call related, anything that's a little bit to do with personal private context things, Apple is slow. And I think reasonably so I think it's okay to like. Take your time before you sick your AI on restaurants, calling them about opening hours.

That sort of thing. Apple is not going to do that ever. I think it's wild that Google is able to, and I think there is helpful executions there too, but I don't know that every single person would be as happy to embrace that. So it's fine that they have two very different approaches. I just think that And that's why maybe I have to have two phones, right?

One company is

Devindra: afraid of actively [00:30:00] harming society with new features that call, that have robots calling, you know, restaurants and the others just taking it slow. But I

Cherlynn: will say that, I will say that my, my desire to carry both of them nowadays has less to do with camera. Because it used to be I carried a pixel phone around because it was just so much better for for my photos and now it's It's it's actually battery life and a little bit on like pixel call UI.

Oh, yeah I chatted with a friend on RCS for the first time yesterday and that was cool. Shout out to my friend who knows who they are who was on Android and we were texting and it was, it said text message RCS. You know how if you send green bubble messages, it says text message SMS. And now it says, Text message RCS, and now it's freaking out, and then we could have back messages.

Devindra: It should be a rainbow bubble, like RCS, the thing unifying all the, all the different platforms. I

Cherlynn: think that would be a bit too ally for Apple to do.

Devindra: Allyship?

Cherlynn: Yeah,

Devindra: [00:31:00] it would be, it would be nice

Cherlynn: if they did, but no, I don't think they would, it would, the implication is kind of weird Also hate that, because of that, we

Devindra: can't use rainbows anymore in certain things.

That's dumb.

Cherlynn: You can still use rainbows. I don't think it matters. It just, I'm glad,

Devindra: I'm glad you're able to do an RCS chat because we have talked about that for years. There was also the news that the RCS the group is now considering a way to make encryption happening, so that's cool. Can I,

Cherlynn: can I just explain this a little bit?

So, when we, when this came out and made the rounds this week that RCS the GSMA was working on our end to end encryption for RCS. the universal profile, which is what Apple said it would adopt for iOS 18. And to be clear, there's different profiles of RCS. The base one was the one that like Apple resisted forever because it was just not very secure.

It allowed businesses to text you with no reason. And there's just a lot of issues with it. Universal profile comes closer. When Apple announced it would support RCS, it did make a It's very clear that like end to end [00:32:00] encryption, it would work with the GSMA to bring end to end encryption to RCSUP before it fully embraced iOS 18 RCS and iOS 18.

So it's not completely new, like you said, Devindra, that like we knew end to end encryption was coming and that's why we were Apple

Devindra: says that they were going to work on it and now, now they, GSMA had to put out an announcement. Hey, we're doing it. We're doing it, baby. I

Cherlynn: mean, they're working on it, but is it news?

Not really. I mean, it's, it's, it has to come.

Devindra: They're doing it also Google

Cherlynn: messages. Yeah. But also Google messages had already, like Google had already implemented E2EE in its own Google message version of RCS UP, which is like a UP with a number, I believe So anyway come at me with

all your RCS nerdery, because apparently this is how much I know about it.

Devindra: Yeah. RCS message Cherlynn if you can find her. How about that? Anything else you want to mention about the phones? Cause I do want to talk a little bit about the Apple Watch Series 10. Yeah. That is the thing. That got all the big changes this year. And we just spent half an hour talking about a fricking camera button.

So come on, I

Cherlynn: mean, I feel like there's more on the phone that I'm forgetting. Just go read [00:33:00] my review. It's like very

Devindra: long, very nice reviews.

Cherlynn: Yeah. And, and the video on our YouTube channel as well. What's up? What's about okay. When you say the watch got all the big changes this year, what are you referring?

It

Devindra: has a new, it has a new design. It is much bigger. Like it is fundamentally a bigger TV. different feeling device. You noted that in your review, you know,

Cherlynn: it does feel different. It feels thinner every time I pick it up when it's not on my wrist, when I pick it up to enter the password or look at the charge level, I feel it in my, in between my fingers, it feels thinner and different.

But the, and especially compared to the series nine, which I've been using since it was launched last year, the screens a little bit wider angle viewing. wider viewing angle. And, and, and, and, and that's about it, right? I mean, what else is like the, the, the battery life for being thinner is very similar still to the Series 9.

In fact, sometimes I actually got a lot more battery life out of the Series 10. It, [00:34:00] I still couldn't replicate that on a consistent, in a consistent way. So I don't know Absolutely true that the Apple Watch Series 10 lasts longer than the Series 9. But yeah, I think it's impressive that the technology they were able to come up with to reach that thinner frame.

And the wider angle. I didn't notice the huge Here's the thing, right? When you're testing two watches side by side, y'all come to the Engadget Podcast for this sort of great interview. You're just deadened

Devindra: to all the changes moving forward, right? Well, a little bit,

Cherlynn: but here's what I was trying to do, right?

I had both watches on each of my wrists, and I was putting them down sort of on my lap to kind of see whether that wider viewing angle makes that huge of a difference. And I'm like, yeah, the one on the left, which is the Series 10, certainly looks like I can see it. Like the clock digits are brighter from that angle and, and more easy to see, whereas the right hand, which was the Series 9 was harder to read.

But you know what the difference was? Partly, yes, brightness. But the other part of it was the locks, the watch face. [00:35:00] Somehow when your AOD is dimmed in on both watches, you're always on display is dimmed. The watch. digits on the Series 9, which to be clear was on watchOS 10, not 11 went into this outline instead of a solid font.

So the font was just, and of course that's going to be harder to read, whereas like on the Series 10, which was running watchOS 11, when the AOD dimmed, the clock digits maintained their solid structure. So the font basically went from a fully filled solid digits situation to stroke only that sort of thing.

So if you know, graphic design, maybe you understand what I'm saying. And that contributes to it. Right. And then I'm not able to then confidently say that, you know, This is certainly a brighter screen at an off angle. I, I have to be like part of the visibility has to do with the fact that the font's different.

So I don't know. I, I, I didn't get into the detail there. But you're here, you're, you're here, you are privy to my inner most fonts. Okay. Okay. Podcast.

Devindra: Even, [00:36:00] even like the, the minimal design changes to the series 10 is more than the, than the phones got. Is the thing. Slightly thinner, slightly bigger.

I mean a whole

Cherlynn: new button. Look, the whole new button.

Devindra: Plus

Cherlynn: the fact that the screens are bigger, plus the fact that therefore the iPhone 15 Pros are just a little bit bigger than their predecessors means you have to get a whole new case, by the way. Yeah,

Devindra: it's mainly the buttons. You have to get the whole new case.

Cherlynn: Well, no, the cases won't fit. I asked and it was like, no, you need new cases even without the buttons. Of course.

Ben: Every year you need a new case. And that difference, the Oh, this is a little bit bigger so you need to get a whole new case and the fact that we spent so much time talking about a button is why all the other kids make fun of us.

Cherlynn: Who's us and who's the other kids? Sorry.

Ben: All of the Android people make fun of us. I consider

Cherlynn: myself an Android kid too,

Devindra: don't us and them, me. I [00:37:00] am a bother. From one phone generation to the next like that is just like a given because things change button placements change camera Modules change, so I'm not gonna knock Apple too much on that.

But you know,

Ben: meanwhile What was Apple talking about so much during that event? We're gonna be carbon neutral by this time. What is it? 2030 not that long. They are by not

Devindra: including the wired buds anymore

Cherlynn: Fiber Kate packaging

Devindra: fiber you can eat that box Yeah,

Cherlynn: if you're having digestive issues if you

Devindra: want to, so it doesn't sound like you're super hot on the, the watch series.

It

Cherlynn: was hard for me to be excited because again, a lot of the marquee features are things you have to wait a little longer to figure out sleep, but we're not waiting

Devindra: for apple intelligence on that. We're not waiting for no, several months. Like we were watch. Yeah,

Cherlynn: we were during the review process waiting on the sleep apnea thing to be FDA green lit, but it did during the [00:38:00] review process.

And so it was like the day or two before that was like, Oh yeah, you can set up sleep apnea now. And to be clear, like we, we had more than a few days with sleep apnea, but, but it was like, Two days before the watch or the day before the watch review was supposed to go up, that sleep apnea came out with watchOS 11.

Did

Devindra: you, so did you do your sleep apnea test? No, because

Cherlynn: not only, I did, I did set it up. I set it up for the alerts. Right. And then, and I did that on the Monday that iOS 18 was pushed out because even though the FDA Greenlight announcement was on Friday. The iOS 18, watchOS 11, blah, blah, blah, update all came out to the public on Monday with the sleep apnea thing.

And then on watchOS 11, that's when you can get it right. And you can get the sleep apnea tracking on watch series nine as well as watch ultra two. So even if I had tested was like a big deal, it was not going to super affect my score because you can get it on an older watch. Like it's not, a huge part of the upgrade [00:39:00] equation, but also I had one night to put this thing on and you need to like sleep with it for

Devindra: 30 nights.

We're gonna need an update on how much you snore and what your sleep breathing is like. Yeah.

Cherlynn: That's what, that's what has to

Devindra: happen. Yeah.

Cherlynn: So basically I think this sort of device and this sort of feature is something we want to spend more time with anyway. So yeah, just come back. Twingadget. com to see if I'm still alive and testing sleep apnea and breathing at night.

Devindra: It is hard to review something that is also meant to track data for several days, like to do that with under a week, you know, so you did, you did what you could. And also given the restrictions Apple placed on us by not having everything fully approved. So anyway, it sounds, it sounds cool. Go check out Shroen's review.

Do you have a video of the Apple watch as well?

Cherlynn: We do not because that would have required shooting on Sunday when I was editing the AirPods review, so no. I mean,

Devindra: you're, it never ends. It never ends. And we're still waiting on the iPhone review. So, you know, that's another thing. They're coming!

Cherlynn: You can consider this my iPhone review, whatever the early [00:40:00]part of this episode was.

That was mine. There is a proper written version. So we know

Devindra: nobody reads anymore. Sherilyn like this is the future of all of our content. And anyway, folks, thank you so much, Sherilyn. If you got any thoughts or questions about the new iPhones and the new Apple watch, drop us an email at podcast and engadget.

com.

Let's move on to some other news and sorry folks that we're running through these stories kind of quickly. We're just, we're just so gadget heavy. We've got so many reviews to talk about. Is that time of

Cherlynn: year?

Devindra: Yeah. One thing I want to bring up is just a wild occurrence that happened on Tuesday and Wednesday.

I started seeing news reports Tuesday morning that pagers were exploding throughout Lebanon and that seemed weird. Like we saw the earlier reports were like, huh. That's, that's strange. Pagers are exploding. Then more reports, thousands of pagers are exploding. Then more and more reports. Basically I think by maybe not by the end of Tuesday, but there were [00:41:00] several waves of pager attacks, or at least one, that first major wave of pager attacks.

What we ended up learning is that likely it was Israel targeting members of the Hezbollah militant group in Lebanon by their pagers. And I'm not going to get too deep into the politics of this all, but just that idea, I don't know what you thought of the Sherwin, but I was thinking like, Oh my God, we've reached like enemy of the state level, weird attack vectors that would sound like science fiction just a couple of years ago.

So that is, that is where we're at. This is like a live, ongoing story on Wednesday, another wave of attacks happened on walkie talkies. because I guess the plan was not to just hit pagers again because people stopped using their pagers. There are reports that solar panel you know, installations throughout Lebanon were attacked as well.

This is all in response to like other attacks that were happening from Hezbollah towards you know, people living in Israel and and like areas throughout that country too. So wild. I don't [00:42:00]know. What did you think, Sherilyn, like when you heard of this?

Cherlynn: I mean, I'll give you 10 to guess what my immediate thought was it was the same as what CF 542 is saying in our chat.

I was shocked that pagers were still being used. I think

Devindra: Listen, if you are if you are currently a member of a militant group and you know Your opponent is like highly technically capable. You're like I can't have a smartphone

Cherlynn: I can't have things that they

Devindra: can hack, you know,

Cherlynn: right. So when you were recapping that, I, I, I, my brain made the connection.

Well, I mean, I kind of knew this, which is like you said. Yeah. A lot of people use lower technology devices to avoid surveillance or detection. Things like burner phones tend to be a little more simple pagers. And you mentioned walkie talkies and solar panels. It was interesting to me how it is. These would appear to be like less sophisticated, more analog devices that were being targeted.

And things not connected to the internet. Right, exactly. You would, right. It's even harder. So it's you would think that internet is the more hackable sort of technology because [00:43:00]it's more communication availability. But no, it's these things that are just chilling along on, I guess, radio waves for a lot of them especially walkie talkies and what, pagers.

Devindra: Yeah. And the, the actual we're still like, this is an ongoing story. The full extent to like how the explosive devices got into the pagers and into the walkie talkies, Is the whole thing because the company behind the pagers is apparently a Taiwan based thing, but they were like, we did not manufacture those.

And then people tracked it to a company in in Turkey that was building devices. And they were like, Oh, we didn't build those either. So it's like, where did these come from? How did these get into the supply chain? But also I think it was also like subcontractors

Ben: on subcontractors

Devindra: upon. So, so, but how do you, how do you get to people outside of hacking a good internet connected device?

We have heard stories like I am. I. Like to read the stories about like how real life spies do their work. And there's a lot of stories about what Russia has done and what Russian spies have done, like the poisoning of people in broad daylight throughout throughout England. That's something Russia is known for.

This is just like wild and I [00:44:00]guess there are two arguments. It's, it's a little more targeted than like missile attacks, but also these things were exploding in public spaces. Children were killed. Thousands of people were injured. The latest total I saw is 25 people were killed, 600 injured. This is just like one of those things where it's I don't.

You don't know what's safe anymore when these devices, these devices that you think are just dumb and silly can just explode at any moment. So, terrifying.

Ben: Yeah, and the politics of this situation is really difficult to get into, so we'll mostly try to sidestep that. I'm feeling for the Lebanese population right now.

This is like pure stochastic

Devindra: terrorism, basically, but yeah.

Ben: From the perspective of gadget people, we love our devices. We use our devices to relax. The idea that you are afraid to touch your device now, because you don't know what's been tampered with and what hasn't been tampered with. The idea that there are families who are completely unaffected and, you know, not Affiliated with Hezbollah at all are maybe putting all of their [00:45:00]devices out in the yard a good distance away from the house because they're afraid of them now, that

Devindra: sucks.

People are afraid to use their computers, any of their other devices, like it's just, this is a weird situation.

Cherlynn: Do y'all see how many phones I held up just now?

Devindra: Yeah, you are, you are quite the, the attack vector right now, Cherlynn. I mean, listen, I have like right behind me, people who can see me on camera.

Like I have a lot of old devices that I need to certainly electronically recycle because I'm worried about what happens to old lithium batteries. And so that's not even worrying about an attack like this. We will be keeping an eye on the story. This is like all ongoing stuff, but I wanted to mention it because this is directly.

I've never seen a military or I've never seen like a specific attack against a military opponents like this. And philosophically, like as somebody who thinks about like how we wage war and how innocents are touched and all this stuff, it is deeply, deeply troubling. We're going to move on to just some strange, like straight up gadget [00:46:00]stuff.

So let's just laugh at snaps. Fifth generation spectacles. How about that? Look at poor Chrisabelle, who did this coverage for us, has had to take pictures of herself wearing these God awful looking augmented reality glasses. These are standalone AR glasses. They're going to be sold to developers who commit to a yearlong 99 a month subscription to start working on AR apps, I guess, similar to what Apple did with Vision Pro, except it's not being sold to normal people at all.

Because I think if people saw the real cost of these things if you had to put a dollar to it, you would probably laugh Snapchat off the face of the planet. Like these would probably cost four to 5, 000 a pair, given the level of technology in them. Thoughts on these Cherlynn?

Cherlynn: I mean, I think they looked weird AF until I watched the Emmys last night.

And I was like, wow, I guess Eugene Levy is wearing the same sort of glasses. The same style glasses, right? They were these very thick black frames that are extremely boxy, especially [00:47:00]near the temples. And I think Carissa got a little roasted on the threads.

Ben: But those actually

Cherlynn: looked good. What?

Ben: But they actually looked good.

The older ones look better. These just look chunky.

Cherlynn: So, okay. To be clear though, the new, the ones now are AR glasses. They have a display in them. I believe the older Snap Spectacles are just camera toting glasses. No, the ones so the

Ben: last picture And I'm also talking about Eugene Levy's glasses.

Eugene Levy's

Cherlynn: ones are great. They're the Prada or Dior ones, so

Ben: Yeah, they were fashion glasses. I was thinking, okay, these look very chunky. Fashion glasses tend to look chunky. I literally just looked up. Glasses designed by like Terry Mugler or, you know, house of Mugler, like very high fashion sort of stuff.

Mugler is known specifically for kind of sci fi looking outfits. Zendaya actually wore a like whole suit of armor designed by Mugler. This is a really

Cherlynn: strange tangent. We're going down. Like I am here for it,

Devindra: but

Ben: these glasses, yeah. [00:48:00] These. The Mugler glasses actually look good. They are chunky.

They take up so much of your face. Go look them up on your own. These just look bad. I mean,

Devindra: I'm specifically comparing them to the last pair Carissa tested Trillin. So I think that was the fourth one. And those did have AR display. She did do a test of that. So this is not just the camera ones that they were selling.

But,

Cherlynn: yeah.

Devindra: My point was

Cherlynn: just going to be that like, we're not going to review this thing obviously. They're not selling it. But I can't wait for us to take a look. A deeper dive into them. We will be doing that. We just won't be reviewing, reviewing. We will be reviewing it. I

Devindra: think we are fully well within our rights to point and laugh at how silly this all looks.

And next week we're going to hear about Meta's you know, concept AR glasses. So that's Orion and the sort of like tease photo. We saw those things, which was in the background of one of Zuckerberg's photos earlier this year. Those just look like chunky hipster frames. And maybe those aren't like fully the things, but at least those look more like glasses than whatever the [00:49:00] hell is happening here.

Like I couldn't, I couldn't help it laugh, but Chris has done some great coverage for us to go check out her story on this stuff briefly. I also want to point out, I wrote about the Vive Focus Vision. HTC Vive is still making VR headsets and this is their latest standalone headset. It's 9. 99. It's interesting because they're, they have better cameras for mixed reality.

And also they have a cool. An accessory, a display port accessory that you can buy. It's like 150. It gives you a direct connection to your computer for connected wired VR. And that is different compared to what Oculus link did or the metal link does on Meta's headsets. When you plug into a PC, you're basically seeing a video feed of what a VR window is seeing on your computer.

By going directly to the graphics card, you're not getting any of that distortion or anything. So this functions more like a traditional VR headset. It looks cool, feels cool. Hope to do a fuller review of this thing, but I also don't, no one's going to buy this. This is 9. is selling these headsets [00:50:00] to businesses and they are doing a good job of that.

But, you know, they're not competing with the meta quest at, you know, 400 and 500. These things are just so much more expensive. We also saw the news that Lionsgate, the movie studio has signed a deal with runway, the AI startup. So that the, let me see here. It will allow runway access to Lionsgate content their library in exchange for a fresh custom AI model that the studio can use in production and editing.

That can mean all sorts of things, but I know among Hollywood, among artists, actors, and directors, like this is the AI encroachment in movie making. is something that people are afraid of. Maybe there's a way that they could use it. That is like a non harmful way, like a simpler way. Hey, listen, I've used AI to plug in one word into a podcast episode where it's I don't, I can't match the voice to retake it.

But if I type the word here and I train this thing on my voice, and it's a local model that I fully control it can replicate a word for me. That makes my life a little easier. Maybe they can [00:51:00]do that, but it's tough for artists. Tough to manage that.

Cherlynn: Yeah. I will say that as of six or seven years ago at 1MWC, there was a tool like that online somewhere that allowed you to create like voice models for of people.

And so me, Matt Smith, and I think Aaron Supor is playing with this. We created voice models of each other. And so I made Matt Smith's fake voice say, Japan, Japan, Japan. And I really recall this very strongly. Here's the thing, though. I will also mention that it's not specific or unique to AI, right? To be able to do this, because I will give you another behind the scenes tidbit that our iPhone 16 review video, there was a moment where I made the mistake and said, the iPhone 15 pros battery life sucks or something along those lines.

And I was like, crap, I meant the iPhone 16 pro and our video editor, Ryan Oh, was able to cook up some magic and find a bit where I said the word. Yeah. And just replace it correctly. So that's

Devindra: normal editing using your normal [00:52:00] voice. It's normal

Cherlynn: editing. Editing, but you're also able to like, you know, being able to get a model of my voice to say the correct words Seems useful to me in in situations like that for post processing, but I can see how it raises concerns of who has control Like you said over who has control i'm

Devindra: sure actors are worried writers are worried about what words they can inject in things we will be keeping an eye on the story for sure.

Ben: I have one kind of easy prediction to make about this. That Runway will develop some kind of internal tool for Lionsgate. Lionsgate will push this very much on their editors and all of their workers. They'll be like, use the internal tool, use the internal tool. They will make a big deal about how one movie used the internal tool and then we'll never hear about it again.

Devindra: I hope so. I hope, I hope that's what it is. But I also know like executives and a lot of basically studio executives cannot wait to stop paying money to actors and writers. Like they just want to like, get [00:53:00]stuff out there to start selling movie tickets or whatever. So yeah, we will see the, the, all these tools can be useful in the right hands.

We are worried about the right hands. Let's Cherlynn?

Cherlynn: I, this weekend. So, and I was very excited to share this on this podcast. I was like telling the team, I have to be here for this. Have you heard of the film Speak No Evil?

Devindra: Yes. Oh, you saw the new one.

Cherlynn: I saw the new one. The, the one with James McAvoy, who is just so menacing in it.

The reviews. said that he's perfected the art of being menacing and they are so right. He is horrifying and such a scary and like the, the way, okay, so this film is about this family meeting or running into another family consisting of James McAvoy, his parents. wife and their child in italy somewhere and then that they hit it off the james mcavoy invites them over to stay at their countryside place For a weekend [00:54:00]and again some of their you know, better instincts They they do do it and then it turns out this is the like strangest family ever No spoilers, but I think you can see where it's headed.

I think Though that the entire experience was really illuminating for me because some of the, the altercations they get into are so reminiscent of like my real life where you do interact with people who just say shit for no reason sometimes, right? on the internet, in the real world. Like people sometimes say shit and then they go, Oh, sorry.

Sorry that you misunderstood what I said, or, Oh, sorry. I didn't mean it that way. Oh, PC. Oh, woke. Like people who use that sort of like labels to defend bad behavior. And you have a lot of that. And so I spent a lot of the movie because I didn't guess the ending. I spent a lot of the movie wondering if.

They were actually like bad, bad, or if they were just unintentional bad, right? And that's me because I'm, I'm the sort of person that gaslights myself. But that's, that's what happens. I think that the [00:55:00] way the actors played it was really nuanced and that's why I was led to that belief. But also the, the, just the whole telling of the story was so like masterful.

The tension never lets up. It's just, it's great. It's really cool. I'm glad I really enjoyed it.

Devindra: I would recommend Trillin. That you watch the original movie, which is mostly in English too, but it's more about the difference. I believe it's like the difference between like Danish culture and Finnish culture and how they can be like slightly different, but also that original movie.

is horrifying. It is so bleak. It is one of the bleakest things I've ever seen. And what I've heard is that the American version, this one's

Cherlynn: pretty bleak too, but yeah, I've

Devindra: heard it doesn't go as far as the original does. And I don't, I don't like the ending of the original. I think it's a deeply disturbing movie, but that was a movie about.

our society of politeness, right? Where somebody says something weird and you're like, Oh, okay. Well, I'm a guest. So I'm just gonna roll with it. Right. It's the same thing. It's the same [00:56:00]story. Yeah. It's also about like how hard it is to make friends as adults because that original movie was just like this like yuppie couple with the kid is I, how do we, how do we hang out with people?

Oh, this, this couple seems nice. I think both these movies sound like the in why you do not make friends on vacation. You meet somebody you meet a couple you meet you meet people on vacation. They're not last let it go. Yeah Yeah, they're temporary friends. Yeah, let it go. Do not visit their houses. Do not do anything I'm looking forward to seeing this movie Cherlynn.

I can't

Cherlynn: wait till you see it. Tell me how you think it

Devindra: is It is fun to see Scoot McNary and Mackenzie Davis. Yes, like normal couple. This is a this is a halting catchfire reunion A show I've told all of you who've been listening to watch forever. They both co star in that show. That's an amazing show for techies.

It's about the sort of like PC building world in Texas in the eighties. It's a lot of fun. It's like mad men, but also far, far geekier. So check that out. Well, I'm glad you like anything else you want to try out Cherlynn.

Cherlynn: I cancelled my Hulu subscription, [00:57:00] so, there you go. They, they, I, I thought I was being scammed when I got an email from Hulu at HuluMail.

com, which just sounded like the worst email in the world. But they were like, price is increasing soon, like 20 basically for a no ad subscription. I was like, what the hell, I'm not doing that. Plus, I also have Disney Plus. So I'm like, I get quite a lot of the same library with that.

Devindra: Yeah, it's, it's so very confusing, what is, is, It is still very

Cherlynn: confusing, yeah.

So for me, I'm like, let's cancel it and see what's gonna happen. But yeah, I mean, I, I, my, my Disney Plus subscription is annual, and my Hulu one is monthly. So I just canceled the monthly one first and see how that goes. All right. Since I can't cancel Disney Plus. Good luck. And then, well, yeah my, my recommendation is if it works out, I'll tell you that to go with Disney Plus instead of Hulu and Disney.

Devindra: Gotcha. Have you checked out Agatha all along yet? I feel like that's in your I have not. I

Cherlynn: saw it on yeah, I haven't seen it yet, but it's on my list.

Devindra: I saw the first few episodes. It's, it's fun. It's fun more mostly because Aubrey Plaza gets to be fun. Oh, yeah! I saw that. Give me a witchy Aubrey Plaza, please.

She is [00:58:00] fantastic in that show. And

Cherlynn: the gay splosion I heard,

Devindra: I want to recommend you folks, I've talked about Pachinko before, which is the Apple TV plus show based on the novel about this sort of sweeping tale of a Korean family from leaving Korea to immigrating to Japan throughout the 1900s.

And also it occurs across different time periods. I started watching season two. This show is still incredible. It looks fantastic. Just incredibly well written. It's just like deeply emotional. I love seeing very, very complex, very far reaching immigrant tales. And this is one of those, Sherilyn, I think you really got to watch this show because it will destroy you.

It is just so fascinating. So yeah. Loving Pachinko Season 2. Also Season 2 has a new opening dance sequence, which became a big hit. with the first season. Still good. I don't think it hits the same highs for me as the Pachinko season one opening, but still very good. Also quickly want to shout out Lego Star Wars Rebuild the Galaxy, which is a Lego Star Wars thing.

My daughter saw a picture of this and she was like, we got to watch this. I don't know what's happening [00:59:00]here. I have not fully gotten her into any Star Wars stuff. We've tried the Clone Wars cartoons and They're really slow. Like it's really tough for her to get into. I'm not going to do the movies.

The original movies just take forever to get started. Maybe when she was like eight or 10, she can survive those things, but she loved Lego Star Wars, rebuilt the galaxy. It's a funny, you know, Lego variant of this thing, but also does something that I don't think Star Wars will ever be able to do, which is completely break and rebuild the entire mythology.

Like at the, you know, In the first episode, they just completely rework it's sort of like a what if thing. They just rework who are the good guys? Who are the bad guys? What happened here? How did key events happen? It's just completely different and they're going to run with this timeline. A lot of good guys become bad.

You may see this in the poster, but a Darth Jar Jar Binks. Is a thing and he is hilarious. Like he's not, he's, he's a dark, he's a sip. But he's also silly and bumbling. And my daughter thinks he's hilarious every time he falls on his face. So it's just, it has a lot of fun with star Wars mythology, a lot of deep cuts in there.

And I think it's fun if you've got [01:00:00]kids who cannot. really pay attention to the little, the, the Star Wars stuff that takes a little, you know, more to get into. I think this is like perfect. Okay. So check it out. Lego Star Wars rebuild the galaxy.

Cherlynn: Well, that's it for the episode this week, everyone.

Thank you as always for listening. Our theme music is by game composer Dale North. Our outro music is by our former managing editor, Terrence O'Brien. The podcast is produced by Ben Elman. You can find the Vindro. At

Devindra: Davindra on Twitter, Mastodon, Blue Sky, all over the place. And I podcast about movies and TV at The Filmcast, thefilmcast.

com. Oh, also I did a Twit. I did This Week in Tech this week. So go check out the latest episode at twit. tv.

Cherlynn: If you want to tell me what your favorite photographic style is. So I can use it on more selfies of me send them to me. I am at Cherlynn low on X or at Cherlynn, Instagram, C H E R L Y N N S T A G R A M on threads, email us your thoughts at podcast at engadget.

com. Leave us a [01:01:00]review, please, on whatever podcast platform you're listening on and subscribe wherever you get podcasts.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/mobile/smartphones/engadget-podcast-reviewing-the-iphone-16-and-apple-watch-series-10-113033805.html?src=rss

HTC Vive’s Focus Vision is a $999 stab at high-end VR and mixed reality

HTC Vive is following up its intriguing, yet expensive, XR Elite headset with something that's still quite pricey, the $999 Focus Vision. Built on the same platform as the standalone Vive Focus 3, the upgraded model adds a slew of new features like built-in eye tracking, 16MP stereo color front-facing cameras for mixed reality and automatic IPD adjustment (which makes it easier to share). And with the additional $149 DisplayPort wired streaming kit, gamers can also hook the Focus Vision up to their PCs for more intensive VR experiences.

Judging from the price and features alone, the Focus Vision isn't much of a mainstream consumer play from HTC Vive. But that's to be expected. While Meta has poured tens of billions into making its Quest headsets cheaper and more accessible, without any need to worry about profitability, HTC Vive has leaned towards making more expensive headsets better suited for business and government work. The Focus 3, for example, made its way to the International Space Station to help astronauts exercise and relax.

While the Vive XR Elite looked almost like a pair of over-sized glasses, the Focus Vision doesn't look much different than the Focus 3. It's clearly a standard VR headset, albeit one a step above the Meta Quest 3, a device mostly made of cheaper plastic and other low-grade materials. There's plenty of cushioning along the front headset and rear head strap, and there's more than enough room to fit large glasses.

Under the hood, the Vive Focus Vision features a 5K LCD display, delivering a 2.5K resolution per eye, a 90Hz refresh rate and a wide 120-degree field of view. (HTC says it'll gain 120Hz support over DisplayPort later this year.) In addition to the two 16MP front-facing cameras, which are positioned like human eyes for distortion-free mixed reality, there's also an infra-red flood light for hand tracking in low light, four external tracking cameras and the usual depth sensor.

Once again, HTC has stuck a removable battery pack in the headset's rear strap, but now there's also a small built-in battery offering an additional 20 minutes of standby charge. That means you can swap battery packs without shutting down the headset and leaving your VR immersion. That feature alone could be compelling to organizations where employees will have to wear the Focus Vision for hours on end. HTC claims the headset can last for two hours of continuous use.

HTC Vive Focus Vision
HTC Vive

With the Vive Focus Vision, HTC is also making a play for high-end VR gaming. While Meta's Quest headsets can connect to gaming PCs wirelessly and with USB-C cables, they're essentially delivering a compressed video feed of VR experiences from those system. The Focus Vision's DisplayPort kit functions more like a standard PC VR headset: It gives you a direct connection to your computer's video card. You shouldn't see any of the lag or compression artifacts that you occasionally do with Meta Quest to PC connections.

As I expected, the Focus Vision feels very similar to the Focus 3. It's easy to put on adjust, there's more than enough room for my glasses to fit, and the front and rear cushioning helps it rest comfortably on my noggin. Thanks to the rear battery pack, the headset also feels well-balanced on my head. Other headsets, even Apple's Vision Pro, can feel front-heavy and place pressure on your nose and eyes.

HTC Vive Focus Vision
HTC Vive

When it comes to the actual VR experience, the Focus Vision delivers what I'd expect from an expensive HTC Vive headset. The 5K display is sharp enough to read small text, and its large field of view makes wandering around locations in Nature Treks VR feel genuinely immersive. I haven't had much of a chance to try PC gaming just yet, but I'm looking forward to delving into that for our review. 

I'm still disappointed by the limited selection of apps in the VivePort store, but once again this isn't a device that needs to cater much to general VR users. Companies relying on the Focus Vision will either use existing enterprise apps or build something for themselves. And gamers likely won't spend much time outside of the wired DisplayPort connection, where they can access the full bounty of their SteamVR libraries.

The Vive Focus Vision is available for pre-order today for $999 ($1,299 for businesses with an additional warranty) until October 17. HTC will also throw in the DisplayPort kit free for early adopters, and there are also three game bundles to choose from. 

Update 9/18 10:55PM: HTC Vive has extended the pre-order window from September 30 to October 17. We've updated the post to reflect that.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/ar-vr/htc-vives-focus-vision-is-a-999-stab-at-high-end-vr-and-mixed-reality-120054049.html?src=rss

Microsoft 365 Copilot users can collaborate with AI and each other in BizChat Pages

While it's unclear if mainstream PC users are actually using Microsoft's Copilot AI, the company claims that businesses using MS 365 Copilot are seeing plenty of benefits. According to a Microsoft survey, Copilot users at Honeywell save up to 92 minutes per week, while customer service agents at Teladoc are saving up to five hours a week by using the AI tool to draft responses to questions. Now that we're a year beyond the MS 365 Copilot launch (at a costly $30 per seat), Microsoft is eager to throw more AI features at corporate drones.

Most intriguingly, Microsoft is upgrading its Business Chat app, which so far has been a way to interact with Copilot's across your emails, calendar entries and other data, alongside data from your organization. Now it's getting better collaboration with the addition of Copilot Pages, which will serve as a sort of "multiplayer" way to share AI generated content with your coworkers.

Microsoft Copilot 365: Copilot Pages
Copilot Pages in BizChat.
Microsoft

"With Pages, all the data in your organization — whether created by humans or AI — is persistent, accessible and valuable," Microsoft CVP Jared Spataro wrote in a blog post. "Pages takes ephemeral AI-generated content and makes it durable, so you can edit it, add to it, and share it with others... This is an entirely new work pattern — multiplayer, human to AI to human collaboration."

It's surprising that it took a year for Microsoft to bring better collaboration to the Business Chat app, as that's an expected feature of every workplace app these days. Having a place for employees to share their existing Copilot queries simply makes sense: Coworkers may want access to the same information, and it's also environmentally wasteful to have people running the same Copilot search multiple times. (Generative AI queries are far more costly for the environment than simple web searches.)

Microsoft says Pages will be available today to MS 365 Copilot users, and it'll also be coming to free Copilot customers with Microsoft Entra accounts "in the coming weeks."

In general, Microsoft says Copilot queries are more than two times faster now compared to launch, because it's relying on the newer GPT4o model. The company is also upgrading AI capabilities across the suite of MS 365 apps: Excel is getting Python support for more complex queries; PowerPoint's Narrative builder capability is widely available, allowing you to craft the story of your presentations with AI help; and Teams can now scan across meeting transcripts and their accompanying chats.

Microsoft Copilot 365: Outlook Prioritize My Inbox
Outlook Prioritize my Inbox
Microsoft

The other Office apps aren't left out either. Outlook will soon let you choose topics, people and keywords to highlight for the "Prioritize my inbox" feature. You'll also be able to reference meetings and emails directly within Word documents, one OneDrive will let you summarize and compare files without opening them using Copilot.

And if you need even more Copilot AI help, business can also create Copilot Agents directly within Business Chat and SharePoint. They're like chatbots that can peer within your corporate files, and you can also tag them in comments like a typical cooworker. While we still need to see these Agents in action to determine if they're actually useful, at the very least, you can feel less guilty about assigning them some menial information processing at the end of the work day.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/ai/microsoft-365-copilot-users-can-collaborate-with-ai-and-each-other-in-bizchat-pages-150042326.html?src=rss