Apple MacBook Pro 14-inch and 16-inch review (2024): Brace yourself for M4 speed

Apple's excellent MacBook Pros are faster than ever with its new M4 chips. That's it, that's the review. Their screens are slightly brighter, and the 14-inch model now starts with 16GB of RAM, but otherwise these are the same laptops that have been around since the M1 Pro redesign in 2021. Really, though, it's not as if Apple had much to improve on. The MacBook Pros have been among our favorite premium laptops for years — now they're just better.

When I last reviewed Apple's MacBook Pros, I concluded by saying, "Just try to save up for 16GB of RAM." Now, thanks to the increasing memory demands of Apple Intelligence, that's not something anyone will have to worry about again. That makes the $1,599 14-inch MacBook Pro a far better deal than before (you previously had to add on another $200 to get to 16GB). The 16-inch model, which starts at $2,499 with 24GB of RAM, is also a better choice for big-screen fans since its M4 Pro chip is a tremendous upgrade over last year's hardware.

The star of the show this year are Apple's new M4, M4 Pro chips and M4 Max chips. The M4 features a 10-core CPU and 10-core GPU, while the Pro bumps up to a 14-core CPU and 20-core GPU. The Max model, as usual, goes even harder: It features a 16-core CPU and a whopping 40-core GPU.

As you'd expected, the prices for those more powerful chips escalate dramatically: The M4 Pro 14-inch MacBook Pro starts at $1,999 ($400 more than the base model), while the M4 Max model starts at $3,199. At least you get slight RAM and storage bumps with those pricier chips, the M4 Pro starts with 24GB of RAM, while the Max model includes 36GB RAM and a 1TB SSD.

Aside from dramatically better chips, all of the new MacBook Pros feature MiniLED Liquid Retina XDR screens that can reach up to 1,000 nits for SDR (standard dynamic range) content. That's a 400-nit increase from before, and it should help make content far more visible in daylight or in very bright rooms. (HDR content, as usual, can push the display even further to a peak of 1,600 nits.) There's also a nano-texture glass option (for a $150 surcharge) that can make the screens more glare resistant, which is useful for working in bright environments. Note, however, that it can also make the screen appear less sharp.

Apple MacBook Pro (2024) webcam view
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

Apple also upgraded the MacBook Pros' webcams to 12-megapixels, a major leap over the previous 1080p camera. (Apple hasn't confirmed the megapixel figure for that camera, but it's likely around 2MP, the bare minimum to reach 1080p). Having a higher resolution camera also opens the door for Center Stage, which can keep you in focus as you move around your room.

Apple MacBook Pro (2024) Desk View on macOS
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

I didn't hate Apple's previous webcams, but mostly that's because I remember how mediocre its older 720p webcams used to be. The new models look far sharper with more accurate colors, and the overall image doesn't look as heavily filtered as the previous cameras. They also support Desk View (above), Apple's helpful feature for showing off objects below your screen.

If you're often dealing with large file transfers, you might also appreciate support for Thunderbolt 5 on the M4 Pro and M4 Max chips. It can support up to 120 Gb/s speeds, up from 40 Gb/s in Thunderbolt 4, which the standard M4 chip includes. That could make a huge difference if you're moving terabytes worth of 4K and 8K videos onto external drives – just note you’ll need to invest in similarly equipped Thunderbolt 5 storage. Thunderbolt 5 could potentially allow for external AI accelerators (unfortunately, Apple Silicon doesn't support external GPUs).

Apple MacBook Pro (2024) 14-inch and 16-inch side-by-side
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

I didn't really expect much from the new MacBook Pros, especially since the previous M3 models were already very impressive. But, once again, Apple managed to surprise me with its mobile hardware. The M4 chip, which was in our 14-inch review unit, was a solid performer. But the M4 Pro in our 16-inch MacBook Pro was an astonishing leap ahead of its predecessor, and it's also faster than every other computer we've tested this year (aside from the new Mac mini, which also had a M4 Pro chip).

Unfortunately, we didn't have an M4 Max-equipped MacBook Pro to test, but given that it's filled with more M4 CPU and GPU cores, I'd expect another major performance jump.

Computer

Geekbench 6

Geekbench 6 GPU

Cinebench 2024

Apple MacBook Pro 14-inch (M4, 2024)

3,797/14,571

37,869

172/979 GPU: 3770

Apple MacBook Pro 16-inch (M4 Pro, 2024)

3,925/22,456

70,197

178/1,689 GPU 9,295

Surface Laptop 7 (Snapdragon X Elite)

2,797/14,400

19,963

123/969 GPU N/A

Apple MacBook Pro 16-inch (M3 Max, 2024)

3,202/21,312

92,344

143/1,686 GPU 13,182


In Geekbench 6's CPU benchmark, the 14-inch M4 MacBook Pro scored 1,000 to 1,500 points higher than other recent laptops when it came to single-threaded work. Its multi-threaded performance lead was more slim, but it still beat out Intel's new Lunar Lake chips and Qualcomm's Snapdragon X Elite. The M4 Pro 16-inch MacBook Pro scored similarly for single-threaded work, but it blew the competition by 9,000 to 12,500 points. That performance gap alone is equivalent to the multi-threaded Geekbench 6 scores from other laptops this year! (It’s also slightly faster than last year’s M3 Max chip in the 16-inch MacBook Pro, another major achievement.)

Cinebench 2024 scores tell a similar story. Both the 14-inch and 16-inch MacBook Pro scored well above the competition in the single-threaded test. The M4 system was on-par with the best multi-threaded scores we saw from the Surface Laptop 7 (powered by a Snapdragon X Elite chip) and HP Omnibook Ultra 14 (AMD Ryzen AI 9 HX 375). But the M4 Pro 16-inch MacBook Pro, once again, handily outclassed other systems with its multithreaded score, which was nearly double what we've been seeing throughout the year.

Cinebench's GPU benchmark puts the M4 Pro's graphics performance in line with NVIDIA's RTX 4070 in Dell's XPS 16, while the M4 chip is in line with the Framework Laptop 16's Radeon 7700S. That's all about what I expected after testing the Mac mini with an M4 Pro chip, and it's simply astonishing to see that level of performance from a mobile-focused GPU.

Apple MacBook Pro (2024)
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

When it comes to games, the M4 Pro 16-inch MacBook Pro was able to maintain 60fps in Lies of P, Resident Evil 4 and Myst while playing in 1,440p with the graphics settings cranked to the max. 4K was possible, but typically slowed things down to around 30fps, which isn't very playable on a computer. The M4 14-inch MacBook Pro, meanwhile, handled those same games in 1080p at 60fps. We typically wouldn't recommend gaming much on Macs, but Apple's graphics hardware is hard to ignore at this point, and the company is also working to get more high profile titles in the App Store, like Remedy's Control.

To put Apple's Neural Engine to the test, I also used the Whisper Transcription app (AKA MacWhisper) to turn an hour and nine-minute long podcast episode into a transcript. The M4 14-inch MacBook Pro took three minutes and two seconds, while the M4 Pro 16-inch model took two minutes and 11 seconds (similar to what I saw on the M4 Mac mini). In comparison, an M3 14-inch MacBook Pro took three minutes and thirty-seven seconds.

Apple MacBook Pro (2024)
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

While the speed upgrades are more than welcome, in my testing I noticed that both of the MacBook Pros' screens were easier to see in bright sunlight. That alone isn't enough to upgrade for if you've already got an M2 or M3 MacBook Pro, but it's definitely something to look forward to. And even though Apple's keyboard and enormous trackpad haven't changed, they're still among the best in the industry. I also still appreciate having a wide variety of ports on these systems: three USB-C connections (Thunderbolt 4 with the M4, Thunderbolt 5 with the M4 Pro), an HDMI port, a headphone jack, a MagSafe power connector and an SD card reader.

Both MacBook Pros also continue to deliver excellent battery life. The 14-inch lasted for 34 hours and 15 minutes while looping an HD video, whereas the 16-inch went for 30 hours and 16 minutes. That's the first time we've seen our video rundown test go beyond 30 hours. In real-world usage, I could typically use both machines for general productivity work for two days without needing a recharge. That's the benefit of relying on power-sipping mobile hardware.

Apple MacBook Pro (2024) bottom view
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

There's no doubt these new MacBook Pros are compelling, especially if you need the raw power of the M4 Pro (or conceivably, the M4 Max). If you're running an M1 MacBook Pro, or still trucking along with an Intel model, you'll definitely see some notable performance gains from these machines. But if you've got an M2 or M3 MacBook Pro, the M4 hardware is less of a qualitative leap. You're probably better off waiting for the eventual OLED refresh, which is rumored to happen in 2026.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-14-inch-and-16-inch-review-2024-brace-yourself-for-m4-speed-140057584.html?src=rss

Apple Mac mini review (M4 Pro, 2024): Shockingly small, incredibly powerful

"That's a computer?!" My daughter just couldn't believe her eyes when I pulled the new Mac mini out of its box. It measures just five-inches by five-inches across, and it sits a mere two inches tall. The Mac mini is an adorable box that resembles an oversized Apple TV. But what's more impressive is that it's significantly faster than before, thanks to Apple's M4 and M4 Pro chips, and it still starts at $599. Once again, the Mac mini redefines what a desktop can be.

While Apple may have started the tiny PC trend with the original Mac mini in 2005, it's certainly not alone today. Intel's NUC line survived execution and is now being spearheaded by ASUS, but those boxes are still expensive and relatively niche. HP sells "Elite MIni" desktops for businesses, but they mainly exist to make IT workers' lives easier.

The Mac mini, meanwhile, has for years been an affordable gateway into the world of Apple desktops. Now, it's the cheapest way to get a taste of Apple Silicon, especially if you already have a monitor, keyboard and mouse. (And if you don't, you can still configure a whole desktop setup for under $1,000.) As I said when it was announced, even if you don't need one, the Mac mini's pint-sized frame and powerful hardware makes it incredibly compelling.

Just look at it! The Mac mini's redesigned case is less than half the size of the previous version, so you won't have to devote as much desk space to it. It also features front connectivity for the first time — two USB-C ports and a headphone jack — something that previously required upgrading to the $1,999 Mac Studio. Most people will likely be better off with the 3.5mm jack up front, but if you’re the rare user who needs to connect speakers, you’re better off relying on a USB-C dongle in the rear, or a high-quality audio interface.

More so than aesthetics, the Mac mini's biggest upgrade this time around is Apple's new M4 hardware, as well as the fact that it – like all new Macs going forward – now comes with 16GB of RAM standard. The M4 sports a 10-core CPU (four high-performance cores and six high-efficiency), a 10-core GPU and a 16-core Neural Engine. For $1,399, you can bump up to the dramatically more powerful M4 Pro chip (which is what's in our review unit), featuring a 14-core CPU (10 high-performance and four high-efficiency) and 20-core GPU.

Apple Mac mini (2024) rear ports: Power, Ethernet, HDMI and three USB-C Thunderbolt 5 connections.
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

The M4 chip includes support for Thunderbolt 4 on its three rear USB-C ports, while the M4 Pro brings Thunderbolt 5 to Macs for the first time, with triple the data transfer speeds (120 Gb/s compared to 40 Gb/s). Every Mac mini also includes a full-sized HDMI connection (supporting up to 8K 60Hz or 4K 240Hz), as well as an Ethernet port (gigabit standard, or upgradable to 10GbE). While it lacks the integrated SD card reader of the Mac Studio, the Mac mini is otherwise well-equipped to meet the demands of many creative professionals.

There are some curious design choices, though. For one, the Mac mini's power button is along the bottom of its rear end, which leads to some awkward finger gymnastics whenever you want to turn it on. (Read into that what you will.) That means you probably wouldn't want to hide it in an unreachable corner of your desk. The previous Mac mini also hid the power button along its rear, but at least that was right beside its ports, and it didn't require tipping over the device.

Apple likely doesn't expect its users to be completely turning off their devices very often, but that's also clearly at odds with its sustainability efforts. (The company loudly claims the Mac mini is carbon neutral, for example, as it's mostly built with recycled metals and other materials.)

Apple Mac mini (2024) in hand, viewing the USB-C ports and headphone jack up front
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

The Mac mini was the fastest computer I've reviewed this year, at least when it comes to CPU benchmarks. I've grown used to being impressed by Apple Silicon, but the M4 Pro in our review unit (which was also equipped with 48GB of RAM) was still a bigger leap ahead than I expected. While running in high power mode, which cranks up performance, the Mac mini’s Geekbench 6 single-threaded score of 3,943 was well above the typical 2,500 to 2,800 point range we've seen in PCs this year. Its multithreaded Geekbench 6 score reached a whopping 22,850 points — the only other systems that cracked 14,00 points this year were the Snapdragon X Elite-powered Surface Laptop 7 and XPS 13.


Computer

Geekbench 6

Geekbench 6 GPU

Cinebench 2024

Apple Mac mini (M4 Pro, 2024)

3,934/22,850

69,753

172/1660 GPU:8953

Apple MacBook Pro 14-inch (M4, 2024)

3,797/14,571

37,869

172/979 GPU: 3770

Surface Laptop 7 (Snapdragon X Elite)

2,797/14,400

19,963

123/969

Apple iMac (M3, 2023)

3,152/11,892

30n388

138/629 GPU:3711

Naturally, other laptops with dedicated, power-hungry video cards outclassed the Mac mini in the Geekbench 6 GPU test, but Apple's tiny desktop still beat out the RTX 4050 in Dell's XPS 14, as well as the Radeon 7700S in the 16-inch Framework Laptop. That's still a very impressive result for graphics built into a single system-on-a-chip.

Outside of benchmarks, the Mac mini impressed me by running Lies of P in 1,440p with maxed out graphics settings at 60fps. It even managed to run the game in 4K with medium graphics settings, but the frame rate hovered around 30fps, which wasn't very playable. That's not a huge surprise though — what's more important is that I know the GPU is powerful enough to run modern games at more reasonable resolutions. Resident Evil 4 and No Man's Sky also held a steady 60 fps in 1,440p.

To test out the Mac mini's AI capabilities, I used the Whisper Transcription app to transcribe an hour and nine-minute long episode of the Engadget Podcast. That took two minutes and nine seconds, using the small language model. In comparison, the M4-powered 14-inch MacBook Pro took three minutes and three seconds, while an M3 14-inch MacBook Pro took three minutes and thirty-seven seconds. These figures tell us Apple's M4 hardware can help students quickly get notes from lecture recordings, or even transcribe classes in real-time without much effort.

Apple Mac mini (2024) from the bottom, viewing the intake vent.
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

As I threw benchmarks, games and encoding jobs at the Mac mini, I was constantly impressed by how much it could tackle without making any discernible fan noise. But Apple can’t escape heat. The Mac mini has a large intake fan along its bottom that sucks in cool air and spreads it out throughout the entire system. However, when I started running Cinebench's multithreaded benchmark, the fan kicked into high gear and the Mac mini sounded like it was getting ready to take off.

It's not an unpleasant sound — it's more like a calming white noise machine than the obnoxiously loud Mac fans of yore — but it's certainly noticeable. If you're typically wearing headphones or blasting music, it may not be an issue, but it could make the Mac mini very annoying in a shared office setting. If you're planning to constantly throw heavy workloads at it in high power mode, you might be better off with the larger Mac Studio, which can better handle heat. Apple still hasn't updated the Studio with M4 chips, though — you'll have to wait until next year for that.

Apple Mac mini (2024) alongside a Studio Display
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

There's no doubt the M4 Pro Mac mini is an absolute beast, but at $1,399 (with 24GB of RAM and a 512GB SSD to start), it's mainly targeted at creative professionals. I didn't have the $599 M4 model to test (which starts with 16GB of RAM and a 256GB SSD), but I benchmarked that exact same chip on the 14-inch MacBook Pro and still found it impressive. Its Geekbench 6 and Cinebench scores still beat out most of the computers we've tested this year, and its GPU is fast enough for solid 1080p 60 fps gameplay.

If you're just looking for a basic and adorably small Mac desktop, the $599 Mac mini will likely be all you need. And if you're looking to do a bit more serious work, and can't justify the $1,999 Mac Studio, the $1,399 model is a decent value compared to PC workstations. Just be prepared to stomach Apple's upgrade prices: You'll have to spend an additional $400 just to get 32GB of RAM on the base Mini, and another $400 to get a 1TB SSD. That's wildly out of step with prices outside of the Apple ecosystem, where you can easily find a decent 1TB NVMe SSD under $100. (That said, unlike a laptop, connecting a cheap but capacious external drive to the mini is a more viable option.)

Apple’s gonna Apple when it comes to upgrade pricing, but at least you can finally buy a $599 Mac mini with 16GB of RAM. That alone is reason to celebrate. The fact that it’s cute enough to impress my kid is a nice bonus.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/apple-mac-mini-review-m4-pro-2024-shockingly-small-incredibly-powerful-140042432.html?src=rss

Apple Mac mini review (M4 Pro, 2024): Shockingly small, incredibly powerful

"That's a computer?!" My daughter just couldn't believe her eyes when I pulled the new Mac mini out of its box. It measures just five-inches by five-inches across, and it sits a mere two inches tall. The Mac mini is an adorable box that resembles an oversized Apple TV. But what's more impressive is that it's significantly faster than before, thanks to Apple's M4 and M4 Pro chips, and it still starts at $599. Once again, the Mac mini redefines what a desktop can be.

While Apple may have started the tiny PC trend with the original Mac mini in 2005, it's certainly not alone today. Intel's NUC line survived execution and is now being spearheaded by ASUS, but those boxes are still expensive and relatively niche. HP sells "Elite MIni" desktops for businesses, but they mainly exist to make IT workers' lives easier.

The Mac mini, meanwhile, has for years been an affordable gateway into the world of Apple desktops. Now, it's the cheapest way to get a taste of Apple Silicon, especially if you already have a monitor, keyboard and mouse. (And if you don't, you can still configure a whole desktop setup for under $1,000.) As I said when it was announced, even if you don't need one, the Mac mini's pint-sized frame and powerful hardware makes it incredibly compelling.

Just look at it! The Mac mini's redesigned case is less than half the size of the previous version, so you won't have to devote as much desk space to it. It also features front connectivity for the first time — two USB-C ports and a headphone jack — something that previously required upgrading to the $1,999 Mac Studio. Most people will likely be better off with the 3.5mm jack up front, but if you’re the rare user who needs to connect speakers, you’re better off relying on a USB-C dongle in the rear, or a high-quality audio interface.

More so than aesthetics, the Mac mini's biggest upgrade this time around is Apple's new M4 hardware, as well as the fact that it – like all new Macs going forward – now comes with 16GB of RAM standard. The M4 sports a 10-core CPU (four high-performance cores and six high-efficiency), a 10-core GPU and a 16-core Neural Engine. For $1,399, you can bump up to the dramatically more powerful M4 Pro chip (which is what's in our review unit), featuring a 14-core CPU (10 high-performance and four high-efficiency) and 20-core GPU.

Apple Mac mini (2024) rear ports: Power, Ethernet, HDMI and three USB-C Thunderbolt 5 connections.
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

The M4 chip includes support for Thunderbolt 4 on its three rear USB-C ports, while the M4 Pro brings Thunderbolt 5 to Macs for the first time, with triple the data transfer speeds (120 Gb/s compared to 40 Gb/s). Every Mac mini also includes a full-sized HDMI connection (supporting up to 8K 60Hz or 4K 240Hz), as well as an Ethernet port (gigabit standard, or upgradable to 10GbE). While it lacks the integrated SD card reader of the Mac Studio, the Mac mini is otherwise well-equipped to meet the demands of many creative professionals.

There are some curious design choices, though. For one, the Mac mini's power button is along the bottom of its rear end, which leads to some awkward finger gymnastics whenever you want to turn it on. (Read into that what you will.) That means you probably wouldn't want to hide it in an unreachable corner of your desk. The previous Mac mini also hid the power button along its rear, but at least that was right beside its ports, and it didn't require tipping over the device.

Apple likely doesn't expect its users to be completely turning off their devices very often, but that's also clearly at odds with its sustainability efforts. (The company loudly claims the Mac mini is carbon neutral, for example, as it's mostly built with recycled metals and other materials.)

Apple Mac mini (2024) in hand, viewing the USB-C ports and headphone jack up front
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

The Mac mini was the fastest computer I've reviewed this year, at least when it comes to CPU benchmarks. I've grown used to being impressed by Apple Silicon, but the M4 Pro in our review unit (which was also equipped with 48GB of RAM) was still a bigger leap ahead than I expected. While running in high power mode, which cranks up performance, the Mac mini’s Geekbench 6 single-threaded score of 3,943 was well above the typical 2,500 to 2,800 point range we've seen in PCs this year. Its multithreaded Geekbench 6 score reached a whopping 22,850 points — the only other systems that cracked 14,00 points this year were the Snapdragon X Elite-powered Surface Laptop 7 and XPS 13.


Computer

Geekbench 6

Geekbench 6 GPU

Cinebench 2024

Apple Mac mini (M4 Pro, 2024)

3,934/22,850

69,753

172/1660 GPU:8953

Apple MacBook Pro 14-inch (M4, 2024)

3,797/14,571

37,869

172/979 GPU: 3770

Surface Laptop 7 (Snapdragon X Elite)

2,797/14,400

19,963

123/969

Apple iMac (M3, 2023)

3,152/11,892

30n388

138/629 GPU:3711

Naturally, other laptops with dedicated, power-hungry video cards outclassed the Mac mini in the Geekbench 6 GPU test, but Apple's tiny desktop still beat out the RTX 4050 in Dell's XPS 14, as well as the Radeon 7700S in the 16-inch Framework Laptop. That's still a very impressive result for graphics built into a single system-on-a-chip.

Outside of benchmarks, the Mac mini impressed me by running Lies of P in 1,440p with maxed out graphics settings at 60fps. It even managed to run the game in 4K with medium graphics settings, but the frame rate hovered around 30fps, which wasn't very playable. That's not a huge surprise though — what's more important is that I know the GPU is powerful enough to run modern games at more reasonable resolutions. Resident Evil 4 and No Man's Sky also held a steady 60 fps in 1,440p.

To test out the Mac mini's AI capabilities, I used the Whisper Transcription app to transcribe an hour and nine-minute long episode of the Engadget Podcast. That took two minutes and nine seconds, using the small language model. In comparison, the M4-powered 14-inch MacBook Pro took three minutes and three seconds, while an M3 14-inch MacBook Pro took three minutes and thirty-seven seconds. These figures tell us Apple's M4 hardware can help students quickly get notes from lecture recordings, or even transcribe classes in real-time without much effort.

Apple Mac mini (2024) from the bottom, viewing the intake vent.
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

As I threw benchmarks, games and encoding jobs at the Mac mini, I was constantly impressed by how much it could tackle without making any discernible fan noise. But Apple can’t escape heat. The Mac mini has a large intake fan along its bottom that sucks in cool air and spreads it out throughout the entire system. However, when I started running Cinebench's multithreaded benchmark, the fan kicked into high gear and the Mac mini sounded like it was getting ready to take off.

It's not an unpleasant sound — it's more like a calming white noise machine than the obnoxiously loud Mac fans of yore — but it's certainly noticeable. If you're typically wearing headphones or blasting music, it may not be an issue, but it could make the Mac mini very annoying in a shared office setting. If you're planning to constantly throw heavy workloads at it in high power mode, you might be better off with the larger Mac Studio, which can better handle heat. Apple still hasn't updated the Studio with M4 chips, though — you'll have to wait until next year for that.

Apple Mac mini (2024) alongside a Studio Display
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

There's no doubt the M4 Pro Mac mini is an absolute beast, but at $1,399 (with 24GB of RAM and a 512GB SSD to start), it's mainly targeted at creative professionals. I didn't have the $599 M4 model to test (which starts with 16GB of RAM and a 256GB SSD), but I benchmarked that exact same chip on the 14-inch MacBook Pro and still found it impressive. Its Geekbench 6 and Cinebench scores still beat out most of the computers we've tested this year, and its GPU is fast enough for solid 1080p 60 fps gameplay.

If you're just looking for a basic and adorably small Mac desktop, the $599 Mac mini will likely be all you need. And if you're looking to do a bit more serious work, and can't justify the $1,999 Mac Studio, the $1,399 model is a decent value compared to PC workstations. Just be prepared to stomach Apple's upgrade prices: You'll have to spend an additional $400 just to get 32GB of RAM on the base Mini, and another $400 to get a 1TB SSD. That's wildly out of step with prices outside of the Apple ecosystem, where you can easily find a decent 1TB NVMe SSD under $100. (That said, unlike a laptop, connecting a cheap but capacious external drive to the mini is a more viable option.)

Apple’s gonna Apple when it comes to upgrade pricing, but at least you can finally buy a $599 Mac mini with 16GB of RAM. That alone is reason to celebrate. The fact that it’s cute enough to impress my kid is a nice bonus.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/apple-mac-mini-review-m4-pro-2024-shockingly-small-incredibly-powerful-140042432.html?src=rss

Engadget Podcast: Apple’s M4 chip heads to the iMac, Mac mini and MacBook Pro

It's been a Mac-heavy week! In this episode, Devindra and producer Ben Ellman dive into all of Apple's new M4 hardware: the new iMac, Mac mini and refreshed Macbook Pros. The Mac mini, in particular, looks like it'll be a huge hit for anyone who needs a simple desktop system. Also, we dive into why Apple is pushing for every Mac to get 16GB of RAM at a minimum. That will benefit all users, even if they don't care about Apple Intelligence.


Listen below or subscribe on your podcast app of choice. If you've got suggestions or topics you'd like covered on the show, be sure to email us or drop a note in the comments! And be sure to check out our other podcast, Engadget News!

  • Unofficial Mac Week: Apple announces M4 Pro and M4 Max chips in refreshed iMac, Mac Mini, and Macbook Pro models – 0:58

  • Regulators force Lyft to tell U.S. drivers accurate numbers of how much money they’ll make – 45:30

  • AP report: OpenAI’s Whisper transcription model invents parts of audio transcripts – 49:06

  • AOC and Tim Walz streamed Crazy Taxi on Twitch – 53:11

  • McDonalds can finally repair their own McFlurry machines in significant win for Right to repair – 55:54

  • Around Engadget – 59:45

  • Pop culture picks – 1:03:42

Hosts: Devindra Hardawar and Ben Ellman
Producer: Ben Ellman
Music: Dale North and Terrence O'Brien

Devindra: What's up internet? Welcome back to the Engadget Podcast I'm senior editor Devindra Hardawar. This week, I'm joined by our podcast producer, Ben Ellman. Hey, Ben.

Ben: Hello. How's it going?

Devindra: Hello. It's going good. Kind of a light ship this week because a lot of people are out. Everyone's on taking some break and a lot of people are just busy at Engadget.

So it's just going to be us. But we've got a lot of news to dive into all of Apple's new Macs with M4 chips, the M4 Pro and M4 Max as well, that they all just announced this week. There's a lot of new stuff and I'm excited to talk about it as always, folks. So if you're enjoying the show, please be sure to subscribe to us on iTunes or your podcatcher of choice.

Leave us a review on iTunes. Drop us an email at podcast@engadget.com. And also, yeah, you can join us Thursday mornings, typically around 1045 AM Eastern on our YouTube channel for our live stream so we can do some Q& A. In fact, we'll be including some of those questions and our answers later in this episode as well.

So, yeah, tune in for that. Ben, you are somebody who I know is fully in the Mac ecosystem, and I also know you're very conscientious. Well, unfortunately, or for what you do, you're kind of there, but you're also very conscientious about how you upgrade, right? Because we're dragging you into a modern iPhone and things like that.

How did you feel about all these new Macs? Because we have the M4 iMac, we have an adorable new Mac mini, which is tiny, absolutely tiny, and M4 chips on the MacBook Pros. Is anything particularly compelling to you?

Ben: So as I was reading up on the Mac, All of the stuff they released this week. I saw the line that said something like the M four, I think it was Pro Chip is now like three times faster than the now ancient M1,

Devindra: it is four.

That chip is four years old now. So that

Ben: cut me like a knife. But that is M1 Classic, not M1 Pro.

Devindra: Yes, I

Ben: do believe that. My research says that the M1 Pro is only two times slower than this new M4 Pro. Please fact check me on this. Send us an email at podcast adding gadget. If I didn't get that right.

Devindra: I mean, you, you bring up a good point though, Ben, be sure to be very clear about what Apple is comparing its devices to, right?

Because they often go back to base M1, which. Was released at the end of 2020 2020. It took a full year before we got the M4 Pro and M4 Max chips, right. Before they really expanded the line. No,

Ben: you mean M1 Pro and M1 Max. M1 Pro and M1 Max.

Devindra: Yeah. So remember that there was that time difference when they, they just dropped the M1 on us and that was on the MacBook Air, MacBook Pro 13 inch, which was a fricking waste of time and the Mac mini, I believe back then, right.

So.

Ben: But then this calls back to a bigger contextual question that I have. Why is Apple doing this? They are just releasing a bunch of stuff kind of quietly. They're putting it on the website. They're sending out like press releases and stuff. Usually they love to bring everyone onto the campus like they did just a couple of months ago and show you nonsensical stuff.

graphs with absolutely no measurements on them, saying how much faster this chip is than a chip that they released a few years ago. Is there any like chatter on why

Devindra: they're doing it kind of quietly like this? Yeah. So, I mean, let's talk about what happened this week, right? So they announced last week, or they confirmed that there will be.

a series of Mac news announcements, but we didn't, we didn't know if it would just be a live stream. We didn't know if it would just be video recordings and news drops. And that's what it ended up being. They love

Ben: a song and dance and there has been no song and

Devindra: dance. I mean, I feel it, you know, I'm sure even Apple is tired of hosting these song and dances or media events.

And yeah. Especially for machines that aren't like too different than before. The Mac mini is like a new one. The Mac mini like looks interesting. And I feel like Apple of yore would have done at least a small press event in New York or something to show off that particular piece of Hardaware. But also, I don't know, man, everyone's tired.

I feel like that's what we're feeling right now. You know, everyone's tired. We are. In this election cycle, which is just about to end, and I feel like they kind of got the news out there, right? They produced a couple of videos. They said, Hey, I mean, we just announced the M4 chip. Here's the M4 Pro and M4 Max.

Here are new systems. You kind of know what the deal is. And I feel like that's pretty much it.

Ben: Are you saying that they might be playing some kind of meta game where they're like, you know what, we're not going to ask all these tech journalists to fly out again and eat half to three quarters of their week going to hang out with us.

Because their grumpiness about having to do that, when it's getting toward the end of the year and they've got so much else on their plate, might bleed into man, why did they fly us out for this? Yes, there are improvements, but I think it's even unbearable. I think

Devindra: They are tired too, like to produce an event, to coordinate everything for a launch.

It's a lot of work. And I feel like even the people at Apple are like, you know, we don't need to go this hard. Like they produced a couple of videos. They got the press releases out there. They pre briefed some press. So I got a bit of early info on this. I didn't get early info on the iMac.

There are reports that they held some sort of hand hands on event. In L. A. At least that's what Mark Gurman said in his newsletter, and I have not seen any of those things out yet. So maybe those hands on will drop later today or tomorrow or something. And to be fair, the

Ben: iPhone 16 launch event was on Monday, September 9th, which means that it was just a month and a half ago.

Devindra: Yeah, it's, I feel like they're done. Like the major things for Apple are the iPhone events, maybe, maybe like a product event early in the year and then WWDC, you know, so, and the other thing is maybe we are amidst the like delayed launch of Apple intelligence. Right. Which also launched this week across devices with iOS 18.

1 and the MacOS stuff. And I also wonder if Apple's just like tired of answering questions about that. Like even that was like a muted, Hey here are a few Apple intelligence features that new Siri, not here yet. That'll be here soon. And also all this stuff is being slow rolled out. So strategy wise, what we saw Apple do, I think last year, Ben, I think they just did one day where they.

Posted a video and was just like, Hey, here's all the news. I wonder if this is a new strategy for Apple where they did it throughout the week, little tidbits of news, and we're talking about it throughout the entire week and they own that week, you know? So I think there's a lot of value to that.

Ben: Yeah.

Same thing is not dropping a entire. series of a show all at once, because if you do it weekly, like you used to, then people are talking about it week to week. The whole like entertainment news industrial complex can do their recaps and everything.

Devindra: Exactly, exactly. So let's take a look at what Apple is has launched this week.

On Monday, we got the new iMac M4 With brighter colors, I guess you could say we're talking brighter

Ben: colors on the front or the back

Devindra: on the back, right? There's no real colors on the real. No, you get the front colors to you have the like little chin on the iMac, but is the design that thinner design they launched with the M one chips now in slightly brighter colors?

M four chip also has, let me just see here. It also has a trend that we started seeing this week, 16 gigabytes of RAM. As the base amount without changing the base price. So who can we

Ben: thank for that?

Devindra: I would, I would say AI, I would say Apple intelligence. And that's also something we've seen throughout this entire year, but I'll get to that.

So 1299 for the new M4 iMac has 16GB of RAM, has much Faster Hardaware, at least with this M four chip. There are four USBC ports on the pricier one with a 10 core CPU and GPU for the M four, I assume you'll get less on the cheaper one. You can upgrade up to 32 gigabytes of ram. This is a nice system. I like the new imax.

Have you seen these things, Ben? In action?

Ben: I'm gonna be straight up with you. I have not seen a iMac inaction really since maybe before college or something. You've been in a Mac store, Ben. Come on. Okay. Yes. I've been in a Mac store, but like I haven't seen them in the wild outside of their enclosure for a very long time for a while.

That was like the way that you signaled to people, especially in education settings that your educational institution had money. Sure. And that actually gets to another question of okay, you have these Pretty colored anodized aluminum backs for the IMAX. And what do they do in most like non open plan office settings?

They're going to be pointed for the wall. Probably you're not even going to be

Devindra: able to enjoy them. You get, you get some color on the front. You get color on the base. The bases all have color too. And honestly, a lot of open offices have they're not pointing at the wall, right? They're, they're cubicles or like mini desks, in the middle of the room and maybe sometimes facing each other. I love this machine. Like I, Apple just did a great job of making the sink super slim. It is very light. It's easy to move around. You certainly couldn't, you know, mistake it for a laptop or something. But when I reviewed the M1 iMac, was it the M2?

Like whatever the last one I reviewed, like I was just so impressed at being able to to move that thing around to just And I remember portability

Ben: was part of the original like pitch for this, like years and years ago.

Devindra: Yeah, like you could bring it from your den to your, you know, dining room or something and do something with your kids and then bring it back.

It's just one cable. You plug it in. You haul over the accessories. It's not that tough. So I've actually for a while been contemplating just getting an iMac, like one of these new iMacs and having it be like the family computer, especially for my daughter, who's getting more into computing stuff right now, like she is.

Big on iPad. She's big on touchscreens. Minecraft is like the thing she does and she has some like iPad reading games and language games and stuff. So this would

Ben: be like the living room computer or something could

Devindra: be, and we have a space for it, or we move it up to an upstairs office or something.

But I just see the value here. So I think this is a great machine. It's great to have new Hardaware in here. Even better that it has 16 gigabytes of RAM. And yeah, as you were saying, Ben, I think we really can thank Apple intelligence for that. Mark Gurman in his last newsletter reported that you know, we've seen Apple intelligence basically eat up eight gigabytes of RAM on its own.

So because it's running large models, large language models and different things, and it's no wonder that. Microsoft's Copilot Plus PCs, those AI PCs also require at least 16 gigabytes of RAM. I think what we're seeing is like that is the cost of running these AI models because what they're doing is basically chewing up large amounts of data or processing it against your current data and that takes memory.

And I think for the longest time PC makers were like, hey, eight gigabytes, that's fine, right? They kind of drag their heels even moving beyond four gigabytes. When we review systems, we always recommend go for at least 16 gigabytes. You don't really want to be opening up your computer and adding in more RAM.

And even for newer computers you can't really do that. You can't do that with Apple's Hardaware because the RAM is built onto the processor. So, this is good. It's a good thing. Even if you don't care about Apple intelligence, you can thank AI for this, at least. So, that's the iMac. Any, any thoughts? Are you compelled by

Ben: this?

And you've been talking about, like, why do they even sell an 8 gig RAM version for a few years now? Because as the IT person, both formerly professionally and IT person of your family, For life, basically, yeah. Yeah. Always on call to be like, okay, well, you know what, I, I think I just want a laptop that like can do word processing and then all of a sudden somebody is like, Oh, well, my kid wants to edit a video on it.

And that's all it takes to justify a upgrade to 16 gigs.

Devindra: Exactly. And I mean, the cost in the past also wasn't that much, but it was still something. And a lot of Mainstream buyers just didn't go for it. I think this is a good thing. This is a good thing for everybody. Certainly like for the people who never made that bump before, when I talked to Apple before, why eight gigabytes was still the thing they were doing, they kept telling me like the M series chips are more memory efficient.

Which is kind of technically true. So they could maybe stretch eight gigabytes of Ram more than before. They're also the memory bandwidth was faster than before because the memory chips are right there next to the CPU. And it can all be processed much more quickly. But yeah, 16, 16 gigabytes is the standard.

And now I'm introducing a new standard folks. If you're listening to this show, if you like to play games. If you like to edit the occasional video or something, or just put something up on Instagram or or TikTok, 32 gigabytes of RAM. Let's go, let's go all in on 32 gigabytes of RAM. How much RAM do you have in your MacBook, Ben?

Ben: I told you 32 gigs, and that was partially subsidized by COVID stimulus checks. There is

Devindra: that too. But 32 gigabytes really gives you room to breathe. And if you're working on a large project, Then yeah, that's something that you definitely want. So I'm just putting that out there now that 16 gigabytes seems like the baseline standard more, most folks will be fine with that, but if you are a pro, a prosumer, if you're a creative professional, at least 32 gigabytes, now Mac and PC would be a good.

Yeah.

Ben: I feel like my position on the show is to act as the non expert, but still smarter than maybe the average user, a little bit smarter than the average user. And so when I was specking out this laptop. I was thinking, okay, I want the M1 Pro because it's still going to be, like, so much of an upgrade over the Intel chip in my 2012 era MacBook Pro.

And also, I want to be able to future proof it, so I didn't know what was going to happen in the future. Generative AI, all of that stuff was just getting started around the time when I finally Pushed purchase on this laptop and I'm really happy that I did some future proofing and went for the 32 gig option

Devindra: Definitely always future proofing especially I think our recommendation was Ben that you do that because what you can't do You can't open up a Mac of any kind now not a laptop not a desktop unless it's a Mac Pro No, you can't even do with the Mac Pro because the Mac Pro is also running an M series chip.

There is no memory upgrades are not a thing anymore, at least on a self contained chip like this. So yeah, buy as much as you can you know, suffer a little bit to put more RAM in there if you have to.

Ben: Okay. So let's talk about this adorable Mac Mini. I

Devindra: think the Mac mini is the star of the week, right?

Because this thing we expected new Mac mini Mark Gurman was reporting like there would be some sort of small redesign. It is small or small as internet would say it it's five inches by five inches. It measures two inches tall. If you look at the pictures, like it's just like on somebody's fingertips.

This is a. It's a small boy, but it's not a weak boy because it has the M4 chip. And it also introduced the M4 pro chip, which is supposed to be really, really fast. And this is a good time to think about what the Mac mini represents to you. Like I remember when this thing came out, I was also working in it.

around 2005. That original Mac Mini was kind of a slow little box, but it was an interesting idea that not many people were doing. I honestly think you can, you can like really trace the small PC trend back to the Mac Mini because Intel's NUCs and other things people did kind of followed with what that was.

Do you have any experience with the Mac Mini? Ben, any thoughts on the previous Mac Minis?

Ben: The studio that I used to work at on the Upper West Side ran entirely on a Mac Mini.

Devindra: Amazing. Like you can, and that was like years ago, right? That was like before the M series Mac. Oh yeah,

Ben: yeah, no. And this was also done by like old school audio engineers who really value the stability of their like workspaces over everything.

So they are very slow to upgrade. And this thing was still chugging along really well.

Devindra: Yeah, yeah. I mean, so the Mac mini has been a great thing for a while. The last one did that one get the M3 chip? I think they had skipped that one, but the last Mac mini I reviewed where they introduced the pro chip for the first time.

That thing blew me away because that thing was just super fast. It kind of delivered most of what you wanted from a Mac studio, but it was far cheaper than studio with the pro chip, it was still more expensive than like the base model. It was like 1299. Let me look up that review actually.

Ben: Plus it looks like it's small enough to fit in the enormous pockets of JNCO jeans that are coming back in style.

Very slowly.

Devindra: Honestly, I don't even think you need like big baggy JNCO jeans. Really saying, I think this thing could fit in like a normal jean pocket, or at least I've been able to fit large packages in mine. I don't know. That's the whole like thing. This it's, it's adorably small. I think, you know, the Mac mini has just been something when I reviewed the the M2 pro mini last year.

Early last year, that was January 28th, 2023. I was just super impressed by the M2 Pro chip. And they're kind of doing that again here. I think for most people, this is kind of all the desktop you need. Certainly all the Mac desktop you need. It's also like the. Only new one with an M Pro chip that you can, er, an M4 chip that you'll be able to buy.

The Mac Studio has not been updated yet, so they're projecting like maybe spring for that. But you know what, like this thing, this thing is great. This thing is so tiny you can put it pretty much anywhere. It also comes with 16 gigabytes of RAM standard. Still starts at 599 with the base M4 chip. But that's, yeah,

Ben: that's base M4.

That's still pretty powerful. Also, yeah. Let's talk about the ports for a second too. So they're all

Devindra: Thunderbolt now? They're all the rear ones I believe are Thunderbolt because they have the little Thunderbolt picture on them But let's talk about those ports because you'll notice something up front that we complained about with the last review Ports up front Last year, if you wanted like a Mac with accessible USB ports up front, you had to get a Mac Studio.

That was like one of the big reasons to do it. And it almost seemed it seems like Apple saw that criticism and directly addressed that. So there were two USB C ports up front. There's also the headphone jack up front. Around the back the base M4 model gets you Thunderbolt 4 support, which is, which is pretty good.

But if you go up to the M4 Pro, you get Thunderbolt 5 support. And that is really interesting. It's the first time we've seen Thunderbolt 5 on Macs. It's also it's not really on many PC systems yet. I had written up Thunderbolt 5 last year. Let me see here. It delivers up to three times the bandwidth of Thunderbolt 3.

So that's pretty good memory, like a memory bandwidth should also be much better with the new Thunderbolt. So that's kind of interesting because it does open up the. Door for better external GPU support. We didn't really like external GPU docs for a while because Thunderbolt three and before were just a little slow.

If you bought a nice CPU, you were not getting all that speed. Now you could potentially do that. I've also seen Apple and others talk about things like AI accelerators, which are just like little GPU boxes, basically that just do AI work, not even for like games. Yeah. So that's what that opens up.

And that M4 pro. Mac mini starts at 13. 99. That's what you'd pay for a decently powerful desktop, you know? So if you are somebody working in audio or video and you don't need the full capabilities of the Mac studio, which is especially

Ben: video, because if you need to Dump like 120 GBPS onto a drive or something.

That's probably going to be video. That's probably going to be like really complicated, like 3d rendering or something like that's an

Devindra: enormous amount

Ben: of

Devindra: data. That's a ton of data. That's the main thing. And 1399, Hey, it is much more expensive than the base model, but that is a really powerful little system.

And look at how far we've come from like the giant desktop towers. I have a giant desktop tower down here. Okay. A pocketable desktop computer. That's nuts. It's just, it's, it's super great. It's one of those things where I've showed this to people and they were like, I don't really need this, but I want to give it a home.

I want to find a place for it. Yeah.

Ben: Because it looks like a puppy. It's adorable. But also, that reminds me, a few weeks ago when we were talking off stream, off podcast, I was saying something about how maybe it would be worth investing in a, Mac mini, because it's just every time I take my laptop out, especially because this is like the biggest investment that I think I've ever made.

I have never bought a car and this thing that I have in front of me right now is the price of, let's say, a kind of decent used car circa 2019. A while ago, before the pandemic.

Devindra: Maybe, maybe 2019, but it depends. I mean, how much So Yeah, go ahead.

Ben: Every time I take it out in the wild, I'm like, Oh, I don't like this.

This is not a controlled environment. Like it is in my house. So I thought it would be nice to get another thing that would just sit on my desk and like never actually have to go out into the elements. It's also

Devindra: nice to have a fail safe. It's nice to have another system to turn to if. your MacBook explodes or won't boot for some reason.

Like I think in general, if you're a professional, I hope not. If you're a professional that relies on your computers, the best thing you could do is have more than one computer. I think that's like a pretty, pretty good sound piece of advice. But you

Ben: said that the Mac mini might end up being underpowered due to, I think like inability to get heat

Devindra: out.

Can you say more about that? I mean, I think that was, I don't know if I had said that recently though, Ben, because like the, the M4, the M series chips in general don't get super hot. So I think that's partially why Apple was able to make this thing so much smaller. It is bringing in air, like the intake fans are like on the bottom.

You can see some fins there. So it is bringing in air and it's doing great. It's like dealing with heat in some ways, but how big can the fans actually be on a thing like this? I don't know. I think Apple had the video or had the thing in the actual let me see in their launch video.

Ben: I'm looking forward to seeing a teardown of this to see what the actual diameter of the fan is going to be.

Devindra: Yeah. I mean, it's probably just one big fan, I believe. But I don't think you need to worry about heat too much because the Apple Silicon chips in general. Don't generate that much heat so the fact that they can do this the fact that they can still have MacBook airs out there They're decently powerful with no fans is you know It's a testament to like what they've been doing in terms of low power

Ben: unless you have your desk in front of a window And Sun is coming down directly on it.

Maybe talked about a while ago. Then

Devindra: be safe You know, you could give your, give your Mac mini a little home, give it a little like sunshield box, you know, as long as there's airflow underneath because build a little cabana for it, a little cabana, but also make sure there's airflow in that cabana. When I was in it, like that was the thing people would complain, oh, my PC is always reboot properly.

I'm like, well, you have your. Desktop system in a cubby in a closet with a closed front door. There's no air coming through. You know, it's like you're choking your computer to death. I think that's less of a problem here. But anyway, I'm, I'm really excited about this thing. So Mark Dell in the chat says no Mac studio, no Mac studio.

Not yet. I think the MacStudio is still running M2 chips, right? So the thinking now is that there's going to be a spring event where we get more on M4 for MacStudio. There's also no MacBook Air announcement yet with M4 chips, but more on that soon. Yeah.

Ben: And I guess if you're talking about like visual branding or something like that, Apple might be like, okay, so now we can say that the Mac mini is truly mini, and they might use a similar.

Like slightly updated version of the case for the old Mac mini on the Mac studio. And they can say okay, now this is you're slightly bigger, but way more powerful entertainment production workstation.

Devindra: I don't, I don't think they need to do that at all. Like the Mac mini exists to be powerhouse where you don't have to worry about heat.

You don't have to worry about anything. And also they need to have room for all those ports on the Mac mini. So the Mac studio is what I mean. So the Mac studio is meant to be the more powerful thing. The thing is, nobody is buying the Mac pro like they updated the Mac pro. We saw that last year. Nobody can afford that thing.

It also functionally is not that much better than the max studio with the max chips or the pro chip. So I think the vast majority of creators, unless you're like high end visual effects, people at Disney or something, Are running Mac studios and you need room and in that

Ben: case you're actually just like throwing something to a render farm probably probably not doing it on your desktop probably

Devindra: I mean you're probably doing like pre renders and stuff on your desktop and then throwing it to render farm for final work certainly no final jobs are being done on an actual machine.

Single desktop, but you know, the, the Mac studio is a really interesting thing. And I wonder, I'm wondering if Apple's rethinking like how that thing is going to be positioned because it's much more expensive. I think for the vast majority of creatives, like this thing, this Mac mini with the M4 pro chip is kind of it, and I don't need it.

I certainly don't need it, but I am tempted to get one and make it my Plex server or something just make it a little headless system that sits somewhere that I can tap into.

Ben: But also think about it a tech guy like you probably has a lot of pretty decent monitors just lying around, and so if you're talking about the possibility of getting a iMac to set up in some public place for Sophia or, you know, both of your kids to use as they grow up.

Why not actually just get this? Cause this is really easy. It's also very portable. I'm certainly thinking about that. It's less of an investment

Devindra: for you. I bought my wife an ultrawide monitor for her like office space years ago. So she uses that occasionally with her laptop, but now there is an open space in our upstairs office area where we could just plug in a Mac mini and the kids can go.

But I can't bring that to like the kitchen, right? Or I can't bring that to downstairs. So the kids can do something where we're all around. And that's where it's

Ben: not an all in one,

Devindra: all in one. So that's where like the, the whole setup issues come in. Anyway, I'm freaking, I cannot wait to get my hands on this thing.

It is adorable. This is I think a testament to the whole idea of a small desktop too. Like if, if you had told me this is what a Mac mini would look like way back in 2005, 20, almost 20 years ago. You know, I would have been shocked because I was there used to digging into large Dell desktops and things like that.

That was my life back then. We have come so far. The only downside is like nothing is upgradable anymore. You can't upgrade the Ram. You can't swap out you know, your wifi card if something goes wrong. So that is the

Ben: price we pay for all that. And I think the last thing that came out during this Mac week was that the AirPods Pro 2 hearing features were finally released.

Is that true? That's one of the things.

Devindra: Yeah. The AirPods Pro 2 hearing features the hearing tests and all that stuff is up there. I believe we have a post on that so you can check to see. If the, if your AirPods think you have hearing issues, I think everybody should do this because we don't think enough about our hearing like what the status of our actual hearing is.

So

Ben: the thing that I still wish I got out of Apple's health app, cause I'm checking it all the time just to see how many steps I took. That's my pedometer. Then I see the other thing of you know, hearing check or something. This was, you know, an older version of iOS because I have an old phone as we've talked about.

It's telling me like how loud. The things I've been listening to are, and it only works when I have my wired earpods in. I really wish that they could have done something to make third party Bluetooth earbuds more compatible with the health app, because I am curious how much I'm putting into my ears every day.

Speaker: Yeah.

Ben: I work with these things and I can only get it like during the maybe like 20 minutes to 45 minutes a week. I spend using the ear pods for the best quality phone mic because sometimes I like to do business calls with that. And I think that honestly, if you're giving someone a Bluetooth.

Quality of your voice that sounds a little bit unprofessional. I want to sound as professional as possible. I

Devindra: think the AirPods mics, like if you're using an AirPod versus the EarPod versus the wire, it's, it's not a huge difference from what I

Ben: was saying. Yeah, I just don't have AirPods. I have

Devindra: Jabra.

Suggested by you. Yes, I did. That was years ago. That was certainly years ago. Now is a good time, Ben, to do that upgrade. Whenever you upgrade your iPhone, you're in the ecosystem, man. Now this is the thing like Apple can do, just

Ben: go for it.

Devindra: Apple can do this with AirPods, like to add in all these new features because they have their own wireless chip.

They can do things beyond what plain Bluetooth headsets have. Jabra doesn't even exist anymore. Jabra is not making headsets anymore or headphones. It sucks. It sucks that that company has just fully given up on the market. Yeah, but anyway, I think this is a cool feature. I also, this is tempting me as I want to get like a professional ear cleaning, which I know is a thing and is like the big social media hype thing right now, but I kind of want to do that.

I'm pretty sure you would, you would probably benefit a lot from that, Ben. Cause we, we always have stuff in our ears. Oh

Ben: yeah, no. I was told by a ENT that I have that kind of earwax, but we'll move on from that very quickly. Let's move on from the earwax talk. So, Also, MacBook Pro. We should talk about the MacBook Pro.

Oh, yeah, MacBook Pro. The last thing that I wanted to say about the hearing features is that I'm still reticent to use it. even if I could, even if I had all the equipment that I needed, just because getting that assessment, and then just having to sit with it, might be a little bit scary. That is human psychology.

I would much, yeah, so I'd much prefer doing a very similar thing at the combined ENT audiologist place, because then at least I can ask some follow up questions, rather than having to sit. there and feel branded with the Oh my God, I can't hear the mosquito tone anymore.

Devindra: Doing it at home may, may encourage more people to like, go get their ears checked out.

I think that's a big benefit here too. So that's, that's, it's, it's going to be a huge thing. I've not done that test yet. So I need to do that. We should talk about them. Okay. So MacBook Pro. They are getting the M4 chips they're gonna get the M4, M4 Pro, and the new M4 Max chip, which was also introduced this week.

Apple's not really giving us many details on these chips, by the way. We know the M4 Max is gonna be a 16 core CPU. The M4 Pro is a 14 core CPU, 20 core GPU. The plain M chip is available in either 8 or 10 core variations in a 10 core. GPU. So that's kind of like how they're scaling it. It's also why like the Mac Mini with the M4 Pro is twice the cost of the of the base Mac Mini.

That's just kind of what you're paying for there. There really aren't any changes, like not many major changes to the new MacBook Pros. They are bringing the space black color, which was on the 16 inch down to the 14 inch now. Everything starts with 16 gigabytes of RAM. Great. That was one of our complaints with the 14 inch MacBook Pro last time I reviewed it.

Let me see here. There's also this and the iMac also have a nano texture option for their screens. And that could be useful for anybody doing work in really bright environments or direct sunlight. So if you're like, if you're working in the desert and MacBook out there, you Even with a great high quality screen, there will be glare, it'll be hard to make things out.

The nanotexture stuff kind of erases a lot of that glare. From what I hear, it also messes with color accuracy and HDR output. So most people It would actually be a worse thing for most people, but if you are in that super bright environment, nanotexture could be great. The MacBook Pros have 1000 nits of SDR brightness now, up from 600 nits.

Also, they both have 12 megapixel center stage webcams. The iMac also has a better webcam. And before they just had 1080p, very basic 1080p cameras. So that's all, good thing. Same starting price for the MacBook Pros, 1599 for the 14 inch. 19. 99 for the M4 Pro model, the 16 inch still starts at 24. 99.

And also if you are in a school, take advantage of those education discounts because they shave off like easily a hundred bucks. And that, that makes a big difference. You know, do that. Many schools also offer like ways to buy, pay for things over time, or you could buy it from Apple store and do the paying over time and it builds your credit.

It's like a thing. I'm not going to say, go, go take out a loan on a computer, but you know, if you break up a more expensive device into smaller monthly payments, It hurts a lot less. That's how I freelanced and got decent computers while I was freelancing. So yeah,

Ben: how long has it been that the MacBook pro had 10 ADP cameras?

So finally, finally, I think since,

Devindra: I mean, it was, I think since I moved to the M one chip, Or since the M2, when the major MacBook pro redesign was, I was like late 2021, I believe then they got 1080p cameras and Apple just never really focused that much on cameras. We've complained about them forever, but now that they have center stage, now that they're doing more processing with the camera stuff.

And I think that's a big deal. Now Apple realized like, Oh yeah, people need to do a lot more video calls and video conferencing than they used to. The pandemic certainly accelerated that. So. There's that whole thing. One thing I do want to mention the MacBook airs, the current M two MacBook air and the and the M three modeled now also start with 16 gigabytes of Ram, the M two MacBook air starts at nine 99, the M three model starts at 10 99, just, just get that like it is.

We're spending an extra 100 for that 16 gigabytes of Ram. That's great.

Ben: And it's especially good because that's the computer that I know a lot of people will bring to college. And so it gives you a lot more wiggle room in terms of what you can do on that computer. You don't know what class you're going to end up taking.

You might end up taking a video editing or audio editing class. And I've watched people try to do heavy lift stuff on MacBook Airs, and it's been sad. It's

Devindra: been, I mean, that stuff has been sad, but I've seen people try to bring Chromebooks to college, you know, I'm like, I, I, I strongly, strongly, We're, you know, trying to get people out of Chromebooks for college stuff.

Like Chromebooks are great for grade school stuff right now. Like in kindergarten, my daughter occasionally messes with a Chromebook in school. That's the level of work you can do with a Chromebook maybe into high school. But once you're doing college work with like major programs, not so much.

Ben: Yeah, I don't think they're doing it because they think they can get away with a Chromebook.

I think it's because the Chromebooks are cheap.

Devindra: Oh, most definitely. Chromebooks, I mean, that's the thing, but we are, I'm at least trying to encourage people at least get a Windows laptop, at least get something that is a little more flexible and functional. And I think that would make a big difference, especially in college where you don't want to be like, Two or three years in like swapping computers and stuff, you know You kind of want to have something that lives with you for a while and it is your everything when you're in college, right?

It's your TV. It's your work machine. It's Everything everything for you. So anyway good news We don't know like what Apple intelligence will do down the line like will these features start to be super memory intensive? Will 16 gigabytes not feel like enough if you're running some crazy AI feature down the line?

We don't know We kind of don't know what any of that stuff is. But hey, for now, good news.

Ben: So I do have some questions from the chat and chat. Now is your time to put in additional questions because this is going to be on the final audio recording finally. And. If you want to participate in chat, remember stop in on the Engadget YouTube page, Thursday mornings.

That's U S Eastern time at 10 45. You can also join in. You can maybe have your name said on air as well. So, first one that we have is from Wes Jackson, and this was from early in the segment, and Wes Jackson was saying it's kind of a big yawn for everything, so maybe that's why they didn't do a song and dance.

Maybe that's why they didn't give us the silly graphs.

Devindra: Kind of. I mean, I could see Apple of yore doing an event, like some gathering for the Mac Mini, because I think the Mac Mini is worth celebrating. That is a cool design. It is like an engineering feat that they've been able to make that thing so small.

And then Danny Diaz says,

Ben: I like these mini events. The format allows me to digest the event right from Apple. Otherwise I just end up seeing the super cuts on YouTube anyway.

Devindra: Pretty much. I think that's, that's it. And Apple is aware of like people getting tired of these, the major events too. It's sort of the Marvel problem, sort of the Star Wars problem, right?

If you have too much, you dilute the market with things and people are less excited for when you actually have something big that you want them to pay attention to. So I'm sure Apple is well aware of that and changing attention spans. Maybe someday we'll see something happen entirely in a short form social media to like all span through 10 TikTok videos, you know, or 10 YouTube shorts to see this entire announcement.

Maybe we'll get there.

Ben: Buddy 305 love says to me specifically, Ben HP has been making pocket sized PCs for years. Yes. Do you know a model that I can

Devindra: go look up? Are they any good? Like Intel has been making small NUCs forever. A lot of PC companies have been doing this. I reviewed way back when, when I first started in gadget, like 2014, 2015, I used to review the Intel what do they call it?

The compute stick, which was just stick that plugged into your HD HDMI port. It. And that's it. That's it. Or no, it was a stick that you plug in. So it's like a

Ben: Roku that sticks into a TV and you can make an, a TV, a computer,

Devindra: basically. It was a cool thing that they could do, but they gave up on it because it was expensive and nobody was really using it.

And you were really limited what you could do with that form factor. So

Ben: I'm looking it up. It's like HP Elite Mini 800 G9 desktop PC. Yes. That looks pretty small. HP G2 Mini G9. So, this one, the Elite Mini. 800 G9 is 699. That's almost 700. And then the HP Z2 Mini G9 workstation, that's 1300. So we're getting toward Mac Mini with M4 Pro prices

Devindra: there.

Simon B. Ask a good question. Do we actually know what is Apple intelligence? Simon B, for the love of God, go to Engadget. com or search Google Engadget. com Apple intelligence, because we have been writing about this for the past six months.

Ben: Okay. What if they're asking a more conceptual, like existential question?

What, what, what is truth? What is

Devindra: truth? I mean, like the Apple intelligence, To recap for everybody is Apple spin on all the AI features we've seen coming to PCs and other systems. It's like the copilot stuff in windows, but Apple intelligence specifically is more focused on delivering features in things you're actually using.

So, if you have a newer iPhone. You get iOS 18. 1, take a look at your notifications and the way like you're instead of like a, a wall of 10 notifications from one of your cameras or something, you will get a condensed thing of Hey, saw somebody up front for a while, you know, or if you have a wall of messages or texts from your friends, it tries to condense that into a thing that is easily grokkable before diving into all the individual messages.

Ben: I don't like that X took Grok away from the old school sci fi fans. What you

Devindra: do is not even acknowledge what Grok, what X did. So how about we just use the word like we, like we normally do. Yeah, no,

Ben: and that, that is Heinlein. Yes. That is, that belongs to Heinlein. That belongs to someone who Yeah, and even he's not, not a great dude, but anyway, that's Buddy305love says that I should also check out the Atom Man X7 Ti yeah, this looks pretty cool.

I like the screen on the front that will show you like some stats about I think the temperature and, you know, maybe like how It's adorable. Full the SSD is like, yeah, that's that's cool. I didn't know that these existed. I'm sorry I'm just the producer. I apologize. They

Devindra: said this thing is super cool.

But what is what is the system Intel ultra 9? So you're using Intel's graphics hit or miss right like hit or miss with what you could do with that I think what's interesting about the Mac mini is that it is Apple's GPU stuff has been proven to be pretty good. Like you can, you can run some decent games on that.

More games are coming over to Mac steam support for some games is there. I'm just more overall impressed by the amount of computing work you could do. But yes, there are PC variants to this too. I don't think as small as a new Mac mini though, at least from what I've seen.

Ben: Yeah. And then Mark Dell says, Oh, my dad is using the AirPods pro and he's amazed by the hearing aid feature.

He says it's going to change his life.

Devindra: Yes. I've heard that from a bunch of people and not even not even older folks. Like they're people. In their twenties and thirties who have hearing issues and they don't want to be walking around with hearing aids because there's like a social stigma to it, or they don't want to like, just be doing that.

Now you could just have AirPods in and have some of that help. So that's great.

Ben: It's true, especially when I like go to a grocery store or something I see a lot of people who are working at the grocery store. Just have one air pod in their hand. That's what I do. It's how I live. Go off and listen to music.

Yeah, whatever. Whatever makes the shift more bearable. Oh, yeah, go ahead. But, it can also be a sneaky way of being like, Hey, you know what? I blew out my ears listening to like crazy dubstep music or something and now I have hearing loss. Earlier

Devindra: than I would think. There's totally that. I've been actually thinking Man, my life, my high school life would have been so different if I had like wireless earbuds like walk around and have stuff.

Because in high school, like I wish, I wish I could have portable music. I wish I could have a like way to shut out part of the world and stuff. That's a whole thing, but man, things are just so much different now. I see a good question from Wes Jackson. Does the power button on the bottom of the Mac mini bother us or the fact that the mouse, including the iMac and Mac mini still charges on the bottom.

I can tell you what Apple thinks about the mouse specifically, because people will still make fun of it. Whenever I bring this up to an Apple person, they're like well. You just have to plug it in for one minute. You plug it in for one minute and you get like tens of hours of charge time. So I think that's their thing.

They don't want like the visible, they would rather do that than give you a visible port on the bottom or the back of that thing. I also don't think they they've done the work to fully redesign the magic mouse, that whole thing. I. To a certain extent, I kind of understand that, you know, it's annoying when you lose power in the middle of a work session, but also your Mac will, will give you the heads up Hey, you're, you're charging, you don't live at your computer all day, so you could just as you're walking away, plug it in, it would be nice if there was an easier solution to that.

But I kind of understand why Apple is just not too bothered to fix it. The power button on the bottom of the Mac mini. I saw people talking about that too. It's like on the bottom rear corner, instead of like on a port on the back or something, or even directly a print. I know Apple wants to make that thing look clean.

Actually don't think that's a big deal because the magic keyboard has a power button and the way most people will be turning on their Mac is by sitting down, hitting the power button that is on their keyboard. The power button on the system itself is sort of like. Last resort type of thing. It's like you have a hard reset you need to do where you just need to cut power immediately.

You're not going to be in daily usage, reaching around and you know, tapping that power button. So I think that's, that's like the main thing there. Also, a lot of people don't shut down their Macs fully. I disagree with that.

Ben: I turned my computer off. I turned my laptop completely off. Ben, you bought the worst iPhone, so I

Devindra: cannot trust your judgment.

The smallest iPhone. Oh, God. No, but you're right. You're right. A lot of people do that, too. But the keyboard has the power button. Now, if you're using It wasn't the worst iPhone when I bought it. It was a decent iPhone when I bought it. We kind of warned you that that screen would be a problem. You would grow out of that.

But anyway If you have a PC keyboard on your Mac mini, then yeah, you are kind of screwed. Then you are going to be reaching around and you know, hitting that button. That's a pain, but it's not like the end of the world. That thing is tiny. You know, I don't think you're not like shoving it way back on your desk.

Cause you probably want it accessible for the USB port. So it's, it is a choice. Apple is building their systems for people who have Apple accessories. And I think that's mainly what they're thinking about here.

Ben: So if you want to also contribute to our live stream, I'm I say at the end of every live stream it gets cut off from the audio version that the live stream makes us smarter.

It remembers stuff that we forgot. Remember you can always tune in on the Engadget YouTube channel or send us an email at podcast at engadget. com

In other news, the FTC has told Lyft that it needs to tell drivers how much they're actually going to make. What a concept. I said a few weeks ago that I had just finished the, what is it? FX adaptation of super pumped the battle for Uber which was Mike Isaac's book about the founding of Uber and

Devindra: man.

Okay.

Ben: I mean, it's just cause I'm a big JGL head. I'm sorry. I watched angels in the outfield literally until the VHS tape. I've got thoughts about

Devindra: JGL and his current career trajectory, but yes, yes. Yes. Okay. We were referring to Joseph Gordon Levitt kids. If you are confused.

Ben: There was a B plot in the series where Austen Geidt, who was responsible for recruiting the majority of the first wave of drivers for uber Was promising up and down that like all these black car drivers were going to be making Something like double or triple what they were making Just doing traditional ride hailing or working for you know as a contractor for a company And the b plot also went through, you know, this very humble driver saying Oh, well, I want to make more money for my family and like You Tracking how Uber's promise did not actually come true for him, or it only existed for a few months.

So I think this is a fantastic step forward. It's definitely a bit more regulation, so if you don't like regulation, argue with the wall, maybe. Argue with the wall. I just want people to Like actually be able to plan their finances and the fact that These like rideshare services really everything as a service Sort of companies play a shell game with people who are otherwise low wage workers.

That's not

Devindra: great It's not great and also because Taxi driving used to be a pretty reliable job for a lot of people especially like immigrants moving to America like There are the jokes about immigrant taxi drivers, but it is a thing that people have done in New York. You, you work towards paying off like a taxi medallion, right?

Like you would buying a house. That's a, just an investment for you basically. So it's I've hated what these companies have all done. Like I was, I don't know if you remember this, Ben, you remember the era before Uber and Lifter and everything New York used to have Halo. Which I think was a London based startup.

There used to be like a couple different ones. If you're in New York, you can also hail normal cabs with the curb app. I really liked the curb app actually. But before then, I still see people using their hands. I use using your hand, New York. That's a great thing. It doesn't work at everywhere. I've learned in Las Vegas, you cannot hail a taxi because you have to do it at the hotel bases, basically, and taxi drivers get annoyed picking up anywhere else.

But yes, there used to be old ways of doing it. When these companies came in, like I, all I saw from Uber and Lyft was just like pure bullshit, pure bullshit to get themselves into markets and everything New York, because it had such a strong taxi. It has a taxi commission. It has a strong taxi industry.

They were able to resist. So you don't get Ubers with normal people driving in New York, New York, Uber drivers, Uber and Lyft drivers have to be like still technically limousine drivers. That's kind of the whole deal. Something I also learned when I moved away from New York you don't, you get bad drivers.

You get really bad drivers on Uber and Lyft because normal people just driving around in their cars. Not fun. Not great. Anyway, that's a good thing. That's a good thing. You also want to bring up this thing about OpenAI, Ben. I know you were interested in this. OpenAI's Whisper.

Ben: Yeah, because it's something that we use to transcribe the podcast now.

I just let my otter subscription lapse because. I was using it for another client. I was using it, you know, five or six times a week. So I figured, okay, yeah, I can take this off of my taxes. It's like a hundred dollars a year or something. Now. I'm not working with those folks anymore. So I don't know if I can really justify the expense of not using this five or six times a week.

So I'm like, okay, what else am I going to do? LLMs have gotten so much better for transcription especially. So let's go off and try this. I got Mac Whisper a while ago. And it's Good. It needs some work. I

Devindra: mean, because Mac whisperer

Ben: UI needs some work.

Devindra: I love Mac whisperer. We talked about it, but that essentially runs the whisper, the opening out with whisper model on your system.

So it takes forever. It takes especially on an M one system, Ben, it probably takes you like what, half an hour to an hour to transcribe a podcast or something.

Ben: No, not really. I mean, I had two hours of tape from like a bunch of different speakers. It didn't have diarization, which is the fancy way of saying like differentiation, which is essential if you're

Devindra: doing transcript.

If you want a transcription tool, it has to kind of do that. There

Ben: were so many different voices in this though. This is something that I recorded in a big, busy, you know, New York City park. I'm hanging out with this guy who he's doing an art project. This is a guy who is kind of running a stand, so people come up to him.

And so there are so many different speakers. I really wish that there were Additional speakers or, or that you could differentiate between speakers. But the thing that I haven't seen that is something that Reuters was talking about just at the end of last week is that OpenAI's Whisper has a tendency to just make stuff up whole cloth as if, you know, it's trying to infer maybe some garbled speech or something like that, and then it will just like kind of free associate.

And the problem is that people are using this in hospitals. That's a situation where you really can't have something just go off all crazy, especially because if it goes off all crazy and it sounds a little scary or something, like I saw some examples in the Associated Press, not Reuters, Reuters would get mad at me for that.

The, the AP article saying that You know, sometimes it got a little bit scary. It said you know, stuff about violence and knives and things like that. Hospitals have psych wards in them! It's very possible that you could have someone talking about that, and if you had some kind of, I don't know automatic flagging tool for whether or not to get someone a PsycheVal, that would be a PsycheVal based on OpenAI's free association.

But we're getting

Devindra: ahead of ourselves. It's a sensitive data environment. I think that's the main thing. So Hey, I use we've talked about using the tool descript. I use them for like producing our transcriptions and I go in and like tweak stuff, like people's names and like Hardaware names. It doesn't get right.

I use that also for producing the social media videos and the audiograms we put out. We are not. You know, we're, we're just a couple of people talking about technology. And I do look over the transcripts and I tweak things as I need to. I have basically been like, I'm okay if a couple words or some things are kind of wrong because the overall transcript is still a useful service to people who need it.

And it's also a useful service to like search engines and things like that. But in the medical environment, or if it's like sensitive legal information, like I would be really careful. About using any of these AI tools. Yeah.

Ben: So, the politicians are live streaming, once again. What do you have to say about that, Devendra?

Devindra: I do have to say about that. Let's flip to that video. Because what's happening, and I was so excited about this. First of all, I was really excited. When the news dropped that you know, Kamala Harris's VP candidate, Tim Walsh is a Dreamcast fan, is a Crazy Taxi fan. So over the weekend, I believe Tim Walsh and AOC did a Crazy Taxi live stream and it just brought back all, all the joy.

It's also, I don't, I don't think I don't think AOC has seen Crazy Taxi before. So it's also introducing a new person into this world and the That's surprising to me. Just like the, the insanity of crazy taxi. I love this game. I love the dreamcast. I've talked about how much I love the dreamcast, but Tim Tim was just has yeah, pure, pure love for it.

This was fun to see. And it was certainly a much more fun thing to talk about rather than the Nazi rally that happened in New York. So here's what I'm going to do. And to listeners to this podcast, all I can tell you is. This is a pretty, pretty important election for America for the future of this country.

So if you care about any of this stuff, you should probably vote. I'm not going to tell you who to vote for. But you know, read, read things, please read the news. Please read about what is actually happening. I will fully endorse on my end. Like I already voted for Kamala Harris and Tim Walz. I put in my early voting in Georgia.

Because I didn't want like any of the weird, like ballot mess that's going to happen. Like this next week is going to be a mess in this, in this state, in a lot of other States, we've already seen ballot boxes being set on fire. We've seen people intimidating others at voting, you know, at polling booths.

Not great. Just, it's going to be a really tough week. Please vote because yeah, this country depends on it. Ben, any, you want to add anything there?

Ben: Only that Tim Walz would probably love the Simpsons hit and run.

Devindra: Oh yeah, absolutely. He would totally love it. I mean, he would be what I, the, the real baller move would be like if Tim Walls just pulled out his like 1000 hour fantasy star online character, because the true dreamcast heads know the fantasy star online was one of the pioneering in games for like console RPGs.

It was barely an MMO, but on consoles, we didn't really have much. And the fact that you could plug in a 33. 6 modem or a 56 K modem on a dreamcast and play. An RPG over phone lines with people from your couch blew me the hell away. So, you know, I will always love you. Dreamcast. He

Ben: is most likely to have fantasy college football,

Devindra: I

Ben: think, rather than fantasy.

I mean, weren't they playing

Devindra: a Madden or something too? They were playing a football game. as well. So

Ben: of course, of course, of course. So the age of ice cream machine broke is finally over. McDonald's can finally service their own machines. They can finally get around the Hardaware locks. Finally, the FTC was like, you know what?

It is really dumb that you can only have one approved technician come and fix something that is Hardaware locked in this way. We don't have enough technicians. You can also. Charge exorbitant amounts of money. So if you're annoyed about, you know, the right to repair issues on your phones, computers, and laptops, if you're annoyed at Apple, especially because so many people are like, Oh my God, I like would never get.

Anything in the Apple ecosystem because of how difficult it is to fix, then you are already a right to repair advocate, and you should be throwing your votes behind maybe an administration that supports right to repair,

Devindra: too. Or workers, or things like that. Specifically, the mystery behind why McFlurry machines break down all the time is that McDonald's corporate has to send somebody, like an official repair person, to fix that machine at every franchise.

Exactly.

Ben: Yeah. And so it is ends up being a game of you can't put out enough fires because everybody loves the McFlurries, so they're going to be used a lot, which means that the moving parts are going to get end up getting messed up. And the next thing we need to do is the same thing, but for John Deere tractors.

Devindra: I mean, It's

Ben: right to repair all the way down. Right

Devindra: to repair all the way down. I mean, we saw a bunch of stories. Farmers are like hacking their, their tractors to fix them. Right. That is, that is the way things should be. And it's funny to talk about this now too, because we were also talking about man, that Mac mini sure is adorable and cute.

You got nothing to repair there, buddy. Like it's all, it's all one little chip and like a circuit board. I'm like, nothing is fully removable and you can't really do much. You can open it up. But there's nothing much that you can do as a consumer. So that is the price we pay for like cute, well, you know, pretty looking electronics.

We kind of miss that. We kind of miss that sometimes. And sometimes you need to just dive in and fix a big machine. So hopefully this will mean more working McFlurries. Are you a big McFlurry consumer, Ben?

Ben: I was actually like within the last few years, I've started thinking like, man, I got to Change my relationship with food.

Not that it was bad or anything. It's just like I'm the only one looking out for myself

Devindra: Also, you're you're getting older Ben. You're gonna feel it. You're feeling it We are watching here, by the way, the I fix a video about why the McFlurry machines are always broken And how to fix them. So thank you to I fix it for always.

Thank you for your service. I fix it. I've always wondered what's going on back there. My kids, like we try to avoid McDonald's honestly, but I don't, I don't have any major qualms around it, but I think we went on vacation last year at some point. The McDonald's was like the only thing at the rest stop to go to.

And now my daughter calls it a happy dinner. All she wants is a happy dinner once in a while. And that's great. That's great. She doesn't demand it. Honestly, I wish she would demand happy meals more often because what she does demand instead is like the stuff I've started giving her. She really likes pho.

She really likes poke. These kids, that's expensive and difficult to do. It's expensive. And then yeah, I can, I could get that delivery 20 for a single, you know, thing for her. Also, I don't know what happened to pho, but at least out here in Georgia, we have a huge immigrant population, a lot of great food from all across Asia, but God damn.

Everything is expensive. Pad Thai 20, 20 before delivery fees. Pad Thai is a five. It should be a 5 dish that you get really easily at a local restaurant or something, but anyway. That's that's the news. Thank you. Hopefully the McFlurries will feel better. I want to shout out a couple of things that we just covered here at NNGadget.

First of all, we have a review of the Kindle ColorSoft. Valentina Palladino, our deputy editor of commerce and buying advice, covered that for us. She's calls it the missing link in Amazon's e reader lineup. Score of 84. She really likes it. And this thing looks cool. We were doing some comparisons, like in Slack, we were comparing it to like the Kobo color reader.

And I think we all noticed that the Kobo's color screen looks a little more saturated, like the colors are just punchier, but Valentina still likes this, and if you're in the Kindle ecosystem, I can't blame you for all your books and your entire libraries there. This is certainly a good option. I have been a Kindle user for a long time.

Last year, I picked up a Kobo e reader just to start separating myself from Amazon. And you know, what's really tough is having multiple e readers. Because then it's Oh, my, my other library is over there. Tell

Ben: us more about your first world problem.

Devindra: It's a really annoying thing. This is how it works.

This is how like the lock in happens is that you can't just bring your Amazon library to Kobo or something. You can put some of those books on your computer and do the, whatever stripping it is to make it an EPUB book and then get that over to Kobo. But man, that's just a pain. So I, I dunno, I'm doing new books on Kobo old books.

I'm still haven't really are still on my Kindle. The color soft looks very cool. I think that's a big takeaway we can have here. I still don't know if like a Kindle. I don't know if I need a color e reader. I would love like a bigger color thing that would be better for comics, but tablet screens have gotten so good, especially with OLED Oh, I'm just such a big old fan.

I think that's the main thing for me. We also have a review of the DJI action Osmo action five pro. for Mr. Steve Dent. He says it's finally a worthy GoPro rival. So that's that's a good thing. Are you an action camera fan Ben? I'd like to be.

Ben: I'd like to have a little drone just to play around with.

Devindra: For you, I would more recommend the DJI Osmo Pocket, which is a little, the portable little camera we use because you may occasionally be doing video production stuff. But you know, I like an action camera. I bought a GoPro like a couple of years ago and I swear to God, I have not actually been able to use it for anything.

It's a, it's very much an aspirational device. My, we do, we do have a small drone and you know what the drone does? It flies up to my roof and make sure there are no more holes in my roof or chimney, like it's, the drone goes places.

Ben: That's actually a great way to inspect your own roof. I've never thought about that.

A

Devindra: lot of roofing companies will just send a drone up there

Ben: to do the inspection. Wow. Yeah, that's really smart. It's a way to not get on a ladder because so many surgeons say don't get on a ladder for the love of God. And also, it's

Devindra: super easy it takes, you know, a couple minutes to throw a drone up there and you have a high quality camera and a real time feed and all that stuff.

So anyway.

Ben: That seems like the sort of thing that homeowner's insurance should be covering

Devindra: sometimes. It's a whole thing, Ben. Yes, yes. It does sort of cover it. What roofers do is that they go around neighborhoods and Hey your, your roof's looking kind of old. We can help you get it covered under insurance.

Like it's a whole, they just fly a drone around where they're like, well, we're, we're helping your neighbors and we will throw the drone up there. And they will work to make sure your insurance will pay for the new roof, which can cost like 20, 000 or so. Doing it through insurance. It's like maybe a thousand dollars or whatever for your co pay or 2000.

So yes to action cameras, Ben, I feel like first of all, in terms of what we're working on, I'm working on a lot of stuff. Apple just announced the four different products. Somebody's gonna have to review those products. So some of us, some of us are going to be heads. You know, I'm basically neck deep in a lot of like testing of things right now.

There's a new game console coming soon. We're testing that. We're reviewing that. Let's move on to pics. What do you got?

Ben: It's over the garden wall season, everybody. It's the 10 year anniversary. They did a 10 year anniversary concert in LA, the blasting company that did all of the music for over the garden wall.

Elijah Wood was there. A lot of the original voices were there. Unfortunately, Jack Jones, who is the singing voice of the frog and also just sang a A couple of the other marquee songs for Over the Garden Wall. He was 89 when he died. So he lived a good long life. And you could kind of tell that this was being sung by a kind of gentle voiced old man too.

He had that, that sweetness in his voice. So if you don't know what I'm talking about, this is a mini series from Cartoon Network that premiered in 2014. It is a little bit of just a send up to the holiday season. Spooky season fall season. It is also an adaptation of Dante's. Oh, yes, it

Devindra: is It was also a lot of David the Gnome in there.

I mean, come on. I love David the Gnome

Ben: Yeah, it is. Also it feels very, you know old American and European like mythological and it's also like a huge, huge homage. Why'd I say that? I don't know. It's a homage to classic animation. So this is the animation of the 1930s or so. Rubber hoe, there is one episode that is like really, really relies on rubber hose animation.

of

Devindra: like Fleischer looking stuff in here.

Ben: Yeah. It's about two brothers who get lost in the woods and their entire The goal is to get out. And so if you know about basic mythology and a little bit about Dante's Inferno, you know what's going to happen. They get chased around by spooky stuff. They meet different crazy characters.

It has become a really classic rewatch for a lot of people. I don't know how many other things have been, like, canonized, like Over the Garden Wall has. In the last 15 years,

Devindra: you know, it's, it's very, it's not like a usually popular thing, but it has like basically garnered like a huge cult audience, which I think kind of the perfect thing for this.

So yeah, good show, good show. Check it out. It was also like unavailable to stream for a long time to you. So I'm happy to see that's a, that's a big thing. Let me just, I'm looking at the thing here. Yeah. We're not going to play this trailer. I want to shout out, I want to shout out the Netflix remake of Ranma one half, which is remember, remember that anime series?

Rama was like a classic eighties anime series about a boy who turns into a girl when he gets hit with water and his father turns into a panda. It's comedy. Kind of a romantic comedy, a situational comedy, also action series at time. Cause there was always a lot of good fighting. It's been remade for Netflix, basically following, at least from what I've seen, I've seen the first couple episodes kind of follows the exact same path as the original, but the animation is nice and clean.

It's still a fun watch and you know, it's, it's cozy anime. That is the sort of thing where I'm just like, I could just sit down really enjoy this J pop intro song, the really soothing ending song. It's funny. The action's pretty good too. Like it just looks cool. So I want to shut that out. Like for anime fans.

If you've not seen Ranma before, you can see the original. That is up on Crunchyroll right now. The animation's good. I think that's a, that's a good thing. Especially what happened to Uzumaki, which had a good first episode, and then the animation just went super, super bad. Downhill after that. So Ranma 1. 5 is my recommendation, especially if you checked out Dandadan, like I recommended it's good stuff.

Very different tonally. Very different tonally, but also I feel like a good chaser. Like Dandadan is pure, it's just like a little, a little like crazy, mad, you know, crazy mad anime. And Ranma is much more chill, even though it's about like much more fantastical stuff. Time. So good stuff.

Ben: Thanks everybody for listening.

Our theme music is by game composer, Dale North. Our outro music is by our former managing editor, Terrence O'Brien. The podcast is produced by me, Ben Elman. You can find Devendra online

Devindra: at Devendra on Twitter, BlueSky, Mastodon, everywhere. And a podcast about movies and TV at the Filmcast, at the Filmcast.

Ben: You can find me online at, I don't know, just listen to your router and I might be whispering to you. Don't try to contact me. No, I'm just kidding. If you want to see my old tweets, find me on Twitter. Hey, Bellman H E Y B E L L M A N. Email us at podcast at Engadget. com. Leave us a review on iTunes and subscribe on anything that gets podcasts.

That includes Spotify.

Why'd I say that? It's a homage.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/engadget-podcast-apples-m4-chip-heads-to-the-imac-mac-mini-and-macbook-pro-132004332.html?src=rss

Engadget Podcast: Apple’s M4 chip heads to the iMac, Mac mini and MacBook Pro

It's been a Mac-heavy week! In this episode, Devindra and producer Ben Ellman dive into all of Apple's new M4 hardware: the new iMac, Mac mini and refreshed Macbook Pros. The Mac mini, in particular, looks like it'll be a huge hit for anyone who needs a simple desktop system. Also, we dive into why Apple is pushing for every Mac to get 16GB of RAM at a minimum. That will benefit all users, even if they don't care about Apple Intelligence.


Listen below or subscribe on your podcast app of choice. If you've got suggestions or topics you'd like covered on the show, be sure to email us or drop a note in the comments! And be sure to check out our other podcast, Engadget News!

  • Unofficial Mac Week: Apple announces M4 Pro and M4 Max chips in refreshed iMac, Mac Mini, and Macbook Pro models – 0:58

  • Regulators force Lyft to tell U.S. drivers accurate numbers of how much money they’ll make – 45:30

  • AP report: OpenAI’s Whisper transcription model invents parts of audio transcripts – 49:06

  • AOC and Tim Walz streamed Crazy Taxi on Twitch – 53:11

  • McDonalds can finally repair their own McFlurry machines in significant win for Right to repair – 55:54

  • Around Engadget – 59:45

  • Pop culture picks – 1:03:42

Hosts: Devindra Hardawar and Ben Ellman
Producer: Ben Ellman
Music: Dale North and Terrence O'Brien

Devindra: What's up internet? Welcome back to the Engadget Podcast I'm senior editor Devindra Hardawar. This week, I'm joined by our podcast producer, Ben Ellman. Hey, Ben.

Ben: Hello. How's it going?

Devindra: Hello. It's going good. Kind of a light ship this week because a lot of people are out. Everyone's on taking some break and a lot of people are just busy at Engadget.

So it's just going to be us. But we've got a lot of news to dive into all of Apple's new Macs with M4 chips, the M4 Pro and M4 Max as well, that they all just announced this week. There's a lot of new stuff and I'm excited to talk about it as always, folks. So if you're enjoying the show, please be sure to subscribe to us on iTunes or your podcatcher of choice.

Leave us a review on iTunes. Drop us an email at podcast@engadget.com. And also, yeah, you can join us Thursday mornings, typically around 1045 AM Eastern on our YouTube channel for our live stream so we can do some Q& A. In fact, we'll be including some of those questions and our answers later in this episode as well.

So, yeah, tune in for that. Ben, you are somebody who I know is fully in the Mac ecosystem, and I also know you're very conscientious. Well, unfortunately, or for what you do, you're kind of there, but you're also very conscientious about how you upgrade, right? Because we're dragging you into a modern iPhone and things like that.

How did you feel about all these new Macs? Because we have the M4 iMac, we have an adorable new Mac mini, which is tiny, absolutely tiny, and M4 chips on the MacBook Pros. Is anything particularly compelling to you?

Ben: So as I was reading up on the Mac, All of the stuff they released this week. I saw the line that said something like the M four, I think it was Pro Chip is now like three times faster than the now ancient M1,

Devindra: it is four.

That chip is four years old now. So that

Ben: cut me like a knife. But that is M1 Classic, not M1 Pro.

Devindra: Yes, I

Ben: do believe that. My research says that the M1 Pro is only two times slower than this new M4 Pro. Please fact check me on this. Send us an email at podcast adding gadget. If I didn't get that right.

Devindra: I mean, you, you bring up a good point though, Ben, be sure to be very clear about what Apple is comparing its devices to, right?

Because they often go back to base M1, which. Was released at the end of 2020 2020. It took a full year before we got the M4 Pro and M4 Max chips, right. Before they really expanded the line. No,

Ben: you mean M1 Pro and M1 Max. M1 Pro and M1 Max.

Devindra: Yeah. So remember that there was that time difference when they, they just dropped the M1 on us and that was on the MacBook Air, MacBook Pro 13 inch, which was a fricking waste of time and the Mac mini, I believe back then, right.

So.

Ben: But then this calls back to a bigger contextual question that I have. Why is Apple doing this? They are just releasing a bunch of stuff kind of quietly. They're putting it on the website. They're sending out like press releases and stuff. Usually they love to bring everyone onto the campus like they did just a couple of months ago and show you nonsensical stuff.

graphs with absolutely no measurements on them, saying how much faster this chip is than a chip that they released a few years ago. Is there any like chatter on why

Devindra: they're doing it kind of quietly like this? Yeah. So, I mean, let's talk about what happened this week, right? So they announced last week, or they confirmed that there will be.

a series of Mac news announcements, but we didn't, we didn't know if it would just be a live stream. We didn't know if it would just be video recordings and news drops. And that's what it ended up being. They love

Ben: a song and dance and there has been no song and

Devindra: dance. I mean, I feel it, you know, I'm sure even Apple is tired of hosting these song and dances or media events.

And yeah. Especially for machines that aren't like too different than before. The Mac mini is like a new one. The Mac mini like looks interesting. And I feel like Apple of yore would have done at least a small press event in New York or something to show off that particular piece of Hardaware. But also, I don't know, man, everyone's tired.

I feel like that's what we're feeling right now. You know, everyone's tired. We are. In this election cycle, which is just about to end, and I feel like they kind of got the news out there, right? They produced a couple of videos. They said, Hey, I mean, we just announced the M4 chip. Here's the M4 Pro and M4 Max.

Here are new systems. You kind of know what the deal is. And I feel like that's pretty much it.

Ben: Are you saying that they might be playing some kind of meta game where they're like, you know what, we're not going to ask all these tech journalists to fly out again and eat half to three quarters of their week going to hang out with us.

Because their grumpiness about having to do that, when it's getting toward the end of the year and they've got so much else on their plate, might bleed into man, why did they fly us out for this? Yes, there are improvements, but I think it's even unbearable. I think

Devindra: They are tired too, like to produce an event, to coordinate everything for a launch.

It's a lot of work. And I feel like even the people at Apple are like, you know, we don't need to go this hard. Like they produced a couple of videos. They got the press releases out there. They pre briefed some press. So I got a bit of early info on this. I didn't get early info on the iMac.

There are reports that they held some sort of hand hands on event. In L. A. At least that's what Mark Gurman said in his newsletter, and I have not seen any of those things out yet. So maybe those hands on will drop later today or tomorrow or something. And to be fair, the

Ben: iPhone 16 launch event was on Monday, September 9th, which means that it was just a month and a half ago.

Devindra: Yeah, it's, I feel like they're done. Like the major things for Apple are the iPhone events, maybe, maybe like a product event early in the year and then WWDC, you know, so, and the other thing is maybe we are amidst the like delayed launch of Apple intelligence. Right. Which also launched this week across devices with iOS 18.

1 and the MacOS stuff. And I also wonder if Apple's just like tired of answering questions about that. Like even that was like a muted, Hey here are a few Apple intelligence features that new Siri, not here yet. That'll be here soon. And also all this stuff is being slow rolled out. So strategy wise, what we saw Apple do, I think last year, Ben, I think they just did one day where they.

Posted a video and was just like, Hey, here's all the news. I wonder if this is a new strategy for Apple where they did it throughout the week, little tidbits of news, and we're talking about it throughout the entire week and they own that week, you know? So I think there's a lot of value to that.

Ben: Yeah.

Same thing is not dropping a entire. series of a show all at once, because if you do it weekly, like you used to, then people are talking about it week to week. The whole like entertainment news industrial complex can do their recaps and everything.

Devindra: Exactly, exactly. So let's take a look at what Apple is has launched this week.

On Monday, we got the new iMac M4 With brighter colors, I guess you could say we're talking brighter

Ben: colors on the front or the back

Devindra: on the back, right? There's no real colors on the real. No, you get the front colors to you have the like little chin on the iMac, but is the design that thinner design they launched with the M one chips now in slightly brighter colors?

M four chip also has, let me just see here. It also has a trend that we started seeing this week, 16 gigabytes of RAM. As the base amount without changing the base price. So who can we

Ben: thank for that?

Devindra: I would, I would say AI, I would say Apple intelligence. And that's also something we've seen throughout this entire year, but I'll get to that.

So 1299 for the new M4 iMac has 16GB of RAM, has much Faster Hardaware, at least with this M four chip. There are four USBC ports on the pricier one with a 10 core CPU and GPU for the M four, I assume you'll get less on the cheaper one. You can upgrade up to 32 gigabytes of ram. This is a nice system. I like the new imax.

Have you seen these things, Ben? In action?

Ben: I'm gonna be straight up with you. I have not seen a iMac inaction really since maybe before college or something. You've been in a Mac store, Ben. Come on. Okay. Yes. I've been in a Mac store, but like I haven't seen them in the wild outside of their enclosure for a very long time for a while.

That was like the way that you signaled to people, especially in education settings that your educational institution had money. Sure. And that actually gets to another question of okay, you have these Pretty colored anodized aluminum backs for the IMAX. And what do they do in most like non open plan office settings?

They're going to be pointed for the wall. Probably you're not even going to be

Devindra: able to enjoy them. You get, you get some color on the front. You get color on the base. The bases all have color too. And honestly, a lot of open offices have they're not pointing at the wall, right? They're, they're cubicles or like mini desks, in the middle of the room and maybe sometimes facing each other. I love this machine. Like I, Apple just did a great job of making the sink super slim. It is very light. It's easy to move around. You certainly couldn't, you know, mistake it for a laptop or something. But when I reviewed the M1 iMac, was it the M2?

Like whatever the last one I reviewed, like I was just so impressed at being able to to move that thing around to just And I remember portability

Ben: was part of the original like pitch for this, like years and years ago.

Devindra: Yeah, like you could bring it from your den to your, you know, dining room or something and do something with your kids and then bring it back.

It's just one cable. You plug it in. You haul over the accessories. It's not that tough. So I've actually for a while been contemplating just getting an iMac, like one of these new iMacs and having it be like the family computer, especially for my daughter, who's getting more into computing stuff right now, like she is.

Big on iPad. She's big on touchscreens. Minecraft is like the thing she does and she has some like iPad reading games and language games and stuff. So this would

Ben: be like the living room computer or something could

Devindra: be, and we have a space for it, or we move it up to an upstairs office or something.

But I just see the value here. So I think this is a great machine. It's great to have new Hardaware in here. Even better that it has 16 gigabytes of RAM. And yeah, as you were saying, Ben, I think we really can thank Apple intelligence for that. Mark Gurman in his last newsletter reported that you know, we've seen Apple intelligence basically eat up eight gigabytes of RAM on its own.

So because it's running large models, large language models and different things, and it's no wonder that. Microsoft's Copilot Plus PCs, those AI PCs also require at least 16 gigabytes of RAM. I think what we're seeing is like that is the cost of running these AI models because what they're doing is basically chewing up large amounts of data or processing it against your current data and that takes memory.

And I think for the longest time PC makers were like, hey, eight gigabytes, that's fine, right? They kind of drag their heels even moving beyond four gigabytes. When we review systems, we always recommend go for at least 16 gigabytes. You don't really want to be opening up your computer and adding in more RAM.

And even for newer computers you can't really do that. You can't do that with Apple's Hardaware because the RAM is built onto the processor. So, this is good. It's a good thing. Even if you don't care about Apple intelligence, you can thank AI for this, at least. So, that's the iMac. Any, any thoughts? Are you compelled by

Ben: this?

And you've been talking about, like, why do they even sell an 8 gig RAM version for a few years now? Because as the IT person, both formerly professionally and IT person of your family, For life, basically, yeah. Yeah. Always on call to be like, okay, well, you know what, I, I think I just want a laptop that like can do word processing and then all of a sudden somebody is like, Oh, well, my kid wants to edit a video on it.

And that's all it takes to justify a upgrade to 16 gigs.

Devindra: Exactly. And I mean, the cost in the past also wasn't that much, but it was still something. And a lot of Mainstream buyers just didn't go for it. I think this is a good thing. This is a good thing for everybody. Certainly like for the people who never made that bump before, when I talked to Apple before, why eight gigabytes was still the thing they were doing, they kept telling me like the M series chips are more memory efficient.

Which is kind of technically true. So they could maybe stretch eight gigabytes of Ram more than before. They're also the memory bandwidth was faster than before because the memory chips are right there next to the CPU. And it can all be processed much more quickly. But yeah, 16, 16 gigabytes is the standard.

And now I'm introducing a new standard folks. If you're listening to this show, if you like to play games. If you like to edit the occasional video or something, or just put something up on Instagram or or TikTok, 32 gigabytes of RAM. Let's go, let's go all in on 32 gigabytes of RAM. How much RAM do you have in your MacBook, Ben?

Ben: I told you 32 gigs, and that was partially subsidized by COVID stimulus checks. There is

Devindra: that too. But 32 gigabytes really gives you room to breathe. And if you're working on a large project, Then yeah, that's something that you definitely want. So I'm just putting that out there now that 16 gigabytes seems like the baseline standard more, most folks will be fine with that, but if you are a pro, a prosumer, if you're a creative professional, at least 32 gigabytes, now Mac and PC would be a good.

Yeah.

Ben: I feel like my position on the show is to act as the non expert, but still smarter than maybe the average user, a little bit smarter than the average user. And so when I was specking out this laptop. I was thinking, okay, I want the M1 Pro because it's still going to be, like, so much of an upgrade over the Intel chip in my 2012 era MacBook Pro.

And also, I want to be able to future proof it, so I didn't know what was going to happen in the future. Generative AI, all of that stuff was just getting started around the time when I finally Pushed purchase on this laptop and I'm really happy that I did some future proofing and went for the 32 gig option

Devindra: Definitely always future proofing especially I think our recommendation was Ben that you do that because what you can't do You can't open up a Mac of any kind now not a laptop not a desktop unless it's a Mac Pro No, you can't even do with the Mac Pro because the Mac Pro is also running an M series chip.

There is no memory upgrades are not a thing anymore, at least on a self contained chip like this. So yeah, buy as much as you can you know, suffer a little bit to put more RAM in there if you have to.

Ben: Okay. So let's talk about this adorable Mac Mini. I

Devindra: think the Mac mini is the star of the week, right?

Because this thing we expected new Mac mini Mark Gurman was reporting like there would be some sort of small redesign. It is small or small as internet would say it it's five inches by five inches. It measures two inches tall. If you look at the pictures, like it's just like on somebody's fingertips.

This is a. It's a small boy, but it's not a weak boy because it has the M4 chip. And it also introduced the M4 pro chip, which is supposed to be really, really fast. And this is a good time to think about what the Mac mini represents to you. Like I remember when this thing came out, I was also working in it.

around 2005. That original Mac Mini was kind of a slow little box, but it was an interesting idea that not many people were doing. I honestly think you can, you can like really trace the small PC trend back to the Mac Mini because Intel's NUCs and other things people did kind of followed with what that was.

Do you have any experience with the Mac Mini? Ben, any thoughts on the previous Mac Minis?

Ben: The studio that I used to work at on the Upper West Side ran entirely on a Mac Mini.

Devindra: Amazing. Like you can, and that was like years ago, right? That was like before the M series Mac. Oh yeah,

Ben: yeah, no. And this was also done by like old school audio engineers who really value the stability of their like workspaces over everything.

So they are very slow to upgrade. And this thing was still chugging along really well.

Devindra: Yeah, yeah. I mean, so the Mac mini has been a great thing for a while. The last one did that one get the M3 chip? I think they had skipped that one, but the last Mac mini I reviewed where they introduced the pro chip for the first time.

That thing blew me away because that thing was just super fast. It kind of delivered most of what you wanted from a Mac studio, but it was far cheaper than studio with the pro chip, it was still more expensive than like the base model. It was like 1299. Let me look up that review actually.

Ben: Plus it looks like it's small enough to fit in the enormous pockets of JNCO jeans that are coming back in style.

Very slowly.

Devindra: Honestly, I don't even think you need like big baggy JNCO jeans. Really saying, I think this thing could fit in like a normal jean pocket, or at least I've been able to fit large packages in mine. I don't know. That's the whole like thing. This it's, it's adorably small. I think, you know, the Mac mini has just been something when I reviewed the the M2 pro mini last year.

Early last year, that was January 28th, 2023. I was just super impressed by the M2 Pro chip. And they're kind of doing that again here. I think for most people, this is kind of all the desktop you need. Certainly all the Mac desktop you need. It's also like the. Only new one with an M Pro chip that you can, er, an M4 chip that you'll be able to buy.

The Mac Studio has not been updated yet, so they're projecting like maybe spring for that. But you know what, like this thing, this thing is great. This thing is so tiny you can put it pretty much anywhere. It also comes with 16 gigabytes of RAM standard. Still starts at 599 with the base M4 chip. But that's, yeah,

Ben: that's base M4.

That's still pretty powerful. Also, yeah. Let's talk about the ports for a second too. So they're all

Devindra: Thunderbolt now? They're all the rear ones I believe are Thunderbolt because they have the little Thunderbolt picture on them But let's talk about those ports because you'll notice something up front that we complained about with the last review Ports up front Last year, if you wanted like a Mac with accessible USB ports up front, you had to get a Mac Studio.

That was like one of the big reasons to do it. And it almost seemed it seems like Apple saw that criticism and directly addressed that. So there were two USB C ports up front. There's also the headphone jack up front. Around the back the base M4 model gets you Thunderbolt 4 support, which is, which is pretty good.

But if you go up to the M4 Pro, you get Thunderbolt 5 support. And that is really interesting. It's the first time we've seen Thunderbolt 5 on Macs. It's also it's not really on many PC systems yet. I had written up Thunderbolt 5 last year. Let me see here. It delivers up to three times the bandwidth of Thunderbolt 3.

So that's pretty good memory, like a memory bandwidth should also be much better with the new Thunderbolt. So that's kind of interesting because it does open up the. Door for better external GPU support. We didn't really like external GPU docs for a while because Thunderbolt three and before were just a little slow.

If you bought a nice CPU, you were not getting all that speed. Now you could potentially do that. I've also seen Apple and others talk about things like AI accelerators, which are just like little GPU boxes, basically that just do AI work, not even for like games. Yeah. So that's what that opens up.

And that M4 pro. Mac mini starts at 13. 99. That's what you'd pay for a decently powerful desktop, you know? So if you are somebody working in audio or video and you don't need the full capabilities of the Mac studio, which is especially

Ben: video, because if you need to Dump like 120 GBPS onto a drive or something.

That's probably going to be video. That's probably going to be like really complicated, like 3d rendering or something like that's an

Devindra: enormous amount

Ben: of

Devindra: data. That's a ton of data. That's the main thing. And 1399, Hey, it is much more expensive than the base model, but that is a really powerful little system.

And look at how far we've come from like the giant desktop towers. I have a giant desktop tower down here. Okay. A pocketable desktop computer. That's nuts. It's just, it's, it's super great. It's one of those things where I've showed this to people and they were like, I don't really need this, but I want to give it a home.

I want to find a place for it. Yeah.

Ben: Because it looks like a puppy. It's adorable. But also, that reminds me, a few weeks ago when we were talking off stream, off podcast, I was saying something about how maybe it would be worth investing in a, Mac mini, because it's just every time I take my laptop out, especially because this is like the biggest investment that I think I've ever made.

I have never bought a car and this thing that I have in front of me right now is the price of, let's say, a kind of decent used car circa 2019. A while ago, before the pandemic.

Devindra: Maybe, maybe 2019, but it depends. I mean, how much So Yeah, go ahead.

Ben: Every time I take it out in the wild, I'm like, Oh, I don't like this.

This is not a controlled environment. Like it is in my house. So I thought it would be nice to get another thing that would just sit on my desk and like never actually have to go out into the elements. It's also

Devindra: nice to have a fail safe. It's nice to have another system to turn to if. your MacBook explodes or won't boot for some reason.

Like I think in general, if you're a professional, I hope not. If you're a professional that relies on your computers, the best thing you could do is have more than one computer. I think that's like a pretty, pretty good sound piece of advice. But you

Ben: said that the Mac mini might end up being underpowered due to, I think like inability to get heat

Devindra: out.

Can you say more about that? I mean, I think that was, I don't know if I had said that recently though, Ben, because like the, the M4, the M series chips in general don't get super hot. So I think that's partially why Apple was able to make this thing so much smaller. It is bringing in air, like the intake fans are like on the bottom.

You can see some fins there. So it is bringing in air and it's doing great. It's like dealing with heat in some ways, but how big can the fans actually be on a thing like this? I don't know. I think Apple had the video or had the thing in the actual let me see in their launch video.

Ben: I'm looking forward to seeing a teardown of this to see what the actual diameter of the fan is going to be.

Devindra: Yeah. I mean, it's probably just one big fan, I believe. But I don't think you need to worry about heat too much because the Apple Silicon chips in general. Don't generate that much heat so the fact that they can do this the fact that they can still have MacBook airs out there They're decently powerful with no fans is you know It's a testament to like what they've been doing in terms of low power

Ben: unless you have your desk in front of a window And Sun is coming down directly on it.

Maybe talked about a while ago. Then

Devindra: be safe You know, you could give your, give your Mac mini a little home, give it a little like sunshield box, you know, as long as there's airflow underneath because build a little cabana for it, a little cabana, but also make sure there's airflow in that cabana. When I was in it, like that was the thing people would complain, oh, my PC is always reboot properly.

I'm like, well, you have your. Desktop system in a cubby in a closet with a closed front door. There's no air coming through. You know, it's like you're choking your computer to death. I think that's less of a problem here. But anyway, I'm, I'm really excited about this thing. So Mark Dell in the chat says no Mac studio, no Mac studio.

Not yet. I think the MacStudio is still running M2 chips, right? So the thinking now is that there's going to be a spring event where we get more on M4 for MacStudio. There's also no MacBook Air announcement yet with M4 chips, but more on that soon. Yeah.

Ben: And I guess if you're talking about like visual branding or something like that, Apple might be like, okay, so now we can say that the Mac mini is truly mini, and they might use a similar.

Like slightly updated version of the case for the old Mac mini on the Mac studio. And they can say okay, now this is you're slightly bigger, but way more powerful entertainment production workstation.

Devindra: I don't, I don't think they need to do that at all. Like the Mac mini exists to be powerhouse where you don't have to worry about heat.

You don't have to worry about anything. And also they need to have room for all those ports on the Mac mini. So the Mac studio is what I mean. So the Mac studio is meant to be the more powerful thing. The thing is, nobody is buying the Mac pro like they updated the Mac pro. We saw that last year. Nobody can afford that thing.

It also functionally is not that much better than the max studio with the max chips or the pro chip. So I think the vast majority of creators, unless you're like high end visual effects, people at Disney or something, Are running Mac studios and you need room and in that

Ben: case you're actually just like throwing something to a render farm probably probably not doing it on your desktop probably

Devindra: I mean you're probably doing like pre renders and stuff on your desktop and then throwing it to render farm for final work certainly no final jobs are being done on an actual machine.

Single desktop, but you know, the, the Mac studio is a really interesting thing. And I wonder, I'm wondering if Apple's rethinking like how that thing is going to be positioned because it's much more expensive. I think for the vast majority of creatives, like this thing, this Mac mini with the M4 pro chip is kind of it, and I don't need it.

I certainly don't need it, but I am tempted to get one and make it my Plex server or something just make it a little headless system that sits somewhere that I can tap into.

Ben: But also think about it a tech guy like you probably has a lot of pretty decent monitors just lying around, and so if you're talking about the possibility of getting a iMac to set up in some public place for Sophia or, you know, both of your kids to use as they grow up.

Why not actually just get this? Cause this is really easy. It's also very portable. I'm certainly thinking about that. It's less of an investment

Devindra: for you. I bought my wife an ultrawide monitor for her like office space years ago. So she uses that occasionally with her laptop, but now there is an open space in our upstairs office area where we could just plug in a Mac mini and the kids can go.

But I can't bring that to like the kitchen, right? Or I can't bring that to downstairs. So the kids can do something where we're all around. And that's where it's

Ben: not an all in one,

Devindra: all in one. So that's where like the, the whole setup issues come in. Anyway, I'm freaking, I cannot wait to get my hands on this thing.

It is adorable. This is I think a testament to the whole idea of a small desktop too. Like if, if you had told me this is what a Mac mini would look like way back in 2005, 20, almost 20 years ago. You know, I would have been shocked because I was there used to digging into large Dell desktops and things like that.

That was my life back then. We have come so far. The only downside is like nothing is upgradable anymore. You can't upgrade the Ram. You can't swap out you know, your wifi card if something goes wrong. So that is the

Ben: price we pay for all that. And I think the last thing that came out during this Mac week was that the AirPods Pro 2 hearing features were finally released.

Is that true? That's one of the things.

Devindra: Yeah. The AirPods Pro 2 hearing features the hearing tests and all that stuff is up there. I believe we have a post on that so you can check to see. If the, if your AirPods think you have hearing issues, I think everybody should do this because we don't think enough about our hearing like what the status of our actual hearing is.

So

Ben: the thing that I still wish I got out of Apple's health app, cause I'm checking it all the time just to see how many steps I took. That's my pedometer. Then I see the other thing of you know, hearing check or something. This was, you know, an older version of iOS because I have an old phone as we've talked about.

It's telling me like how loud. The things I've been listening to are, and it only works when I have my wired earpods in. I really wish that they could have done something to make third party Bluetooth earbuds more compatible with the health app, because I am curious how much I'm putting into my ears every day.

Speaker: Yeah.

Ben: I work with these things and I can only get it like during the maybe like 20 minutes to 45 minutes a week. I spend using the ear pods for the best quality phone mic because sometimes I like to do business calls with that. And I think that honestly, if you're giving someone a Bluetooth.

Quality of your voice that sounds a little bit unprofessional. I want to sound as professional as possible. I

Devindra: think the AirPods mics, like if you're using an AirPod versus the EarPod versus the wire, it's, it's not a huge difference from what I

Ben: was saying. Yeah, I just don't have AirPods. I have

Devindra: Jabra.

Suggested by you. Yes, I did. That was years ago. That was certainly years ago. Now is a good time, Ben, to do that upgrade. Whenever you upgrade your iPhone, you're in the ecosystem, man. Now this is the thing like Apple can do, just

Ben: go for it.

Devindra: Apple can do this with AirPods, like to add in all these new features because they have their own wireless chip.

They can do things beyond what plain Bluetooth headsets have. Jabra doesn't even exist anymore. Jabra is not making headsets anymore or headphones. It sucks. It sucks that that company has just fully given up on the market. Yeah, but anyway, I think this is a cool feature. I also, this is tempting me as I want to get like a professional ear cleaning, which I know is a thing and is like the big social media hype thing right now, but I kind of want to do that.

I'm pretty sure you would, you would probably benefit a lot from that, Ben. Cause we, we always have stuff in our ears. Oh

Ben: yeah, no. I was told by a ENT that I have that kind of earwax, but we'll move on from that very quickly. Let's move on from the earwax talk. So, Also, MacBook Pro. We should talk about the MacBook Pro.

Oh, yeah, MacBook Pro. The last thing that I wanted to say about the hearing features is that I'm still reticent to use it. even if I could, even if I had all the equipment that I needed, just because getting that assessment, and then just having to sit with it, might be a little bit scary. That is human psychology.

I would much, yeah, so I'd much prefer doing a very similar thing at the combined ENT audiologist place, because then at least I can ask some follow up questions, rather than having to sit. there and feel branded with the Oh my God, I can't hear the mosquito tone anymore.

Devindra: Doing it at home may, may encourage more people to like, go get their ears checked out.

I think that's a big benefit here too. So that's, that's, it's, it's going to be a huge thing. I've not done that test yet. So I need to do that. We should talk about them. Okay. So MacBook Pro. They are getting the M4 chips they're gonna get the M4, M4 Pro, and the new M4 Max chip, which was also introduced this week.

Apple's not really giving us many details on these chips, by the way. We know the M4 Max is gonna be a 16 core CPU. The M4 Pro is a 14 core CPU, 20 core GPU. The plain M chip is available in either 8 or 10 core variations in a 10 core. GPU. So that's kind of like how they're scaling it. It's also why like the Mac Mini with the M4 Pro is twice the cost of the of the base Mac Mini.

That's just kind of what you're paying for there. There really aren't any changes, like not many major changes to the new MacBook Pros. They are bringing the space black color, which was on the 16 inch down to the 14 inch now. Everything starts with 16 gigabytes of RAM. Great. That was one of our complaints with the 14 inch MacBook Pro last time I reviewed it.

Let me see here. There's also this and the iMac also have a nano texture option for their screens. And that could be useful for anybody doing work in really bright environments or direct sunlight. So if you're like, if you're working in the desert and MacBook out there, you Even with a great high quality screen, there will be glare, it'll be hard to make things out.

The nanotexture stuff kind of erases a lot of that glare. From what I hear, it also messes with color accuracy and HDR output. So most people It would actually be a worse thing for most people, but if you are in that super bright environment, nanotexture could be great. The MacBook Pros have 1000 nits of SDR brightness now, up from 600 nits.

Also, they both have 12 megapixel center stage webcams. The iMac also has a better webcam. And before they just had 1080p, very basic 1080p cameras. So that's all, good thing. Same starting price for the MacBook Pros, 1599 for the 14 inch. 19. 99 for the M4 Pro model, the 16 inch still starts at 24. 99.

And also if you are in a school, take advantage of those education discounts because they shave off like easily a hundred bucks. And that, that makes a big difference. You know, do that. Many schools also offer like ways to buy, pay for things over time, or you could buy it from Apple store and do the paying over time and it builds your credit.

It's like a thing. I'm not going to say, go, go take out a loan on a computer, but you know, if you break up a more expensive device into smaller monthly payments, It hurts a lot less. That's how I freelanced and got decent computers while I was freelancing. So yeah,

Ben: how long has it been that the MacBook pro had 10 ADP cameras?

So finally, finally, I think since,

Devindra: I mean, it was, I think since I moved to the M one chip, Or since the M2, when the major MacBook pro redesign was, I was like late 2021, I believe then they got 1080p cameras and Apple just never really focused that much on cameras. We've complained about them forever, but now that they have center stage, now that they're doing more processing with the camera stuff.

And I think that's a big deal. Now Apple realized like, Oh yeah, people need to do a lot more video calls and video conferencing than they used to. The pandemic certainly accelerated that. So. There's that whole thing. One thing I do want to mention the MacBook airs, the current M two MacBook air and the and the M three modeled now also start with 16 gigabytes of Ram, the M two MacBook air starts at nine 99, the M three model starts at 10 99, just, just get that like it is.

We're spending an extra 100 for that 16 gigabytes of Ram. That's great.

Ben: And it's especially good because that's the computer that I know a lot of people will bring to college. And so it gives you a lot more wiggle room in terms of what you can do on that computer. You don't know what class you're going to end up taking.

You might end up taking a video editing or audio editing class. And I've watched people try to do heavy lift stuff on MacBook Airs, and it's been sad. It's

Devindra: been, I mean, that stuff has been sad, but I've seen people try to bring Chromebooks to college, you know, I'm like, I, I, I strongly, strongly, We're, you know, trying to get people out of Chromebooks for college stuff.

Like Chromebooks are great for grade school stuff right now. Like in kindergarten, my daughter occasionally messes with a Chromebook in school. That's the level of work you can do with a Chromebook maybe into high school. But once you're doing college work with like major programs, not so much.

Ben: Yeah, I don't think they're doing it because they think they can get away with a Chromebook.

I think it's because the Chromebooks are cheap.

Devindra: Oh, most definitely. Chromebooks, I mean, that's the thing, but we are, I'm at least trying to encourage people at least get a Windows laptop, at least get something that is a little more flexible and functional. And I think that would make a big difference, especially in college where you don't want to be like, Two or three years in like swapping computers and stuff, you know You kind of want to have something that lives with you for a while and it is your everything when you're in college, right?

It's your TV. It's your work machine. It's Everything everything for you. So anyway good news We don't know like what Apple intelligence will do down the line like will these features start to be super memory intensive? Will 16 gigabytes not feel like enough if you're running some crazy AI feature down the line?

We don't know We kind of don't know what any of that stuff is. But hey, for now, good news.

Ben: So I do have some questions from the chat and chat. Now is your time to put in additional questions because this is going to be on the final audio recording finally. And. If you want to participate in chat, remember stop in on the Engadget YouTube page, Thursday mornings.

That's U S Eastern time at 10 45. You can also join in. You can maybe have your name said on air as well. So, first one that we have is from Wes Jackson, and this was from early in the segment, and Wes Jackson was saying it's kind of a big yawn for everything, so maybe that's why they didn't do a song and dance.

Maybe that's why they didn't give us the silly graphs.

Devindra: Kind of. I mean, I could see Apple of yore doing an event, like some gathering for the Mac Mini, because I think the Mac Mini is worth celebrating. That is a cool design. It is like an engineering feat that they've been able to make that thing so small.

And then Danny Diaz says,

Ben: I like these mini events. The format allows me to digest the event right from Apple. Otherwise I just end up seeing the super cuts on YouTube anyway.

Devindra: Pretty much. I think that's, that's it. And Apple is aware of like people getting tired of these, the major events too. It's sort of the Marvel problem, sort of the Star Wars problem, right?

If you have too much, you dilute the market with things and people are less excited for when you actually have something big that you want them to pay attention to. So I'm sure Apple is well aware of that and changing attention spans. Maybe someday we'll see something happen entirely in a short form social media to like all span through 10 TikTok videos, you know, or 10 YouTube shorts to see this entire announcement.

Maybe we'll get there.

Ben: Buddy 305 love says to me specifically, Ben HP has been making pocket sized PCs for years. Yes. Do you know a model that I can

Devindra: go look up? Are they any good? Like Intel has been making small NUCs forever. A lot of PC companies have been doing this. I reviewed way back when, when I first started in gadget, like 2014, 2015, I used to review the Intel what do they call it?

The compute stick, which was just stick that plugged into your HD HDMI port. It. And that's it. That's it. Or no, it was a stick that you plug in. So it's like a

Ben: Roku that sticks into a TV and you can make an, a TV, a computer,

Devindra: basically. It was a cool thing that they could do, but they gave up on it because it was expensive and nobody was really using it.

And you were really limited what you could do with that form factor. So

Ben: I'm looking it up. It's like HP Elite Mini 800 G9 desktop PC. Yes. That looks pretty small. HP G2 Mini G9. So, this one, the Elite Mini. 800 G9 is 699. That's almost 700. And then the HP Z2 Mini G9 workstation, that's 1300. So we're getting toward Mac Mini with M4 Pro prices

Devindra: there.

Simon B. Ask a good question. Do we actually know what is Apple intelligence? Simon B, for the love of God, go to Engadget. com or search Google Engadget. com Apple intelligence, because we have been writing about this for the past six months.

Ben: Okay. What if they're asking a more conceptual, like existential question?

What, what, what is truth? What is

Devindra: truth? I mean, like the Apple intelligence, To recap for everybody is Apple spin on all the AI features we've seen coming to PCs and other systems. It's like the copilot stuff in windows, but Apple intelligence specifically is more focused on delivering features in things you're actually using.

So, if you have a newer iPhone. You get iOS 18. 1, take a look at your notifications and the way like you're instead of like a, a wall of 10 notifications from one of your cameras or something, you will get a condensed thing of Hey, saw somebody up front for a while, you know, or if you have a wall of messages or texts from your friends, it tries to condense that into a thing that is easily grokkable before diving into all the individual messages.

Ben: I don't like that X took Grok away from the old school sci fi fans. What you

Devindra: do is not even acknowledge what Grok, what X did. So how about we just use the word like we, like we normally do. Yeah, no,

Ben: and that, that is Heinlein. Yes. That is, that belongs to Heinlein. That belongs to someone who Yeah, and even he's not, not a great dude, but anyway, that's Buddy305love says that I should also check out the Atom Man X7 Ti yeah, this looks pretty cool.

I like the screen on the front that will show you like some stats about I think the temperature and, you know, maybe like how It's adorable. Full the SSD is like, yeah, that's that's cool. I didn't know that these existed. I'm sorry I'm just the producer. I apologize. They

Devindra: said this thing is super cool.

But what is what is the system Intel ultra 9? So you're using Intel's graphics hit or miss right like hit or miss with what you could do with that I think what's interesting about the Mac mini is that it is Apple's GPU stuff has been proven to be pretty good. Like you can, you can run some decent games on that.

More games are coming over to Mac steam support for some games is there. I'm just more overall impressed by the amount of computing work you could do. But yes, there are PC variants to this too. I don't think as small as a new Mac mini though, at least from what I've seen.

Ben: Yeah. And then Mark Dell says, Oh, my dad is using the AirPods pro and he's amazed by the hearing aid feature.

He says it's going to change his life.

Devindra: Yes. I've heard that from a bunch of people and not even not even older folks. Like they're people. In their twenties and thirties who have hearing issues and they don't want to be walking around with hearing aids because there's like a social stigma to it, or they don't want to like, just be doing that.

Now you could just have AirPods in and have some of that help. So that's great.

Ben: It's true, especially when I like go to a grocery store or something I see a lot of people who are working at the grocery store. Just have one air pod in their hand. That's what I do. It's how I live. Go off and listen to music.

Yeah, whatever. Whatever makes the shift more bearable. Oh, yeah, go ahead. But, it can also be a sneaky way of being like, Hey, you know what? I blew out my ears listening to like crazy dubstep music or something and now I have hearing loss. Earlier

Devindra: than I would think. There's totally that. I've been actually thinking Man, my life, my high school life would have been so different if I had like wireless earbuds like walk around and have stuff.

Because in high school, like I wish, I wish I could have portable music. I wish I could have a like way to shut out part of the world and stuff. That's a whole thing, but man, things are just so much different now. I see a good question from Wes Jackson. Does the power button on the bottom of the Mac mini bother us or the fact that the mouse, including the iMac and Mac mini still charges on the bottom.

I can tell you what Apple thinks about the mouse specifically, because people will still make fun of it. Whenever I bring this up to an Apple person, they're like well. You just have to plug it in for one minute. You plug it in for one minute and you get like tens of hours of charge time. So I think that's their thing.

They don't want like the visible, they would rather do that than give you a visible port on the bottom or the back of that thing. I also don't think they they've done the work to fully redesign the magic mouse, that whole thing. I. To a certain extent, I kind of understand that, you know, it's annoying when you lose power in the middle of a work session, but also your Mac will, will give you the heads up Hey, you're, you're charging, you don't live at your computer all day, so you could just as you're walking away, plug it in, it would be nice if there was an easier solution to that.

But I kind of understand why Apple is just not too bothered to fix it. The power button on the bottom of the Mac mini. I saw people talking about that too. It's like on the bottom rear corner, instead of like on a port on the back or something, or even directly a print. I know Apple wants to make that thing look clean.

Actually don't think that's a big deal because the magic keyboard has a power button and the way most people will be turning on their Mac is by sitting down, hitting the power button that is on their keyboard. The power button on the system itself is sort of like. Last resort type of thing. It's like you have a hard reset you need to do where you just need to cut power immediately.

You're not going to be in daily usage, reaching around and you know, tapping that power button. So I think that's, that's like the main thing there. Also, a lot of people don't shut down their Macs fully. I disagree with that.

Ben: I turned my computer off. I turned my laptop completely off. Ben, you bought the worst iPhone, so I

Devindra: cannot trust your judgment.

The smallest iPhone. Oh, God. No, but you're right. You're right. A lot of people do that, too. But the keyboard has the power button. Now, if you're using It wasn't the worst iPhone when I bought it. It was a decent iPhone when I bought it. We kind of warned you that that screen would be a problem. You would grow out of that.

But anyway If you have a PC keyboard on your Mac mini, then yeah, you are kind of screwed. Then you are going to be reaching around and you know, hitting that button. That's a pain, but it's not like the end of the world. That thing is tiny. You know, I don't think you're not like shoving it way back on your desk.

Cause you probably want it accessible for the USB port. So it's, it is a choice. Apple is building their systems for people who have Apple accessories. And I think that's mainly what they're thinking about here.

Ben: So if you want to also contribute to our live stream, I'm I say at the end of every live stream it gets cut off from the audio version that the live stream makes us smarter.

It remembers stuff that we forgot. Remember you can always tune in on the Engadget YouTube channel or send us an email at podcast at engadget. com

In other news, the FTC has told Lyft that it needs to tell drivers how much they're actually going to make. What a concept. I said a few weeks ago that I had just finished the, what is it? FX adaptation of super pumped the battle for Uber which was Mike Isaac's book about the founding of Uber and

Devindra: man.

Okay.

Ben: I mean, it's just cause I'm a big JGL head. I'm sorry. I watched angels in the outfield literally until the VHS tape. I've got thoughts about

Devindra: JGL and his current career trajectory, but yes, yes. Yes. Okay. We were referring to Joseph Gordon Levitt kids. If you are confused.

Ben: There was a B plot in the series where Austen Geidt, who was responsible for recruiting the majority of the first wave of drivers for uber Was promising up and down that like all these black car drivers were going to be making Something like double or triple what they were making Just doing traditional ride hailing or working for you know as a contractor for a company And the b plot also went through, you know, this very humble driver saying Oh, well, I want to make more money for my family and like You Tracking how Uber's promise did not actually come true for him, or it only existed for a few months.

So I think this is a fantastic step forward. It's definitely a bit more regulation, so if you don't like regulation, argue with the wall, maybe. Argue with the wall. I just want people to Like actually be able to plan their finances and the fact that These like rideshare services really everything as a service Sort of companies play a shell game with people who are otherwise low wage workers.

That's not

Devindra: great It's not great and also because Taxi driving used to be a pretty reliable job for a lot of people especially like immigrants moving to America like There are the jokes about immigrant taxi drivers, but it is a thing that people have done in New York. You, you work towards paying off like a taxi medallion, right?

Like you would buying a house. That's a, just an investment for you basically. So it's I've hated what these companies have all done. Like I was, I don't know if you remember this, Ben, you remember the era before Uber and Lifter and everything New York used to have Halo. Which I think was a London based startup.

There used to be like a couple different ones. If you're in New York, you can also hail normal cabs with the curb app. I really liked the curb app actually. But before then, I still see people using their hands. I use using your hand, New York. That's a great thing. It doesn't work at everywhere. I've learned in Las Vegas, you cannot hail a taxi because you have to do it at the hotel bases, basically, and taxi drivers get annoyed picking up anywhere else.

But yes, there used to be old ways of doing it. When these companies came in, like I, all I saw from Uber and Lyft was just like pure bullshit, pure bullshit to get themselves into markets and everything New York, because it had such a strong taxi. It has a taxi commission. It has a strong taxi industry.

They were able to resist. So you don't get Ubers with normal people driving in New York, New York, Uber drivers, Uber and Lyft drivers have to be like still technically limousine drivers. That's kind of the whole deal. Something I also learned when I moved away from New York you don't, you get bad drivers.

You get really bad drivers on Uber and Lyft because normal people just driving around in their cars. Not fun. Not great. Anyway, that's a good thing. That's a good thing. You also want to bring up this thing about OpenAI, Ben. I know you were interested in this. OpenAI's Whisper.

Ben: Yeah, because it's something that we use to transcribe the podcast now.

I just let my otter subscription lapse because. I was using it for another client. I was using it, you know, five or six times a week. So I figured, okay, yeah, I can take this off of my taxes. It's like a hundred dollars a year or something. Now. I'm not working with those folks anymore. So I don't know if I can really justify the expense of not using this five or six times a week.

So I'm like, okay, what else am I going to do? LLMs have gotten so much better for transcription especially. So let's go off and try this. I got Mac Whisper a while ago. And it's Good. It needs some work. I

Devindra: mean, because Mac whisperer

Ben: UI needs some work.

Devindra: I love Mac whisperer. We talked about it, but that essentially runs the whisper, the opening out with whisper model on your system.

So it takes forever. It takes especially on an M one system, Ben, it probably takes you like what, half an hour to an hour to transcribe a podcast or something.

Ben: No, not really. I mean, I had two hours of tape from like a bunch of different speakers. It didn't have diarization, which is the fancy way of saying like differentiation, which is essential if you're

Devindra: doing transcript.

If you want a transcription tool, it has to kind of do that. There

Ben: were so many different voices in this though. This is something that I recorded in a big, busy, you know, New York City park. I'm hanging out with this guy who he's doing an art project. This is a guy who is kind of running a stand, so people come up to him.

And so there are so many different speakers. I really wish that there were Additional speakers or, or that you could differentiate between speakers. But the thing that I haven't seen that is something that Reuters was talking about just at the end of last week is that OpenAI's Whisper has a tendency to just make stuff up whole cloth as if, you know, it's trying to infer maybe some garbled speech or something like that, and then it will just like kind of free associate.

And the problem is that people are using this in hospitals. That's a situation where you really can't have something just go off all crazy, especially because if it goes off all crazy and it sounds a little scary or something, like I saw some examples in the Associated Press, not Reuters, Reuters would get mad at me for that.

The, the AP article saying that You know, sometimes it got a little bit scary. It said you know, stuff about violence and knives and things like that. Hospitals have psych wards in them! It's very possible that you could have someone talking about that, and if you had some kind of, I don't know automatic flagging tool for whether or not to get someone a PsycheVal, that would be a PsycheVal based on OpenAI's free association.

But we're getting

Devindra: ahead of ourselves. It's a sensitive data environment. I think that's the main thing. So Hey, I use we've talked about using the tool descript. I use them for like producing our transcriptions and I go in and like tweak stuff, like people's names and like Hardaware names. It doesn't get right.

I use that also for producing the social media videos and the audiograms we put out. We are not. You know, we're, we're just a couple of people talking about technology. And I do look over the transcripts and I tweak things as I need to. I have basically been like, I'm okay if a couple words or some things are kind of wrong because the overall transcript is still a useful service to people who need it.

And it's also a useful service to like search engines and things like that. But in the medical environment, or if it's like sensitive legal information, like I would be really careful. About using any of these AI tools. Yeah.

Ben: So, the politicians are live streaming, once again. What do you have to say about that, Devendra?

Devindra: I do have to say about that. Let's flip to that video. Because what's happening, and I was so excited about this. First of all, I was really excited. When the news dropped that you know, Kamala Harris's VP candidate, Tim Walsh is a Dreamcast fan, is a Crazy Taxi fan. So over the weekend, I believe Tim Walsh and AOC did a Crazy Taxi live stream and it just brought back all, all the joy.

It's also, I don't, I don't think I don't think AOC has seen Crazy Taxi before. So it's also introducing a new person into this world and the That's surprising to me. Just like the, the insanity of crazy taxi. I love this game. I love the dreamcast. I've talked about how much I love the dreamcast, but Tim Tim was just has yeah, pure, pure love for it.

This was fun to see. And it was certainly a much more fun thing to talk about rather than the Nazi rally that happened in New York. So here's what I'm going to do. And to listeners to this podcast, all I can tell you is. This is a pretty, pretty important election for America for the future of this country.

So if you care about any of this stuff, you should probably vote. I'm not going to tell you who to vote for. But you know, read, read things, please read the news. Please read about what is actually happening. I will fully endorse on my end. Like I already voted for Kamala Harris and Tim Walz. I put in my early voting in Georgia.

Because I didn't want like any of the weird, like ballot mess that's going to happen. Like this next week is going to be a mess in this, in this state, in a lot of other States, we've already seen ballot boxes being set on fire. We've seen people intimidating others at voting, you know, at polling booths.

Not great. Just, it's going to be a really tough week. Please vote because yeah, this country depends on it. Ben, any, you want to add anything there?

Ben: Only that Tim Walz would probably love the Simpsons hit and run.

Devindra: Oh yeah, absolutely. He would totally love it. I mean, he would be what I, the, the real baller move would be like if Tim Walls just pulled out his like 1000 hour fantasy star online character, because the true dreamcast heads know the fantasy star online was one of the pioneering in games for like console RPGs.

It was barely an MMO, but on consoles, we didn't really have much. And the fact that you could plug in a 33. 6 modem or a 56 K modem on a dreamcast and play. An RPG over phone lines with people from your couch blew me the hell away. So, you know, I will always love you. Dreamcast. He

Ben: is most likely to have fantasy college football,

Devindra: I

Ben: think, rather than fantasy.

I mean, weren't they playing

Devindra: a Madden or something too? They were playing a football game. as well. So

Ben: of course, of course, of course. So the age of ice cream machine broke is finally over. McDonald's can finally service their own machines. They can finally get around the Hardaware locks. Finally, the FTC was like, you know what?

It is really dumb that you can only have one approved technician come and fix something that is Hardaware locked in this way. We don't have enough technicians. You can also. Charge exorbitant amounts of money. So if you're annoyed about, you know, the right to repair issues on your phones, computers, and laptops, if you're annoyed at Apple, especially because so many people are like, Oh my God, I like would never get.

Anything in the Apple ecosystem because of how difficult it is to fix, then you are already a right to repair advocate, and you should be throwing your votes behind maybe an administration that supports right to repair,

Devindra: too. Or workers, or things like that. Specifically, the mystery behind why McFlurry machines break down all the time is that McDonald's corporate has to send somebody, like an official repair person, to fix that machine at every franchise.

Exactly.

Ben: Yeah. And so it is ends up being a game of you can't put out enough fires because everybody loves the McFlurries, so they're going to be used a lot, which means that the moving parts are going to get end up getting messed up. And the next thing we need to do is the same thing, but for John Deere tractors.

Devindra: I mean, It's

Ben: right to repair all the way down. Right

Devindra: to repair all the way down. I mean, we saw a bunch of stories. Farmers are like hacking their, their tractors to fix them. Right. That is, that is the way things should be. And it's funny to talk about this now too, because we were also talking about man, that Mac mini sure is adorable and cute.

You got nothing to repair there, buddy. Like it's all, it's all one little chip and like a circuit board. I'm like, nothing is fully removable and you can't really do much. You can open it up. But there's nothing much that you can do as a consumer. So that is the price we pay for like cute, well, you know, pretty looking electronics.

We kind of miss that. We kind of miss that sometimes. And sometimes you need to just dive in and fix a big machine. So hopefully this will mean more working McFlurries. Are you a big McFlurry consumer, Ben?

Ben: I was actually like within the last few years, I've started thinking like, man, I got to Change my relationship with food.

Not that it was bad or anything. It's just like I'm the only one looking out for myself

Devindra: Also, you're you're getting older Ben. You're gonna feel it. You're feeling it We are watching here, by the way, the I fix a video about why the McFlurry machines are always broken And how to fix them. So thank you to I fix it for always.

Thank you for your service. I fix it. I've always wondered what's going on back there. My kids, like we try to avoid McDonald's honestly, but I don't, I don't have any major qualms around it, but I think we went on vacation last year at some point. The McDonald's was like the only thing at the rest stop to go to.

And now my daughter calls it a happy dinner. All she wants is a happy dinner once in a while. And that's great. That's great. She doesn't demand it. Honestly, I wish she would demand happy meals more often because what she does demand instead is like the stuff I've started giving her. She really likes pho.

She really likes poke. These kids, that's expensive and difficult to do. It's expensive. And then yeah, I can, I could get that delivery 20 for a single, you know, thing for her. Also, I don't know what happened to pho, but at least out here in Georgia, we have a huge immigrant population, a lot of great food from all across Asia, but God damn.

Everything is expensive. Pad Thai 20, 20 before delivery fees. Pad Thai is a five. It should be a 5 dish that you get really easily at a local restaurant or something, but anyway. That's that's the news. Thank you. Hopefully the McFlurries will feel better. I want to shout out a couple of things that we just covered here at NNGadget.

First of all, we have a review of the Kindle ColorSoft. Valentina Palladino, our deputy editor of commerce and buying advice, covered that for us. She's calls it the missing link in Amazon's e reader lineup. Score of 84. She really likes it. And this thing looks cool. We were doing some comparisons, like in Slack, we were comparing it to like the Kobo color reader.

And I think we all noticed that the Kobo's color screen looks a little more saturated, like the colors are just punchier, but Valentina still likes this, and if you're in the Kindle ecosystem, I can't blame you for all your books and your entire libraries there. This is certainly a good option. I have been a Kindle user for a long time.

Last year, I picked up a Kobo e reader just to start separating myself from Amazon. And you know, what's really tough is having multiple e readers. Because then it's Oh, my, my other library is over there. Tell

Ben: us more about your first world problem.

Devindra: It's a really annoying thing. This is how it works.

This is how like the lock in happens is that you can't just bring your Amazon library to Kobo or something. You can put some of those books on your computer and do the, whatever stripping it is to make it an EPUB book and then get that over to Kobo. But man, that's just a pain. So I, I dunno, I'm doing new books on Kobo old books.

I'm still haven't really are still on my Kindle. The color soft looks very cool. I think that's a big takeaway we can have here. I still don't know if like a Kindle. I don't know if I need a color e reader. I would love like a bigger color thing that would be better for comics, but tablet screens have gotten so good, especially with OLED Oh, I'm just such a big old fan.

I think that's the main thing for me. We also have a review of the DJI action Osmo action five pro. for Mr. Steve Dent. He says it's finally a worthy GoPro rival. So that's that's a good thing. Are you an action camera fan Ben? I'd like to be.

Ben: I'd like to have a little drone just to play around with.

Devindra: For you, I would more recommend the DJI Osmo Pocket, which is a little, the portable little camera we use because you may occasionally be doing video production stuff. But you know, I like an action camera. I bought a GoPro like a couple of years ago and I swear to God, I have not actually been able to use it for anything.

It's a, it's very much an aspirational device. My, we do, we do have a small drone and you know what the drone does? It flies up to my roof and make sure there are no more holes in my roof or chimney, like it's, the drone goes places.

Ben: That's actually a great way to inspect your own roof. I've never thought about that.

A

Devindra: lot of roofing companies will just send a drone up there

Ben: to do the inspection. Wow. Yeah, that's really smart. It's a way to not get on a ladder because so many surgeons say don't get on a ladder for the love of God. And also, it's

Devindra: super easy it takes, you know, a couple minutes to throw a drone up there and you have a high quality camera and a real time feed and all that stuff.

So anyway.

Ben: That seems like the sort of thing that homeowner's insurance should be covering

Devindra: sometimes. It's a whole thing, Ben. Yes, yes. It does sort of cover it. What roofers do is that they go around neighborhoods and Hey your, your roof's looking kind of old. We can help you get it covered under insurance.

Like it's a whole, they just fly a drone around where they're like, well, we're, we're helping your neighbors and we will throw the drone up there. And they will work to make sure your insurance will pay for the new roof, which can cost like 20, 000 or so. Doing it through insurance. It's like maybe a thousand dollars or whatever for your co pay or 2000.

So yes to action cameras, Ben, I feel like first of all, in terms of what we're working on, I'm working on a lot of stuff. Apple just announced the four different products. Somebody's gonna have to review those products. So some of us, some of us are going to be heads. You know, I'm basically neck deep in a lot of like testing of things right now.

There's a new game console coming soon. We're testing that. We're reviewing that. Let's move on to pics. What do you got?

Ben: It's over the garden wall season, everybody. It's the 10 year anniversary. They did a 10 year anniversary concert in LA, the blasting company that did all of the music for over the garden wall.

Elijah Wood was there. A lot of the original voices were there. Unfortunately, Jack Jones, who is the singing voice of the frog and also just sang a A couple of the other marquee songs for Over the Garden Wall. He was 89 when he died. So he lived a good long life. And you could kind of tell that this was being sung by a kind of gentle voiced old man too.

He had that, that sweetness in his voice. So if you don't know what I'm talking about, this is a mini series from Cartoon Network that premiered in 2014. It is a little bit of just a send up to the holiday season. Spooky season fall season. It is also an adaptation of Dante's. Oh, yes, it

Devindra: is It was also a lot of David the Gnome in there.

I mean, come on. I love David the Gnome

Ben: Yeah, it is. Also it feels very, you know old American and European like mythological and it's also like a huge, huge homage. Why'd I say that? I don't know. It's a homage to classic animation. So this is the animation of the 1930s or so. Rubber hoe, there is one episode that is like really, really relies on rubber hose animation.

of

Devindra: like Fleischer looking stuff in here.

Ben: Yeah. It's about two brothers who get lost in the woods and their entire The goal is to get out. And so if you know about basic mythology and a little bit about Dante's Inferno, you know what's going to happen. They get chased around by spooky stuff. They meet different crazy characters.

It has become a really classic rewatch for a lot of people. I don't know how many other things have been, like, canonized, like Over the Garden Wall has. In the last 15 years,

Devindra: you know, it's, it's very, it's not like a usually popular thing, but it has like basically garnered like a huge cult audience, which I think kind of the perfect thing for this.

So yeah, good show, good show. Check it out. It was also like unavailable to stream for a long time to you. So I'm happy to see that's a, that's a big thing. Let me just, I'm looking at the thing here. Yeah. We're not going to play this trailer. I want to shout out, I want to shout out the Netflix remake of Ranma one half, which is remember, remember that anime series?

Rama was like a classic eighties anime series about a boy who turns into a girl when he gets hit with water and his father turns into a panda. It's comedy. Kind of a romantic comedy, a situational comedy, also action series at time. Cause there was always a lot of good fighting. It's been remade for Netflix, basically following, at least from what I've seen, I've seen the first couple episodes kind of follows the exact same path as the original, but the animation is nice and clean.

It's still a fun watch and you know, it's, it's cozy anime. That is the sort of thing where I'm just like, I could just sit down really enjoy this J pop intro song, the really soothing ending song. It's funny. The action's pretty good too. Like it just looks cool. So I want to shut that out. Like for anime fans.

If you've not seen Ranma before, you can see the original. That is up on Crunchyroll right now. The animation's good. I think that's a, that's a good thing. Especially what happened to Uzumaki, which had a good first episode, and then the animation just went super, super bad. Downhill after that. So Ranma 1. 5 is my recommendation, especially if you checked out Dandadan, like I recommended it's good stuff.

Very different tonally. Very different tonally, but also I feel like a good chaser. Like Dandadan is pure, it's just like a little, a little like crazy, mad, you know, crazy mad anime. And Ranma is much more chill, even though it's about like much more fantastical stuff. Time. So good stuff.

Ben: Thanks everybody for listening.

Our theme music is by game composer, Dale North. Our outro music is by our former managing editor, Terrence O'Brien. The podcast is produced by me, Ben Elman. You can find Devendra online

Devindra: at Devendra on Twitter, BlueSky, Mastodon, everywhere. And a podcast about movies and TV at the Filmcast, at the Filmcast.

Ben: You can find me online at, I don't know, just listen to your router and I might be whispering to you. Don't try to contact me. No, I'm just kidding. If you want to see my old tweets, find me on Twitter. Hey, Bellman H E Y B E L L M A N. Email us at podcast at Engadget. com. Leave us a review on iTunes and subscribe on anything that gets podcasts.

That includes Spotify.

Why'd I say that? It's a homage.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/engadget-podcast-apples-m4-chip-heads-to-the-imac-mac-mini-and-macbook-pro-132004332.html?src=rss

Apple’s MacBook Pros get an M4 upgrade, including the new M4 Max chip

Not that it's a huge surprise after Apple's week of M4 upgrades — first with the 24-inch iMac, then the adorable new Mac mini — but today the company is also bringing its M4 chips to the 14-inch and 16-inch MacBook Pro. And, in addition to the base M4 chip and the M4 Pro, they can also be configured with the newly announced M4 Max.

Apple isn't sneaking in any major tweaks this time around, aside from bringing over the Space Black color option to the 14-inch MacBook Pro. Still, the internal upgrades should be compelling for anyone with an M1 MacBook Pro or an older Intel model. Just like with the M4 iMac and Mac mini, Apple is also making 16GB of RAM the default for the $1,599 14-inch MacBook Pro (fixing one of our biggest issues with that model). You can thank Apple Intelligence for that memory bump, even if you don't give a lick about AI.

Apple MacBook Pro M4
Apple

Apple isn't saying much about the M4 Max chip yet, but we know it'll feature up to a 16-core CPU (12 performance cores and 4 efficiency cores), and a 40-core GPU. In comparison, the M4 Pro sports a 14-core CPU and 20-core GPU, while the plain M4 chip comes with either 8 or 10 cores alongside a 10-core graphics chip. The M4 Max chip also supports up to 128GB of RAM with 30 percent more memory bandwidth than the M3 Max.

As for other upgrades, the M4 Pro and M4 Max MacBook Pros will also include three Thunderbolt 5 USB-C ports, just like the M4 Pro-equipped Mac mini. If you're constantly moving enormous files around, that alone could be a reason to step up, since Thunderbolt 5 can support up to 80 Gbps speeds (it can also reach up to 120 Gbps with its Bandwidth Boost feature). That's a huge step up from 40 Gbps limit of Thunderbolt 3 and 4, and it also opens the door for better external GPU support, as well as powerful AI accelerators.

Apple MacBook Pro M4
Apple

The new MacBook Pros have slightly brighter screens which can reach up to 1,000 nits of SDR brightness (compared to 600 nits before), and there's also a nano-texture display option. That feature is mainly meant for people working in very bright environments or direct sunlight, as it drastically reduces glare. Both machines are also getting 12MP Center Stage webcams, a huge upgrade over the previous 1080p cameras.

The 14-inch M4 MacBook Pro still starts at $1,599 ($1,499 for education customers), while the M4 Pro model starts at $1,999 ($1,849 for education). The 16-inch MacBook Pro, meanwhile, still starts at $2,499 ($2,299 for education customers). You can pre-order both laptops today, and they'll be in stores on November 8.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/laptops/apples-macbook-pros-get-an-m4-upgrade-including-the-new-m4-max-chip-150055208.html?src=rss

Every MacBook Air now starts with 16GB of RAM at no extra cost

No, Apple isn't stuffing an M4 chip into the MacBook Air lineup just yet, but it is giving the ultraportables a healthy memory bump. Starting today, every M2 and M3-equipped MacBook Air will come with 16GB of RAM by default, making them better equipped for multitasking and memory-hungry Apple Intelligence features. Thankfully, Apple isn't changing its pricing: The M2 model still starts at $999, while the 13-inch M3 MacBook Air goes for $1,099 and the 15-inch variant runs for $1,299. (It's no wonder we've seen the 8GB systems drop as low as $700.)

You'll still have to live with a paltry 256GB of storage on all of the base MacBook Air systems, but hey, at least Apple is finally listening to our demands. We've long argued that it's worth bumping up to 16GB of RAM for most laptops. That's particularly true for Apple Silicon systems, which have memory directly built into their SoCs (system on a chip) and can't expand their RAM down the line.

You can thank AI as the main reason Apple and Microsoft (with Copilot+ AI PCs) are now pushing for 16GB of RAM. While Apple Intelligence requires 8GB of RAM to function, the company previously admitted it may not be enough to run the AI features in Xcode 16. As AI models grow and become more complex, their memory demands will only increase. More than ever, it pays to invest in as much RAM as you can up front.

You can order the refreshed MacBook Airs with 16GB of RAM online today, and they should be available in stores soon.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/laptops/every-macbook-air-now-starts-with-16gb-of-ram-at-no-extra-cost-150041320.html?src=rss

Apple’s redesigned Mac mini is a tiny beast with M4 and M4 Pro chips

You can likely trace the start of the small computer trend back to the original Mac mini, which debuted in 2005 with a simple pitch: What if desktop, but tiny? Now Apple aims to take that concept even further with its latest Mac mini, a five-inch by five-inch box measuring a mere two inches tall, that can tackle some serious workloads. And while we expected it to include Apple's M4 chip, it can also be configured with an even more powerful M4 Pro model, which is also being announced today. Take that hardware together with a standard 16GB of RAM (just like the new M4 iMac), and you've got a pretty compelling Mac mini starting at $599 ($499 for education customers).

Why, exactly, did Apple shrink down the Mac mini? It's not as if the previous case, which has been around for years, was very large (it measures 7.75-inches by 7.75-inches, and it's 1.41-inches thick). When I reviewed the the M2 Mac mini early last year, I was still impressed by how slim and sleek it looked, especially compared to small form factor Windows systems. But by trimming down its footprint (at the expense of making it a bit taller), Apple can once again portray the Mac mini as an object of desire. 

You may not need it, but one look at its diminutive frame, and you might start finding reasons to give it a loving home.

Mac Mini M4 rear ports
Apple

Apple claims the M4 chip makes the new Mac mini up to 1.8 times faster than the M1 version, and up to 2.2 times faster when it comes to graphics. (The fact that Apple isn't directly comparing it to the M2 model makes it clear this isn't a major year-over-year upgrade.) While the M4 chip tops out at 10 cores, the M4 Pro reaches up to 14 cores (10 performance and 2 efficiency cores). It also features a 20 core GPU, double the amount in the base M4 chip. M4 Pro delivers Thunderbolt 5 connectivity for the first time on a Mac, which offers up to three times the bandwidth of Thunderbolt 3, as well as up to 64GB of RAM. There's also 273 GBps of memory bandwidth, which should be a huge help for AI processing.

Given that Apple Intelligence officially launched this week with the release of iOS 18.1, it's also a major selling point for the new Mac mini. The M4 chip sports 38 TOPS (tera operations per second) of AI processing power, while the M3 topped out at 18 TOPS. While Apple hasn't said this directly, I'd bet AI is also a major reason why the Mac Mini now starts with 16GB of RAM. Apple Intelligence requires at least 8GB of RAM to function, but the company has admitted that may not be enough to run Xcode 16's AI features. As always, having more RAM is better for future proofing, especially when you can't add more memory down the line.

Apple has also finally given us a few front ports on the Mac mini, instead of the clean facade of the last few models. There are two USB-C ports and a 3.5mm jack up front, which will make it far easier to plug in jump drives and headphones. On the back, you'll find another three Thunderbolt USB-C ports, HDMI, and Ethernet. While it would be nice to see an integrated SD card reader, Apple currently reserves that for the more expensive Mac Studio. 

Mac Mini M4 in use
Apple

You can preorder the new M4 Mac mini today starting at $599 ($499 for education customers), and it'll be available in stores on November 9th. The M4 Pro model, meanwhile, starts at $1,399 ($1,299 for schools). That price difference may seem high, but it's the same as it was for the M2 models. And as we saw from our M2 Mac mini review, it certainly held its own against other pricey desktops.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/computing/apples-redesigned-mac-mini-is-a-tiny-beast-with-m4-and-m4-pro-chips-150016484.html?src=rss

Engadget Podcast: The new iPad Mini is boring and that’s okay!

We finally got an iPad Mini refresh, and it's not particularly exciting. But that's fine! It's still a useful little tablet, and now thanks to the A17 Pro chip, it's already ready for upcoming Apple Intelligence features. In this episode, Engadget Deputy Editor Nathan Ingraham joins to discuss what he liked about the new iPad Mini, and what he hopes Apple will eventually fix in future models. Also, we chat about Netflix abandoning its AAA game studio, and why over 10,500 artists signed a letter against AI training.


Listen below or subscribe on your podcast app of choice. If you've got suggestions or topics you'd like covered on the show, be sure to email us or drop a note in the comments! And be sure to check out our other podcast, Engadget News!

  • The refreshed iPad Mini is playing it safe and that’s totally fine – 0:58

  • Netflix closes Team Blue, its attempt at a AAA game studio – 24:16

  • Over 10,000 of the world’s top artists sign a letter protesting AI training using their work – 28:27

  • X Terms of Service changes on account blocking, AI training spurs a fresh wave of Bluesky signups – 30:07

  • Ronald D. Moore (Outlander, Battlestar Galactica) chosen to helm Amazon’s God of War series – 38:35

  • Working on – 42:11

  • Pop culture picks – 43:17

Hosts: Devindra Hardawar and Ben Ellman
Guest: Nathan Ingraham
Producer: Ben Ellman
Music: Dale North and Terrence O'Brien

Devindra: [00:00:00]What's up, Internet, and welcome back to the Engadget Podcast. I'm Senior Editor Devindra Hardawar. This week I'm joined by Deputy Editor Nathan Ingraham. Hey, Nate.

Nate: Good morning, Devindra. How goes?

Devindra: Good morning. It goes well, and I want to talk about the thing you've been testing for a while. And also, podcast producer Ben Ellman is joining us.

Hey, Ben.

Ben: Hello, everybody.

Devindra: Hello, everybody. Thank you all for listening, and also, Again, we are moving to new podcast platform. So you may be hearing different things at the beginning. Just sit tight. It's still us. Just different ads, different announcements

Ben: . If the ads sound very sports, you're still in the right place.

Don't worry about it.

Devindra: I think one was like, welcome to the college sports podcast or something. And I guess

Ben: I promise that we're not going to shove you in a locker now that we're on this new like ad platform.

Devindra: Unlocking all the high school fears. Yes. As always, folks, if you are enjoying the please be sure to subscribe to us on iTunes or your podcatcher of choice.

Leave us a review on iTunes. Drop us an email at podcast@engadget.Com. Nate, you're here to talk about the new iPad mini, which you [00:01:00] reviewed this week. And I love your title because that's basically what we think when we think iPad mini, like what a little boring tablet, you know, why is it still around?

Surely it still has some uses. So it did get a slight Hardaware refresh, not a major redesign. What are your thoughts on this thing?

Nate: Yeah, I think the headline's funny. Sherilyn, liked it because she was like it's kind of a dating trope of like you want the safe and boring person Not the like crazy exciting person, which not the exciting one yeah, and like it sounds negative, but It's it's only slightly negative in the sense that it's a very mature piece of hardware at this point So like i'm not sure what else there is to innovate on in a In a small tablet form factor, my major like complaints was that I wish the screen was a little better but I also understand that we're talking about you know, 499 device instead of a 899 device.

And interestingly enough, I saw today a rumor that. Someone who's already one of the display guys has prognosed to getting about the next iPad mini having an OLED. But [00:02:00]chances are, we're not going to see that for at least two years anyway. So, yeah, in the meantime, it's got your basic Apple LCD that you'll find on.

You know, any all, most of the other iPads and the you know, well, it's very much the

Devindra: air screen, isn't it? Yeah, it's not the base level junk. Yeah,

Nate: correct. It's laminated. It's it has P3 color. It's better than the screen on the entry level iPad, but obviously not nearly as good as the ones on the iPad pro definitely comparable to the air.

Just as much smaller. And like the, the thing that was fun about this is that, you know, You know, earlier in the year, I reviewed the new iPad Air and the new iPad Pro, both 13 inch models that Apple provided us. And those are the ones where you're like, Oh do I want to use it as a laptop or as a tablet?

And, you know, should it have a more flexible operating system or is iPad OS okay? And with a small device like this, those questions kind of go away. They're not really relevant. You know, I'm not using this to write a review. I did not write the review on the iPad. Instead, it's just like a little companion device.

It's [00:03:00] like using my phone, but better. So like I can do a little work on it, but I don't want to do a ton.

Devindra: I can, it does sit in a weird space right now though. Right. Cause the phones are getting bigger, you know, like the, the pro the pro max is inching towards seven inches. This thing is an 8.3-inch screen.

So. I guess if you have a Pro Max, right, you probably would not be getting the iPad mini. Yeah, there's no

Nate: real gulf there. That's true. Although I'll say that like the phone, and this is probably I don't think something a lot of people are asking for but you know, iOS is still very much oriented around portrait usage.

Landscape always feels a little weird. You could probably say the same thing about the iPad mini though. Note that they left the camera on the top you know, portrait oriented edge instead of moving it to landscape like they did with all the other iPads. I think that makes sense in this case because You're just going to hold it up like this and do a FaceTime probably like this.

You could do it like this too, but you know, it kind of, it's, it's not a change that I'm like, Oh, why didn't they do this? So it's just something to know. Gotcha.

Devindra: The, the main [00:04:00] thing this year is the new chip, right? The A17 Pro chip. So it's ready for Apple intelligence, but that's really it. Right. And a better base storage.

That's like the main upgrades. Yeah.

Nate: Yeah. So not much considering it's three years old. Obviously. At this point, you know, you wouldn't have wanted to buy the old one with a chip that's three years old because you know, hopefully you buy one of these and they last you four years or whatever or maybe even more so having you know, the a17 pro is solid.

I think they could have put in this year's chip the a18 I don't know why not. I mean sure saving a few bucks but that said for what? One wants to do with an iPad mini. I'm sure it will be perfectly fine. I realized that in, I feel like in the cons, I did say it doesn't have an M series chip, like the like the iPad air it's the smallest of cons.

It's like something to be aware of, but I don't think it will. Actually affect the way anyone uses this thing.

Ben: Nate, are you complaining about not paying 200 more dollars for an iPad mini because it doesn't have a M series chip? I'm

Nate: not. If that's the trade off we're [00:05:00] talking about, if that's a trade off, then I'm 100 percent

Devindra: fine with this.

That's also why it has last year's chip, too. I'm sure this is the tablet where Apple's OK. What can we cut? What can we cut? Not a, not a screen beyond 60 Hertz, you know, no promotion for this thing. Not this year's chip. We've got a huge stock of old chips. The case is no different, right? So they didn't have to like design much.

This is a, it's a very much like a minimal effort tablet where I think Apple even puts more effort into the base iPad because you really have to be creative there. to cut those corners and also deliver a bigger screen. This is okay, not many people are buying this, but some enough people are that we have to keep it around.

That's what it kind of feels like. But speaking

Ben: of innovation, one person in the chat is saying, Wes Jackson said Can't they innovate smaller bezels and better refresh rate? What's going on there?

Nate: Yeah, I think the bezel will be the next thing to, they'll have to improve that a little bit, maybe with the OLED model.

Although, you know, when you use a tablet, I just noticed like your hands always rest on the edge of it enough that I don't mind that the screen doesn't go fully [00:06:00] to the edge. It, it is starting to look a little chunky in that regard. Higher refresh rate is definitely something Apple needs to consider across more of its products.

Right now it's only the pro lineup that gets that across, you know, phones, computers iPads.

Devindra: Yeah.

Nate: The only iPad with with 120 Hertz starts at a grand, which is bonkers.

Devindra: Yeah. So the same price you're paying for a MacBook Air, which does not have a 60, which does not have a promotion screen. So there's this degradation or delineation of how they're dueling out that feature.

Can you, I can imagine a future in a couple of years, we've seen the rumors where Apple could have promotion or faster refresh rates on all of its, all of its devices, basically. Like it's on pretty much every single Android device. There's no Android device, even though there aren't many Android tablets.

Nothing is going out with 60 Hertz screens. Yeah, 90 seems to be the

Nate: minimum they shoot for now. I will say that most of the time doesn't really bother me on most devices. You know, it takes a minute and you're like, okay, I'm used to this. I will say that because of the way I use the iPad mini, which was often [00:07:00] like reading, scrolling websites, you know, doing a lot of like vertical, You know, scrolling through websites, I felt I noticed the jerkiness more in that context.

Versus, you know, on like the iPad Pro, I'm not, maybe it's a bigger screen, I'm not scrolling quite as much, I don't know. And also I don't, you know, hold it in my hands and read because it's a giant slab. Whereas this thing otherwise is perfectly suited to a little reading device.

Devindra: Which phone

Nate: do you have Nate?

I currently have a 14 pro, which does have promotion. Yes. Yeah. So, so in your,

Devindra: in your daily life, you're used to like when you're scrolling social media or whatever, like the smooth scroll. And I do think that is, it's one of those things. A lot of consumers may not realize like what is happening across a lot of devices, but it It's better for your eyes.

It's like leads to less headaches and eye strain. I would love to see it on more devices from Apple. So that's kind of a shame. You wrote about the this one doesn't have the jelly roll issue. Yeah. I don't, the last gen. I don't think so.

Nate: I will say, I can't say that with a hundred percent certainty.

Cause I think to some degree [00:08:00]it is dependent on like some people are more sensitive to it than others. I haven't noticed it I know that the verges review said it was quote very much still there doesn't something like that. They said it's there Most other reviewers said it seems better to me So I think it's one of those things where you need to go check it out yourself and notice like okay Is this gonna bother me?

Or not to explain what that is. Yeah, I was

Ben: about to say, can you explain that to me? And also every Android tablet user?

Devindra: Well, I'm some and it's not. It's an LCD

Ben: thing.

Devindra: It's an LCD thing, but it's so what it is is when you're in portrait mode and you scroll up and down like part of the screen, half the screen looks like it's refreshing slower.

We're moving a little slower than the other half. And that's due to like how the panel is situated. If you're in landscape mode, you don't have that issue. It kind of scrolls a little better. So I would have loved to see Apple, do something to fix that. But again, it's an iPad mini and they're like, whatever, man, this has to be 500.

And we're not going to engineer more to solve a problem. I [00:09:00] just picked it up

Nate: and I'm scrolling around with it in portrait. I don't see it. And now I'm switching the landscape and I still don't see it. I think I read somewhere that they, they posited that Apple made it, they reoriented the panel so that portrait would be smooth and landscape would be where you might see it.

But I don't know. I don't see it. Okay. I don't think it's an issue.

Devindra: We'll have to see when the, when one of the like real teardown people get into these devices to see what the real situation is there. I imagine they could come up with some sort of software solution to, to maybe make it look a little less bad.

But anyway, it's an iPad mini. It's boring, but that's okay. The other thing

Nate: to note that is new is that it supports the Apple Pencil Pro rather than the second generation Apple Pencil, which, believe it or not, was introduced all the way back in 2018 now makes me feel old. I am sadly a terrible artist.

I have no visual art skills. My handwriting is serial killer style, so I don't get as much personal benefit out of it. But I'm glad that they didn't. Keep the iPad mini stuck with an old accessory. [00:10:00] The pencil lineup was really kind of weird and confusing for a bit. And now they basically just have the 79 USBC model that doesn't charge and pair magnetically.

You have to plug it in. And it has a few other you know, it's missing pressure sensitivity and a few things. And then there's the 130. Dollar Pencil Pro, which has a gyroscope and haptic feedback and you can squeeze it to pull up a, you know, your palette double tap to switch tools like it's, it's a pretty good device for sure.

If you're somebody who's gonna use it a lot and, and the combo of that and the super portable tiny sides of the mini. Makes you think it'd be a great little like sketchbook. Like you can just toss it in your bag and bring it to you everywhere. And if you like to draw or otherwise take notes on things, you could just go nuts with that.

Isn't the stylus like almost as tall as it is? Yeah, it's nearly a, when you tap it, when you attach to the side, it like takes up most of the iPad's long edge. So it's a little, you

Ben: can also see this. In the review, you have one picture of the iPad mini showing Bellatro [00:11:00] and the Apple Pencil is let's say 80 percent as long as that thing?

I think more. I think it's probably closer to 90. I mean,

Devindra: Looks like 90%. Yeah. It's pretty much almost all the way there. It's all pencil, baby.

Nate: So it's a little awkward in that regard, but it, it didn't really bother me. I would say that I was less likely to leave it attached when I was otherwise doing things.

So my hand wouldn't like bump the pencil, I'll just, you know, take it off and put it away. But it's there if you need it to take it away as one little package. I, I still think that's one of the nicest things Apple fixed generally speaking with the iPad once they're like, Oh, we can just flatten the edge, stick this thing to the side.

It got so much more. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Devindra:Aesthetically pleasing so much easier. I feel like anybody doodling will probably just go for the air though. Right. Which is not that much more than does give you 11 inch air is

Nate: only a hundred bucks more. So, I think unless, again unless you really like the small form factor, then like the Air is still the one that I recommend for the vast majority of people.

Devindra: Or if you just get one, I'm sure Apple's Hey if you want a nice portable one to take around the house, get both, get, get as many iPads as you want. Get

Nate: all of them. But [00:12:00] I say, I don't think I know too many people who've bought more than one of these things at a time. So. I have them all in my house right now, which is just ridiculous.

I need to return some of them.

Devindra: But,

It's just, I always, I always have piles of like old gadgets laying around, unfortunately. The thing about iPads though, is that they are, they're kind of relentless, right? They, they kind of hold up pretty well. I'm still using, I bought a 2018. It was actually whatever six gen was, I think that was a 2017 release.

And we're still using that in our house. My son uses as like a car video card. thing still works. It's not super fast, but it still works. So it's you could conceivably gain a pile of iPads in your house. And at some point have an air and be like, what if it were a little smaller? And then you have this option and spend another 500 for this guy.

Where does it what would you prefer Nate, in terms of what you want from an iPad?

Nate: Good question. Yeah. The one that I, you know, going back to having ones that last long time, the one that I personally last purchased was a 2020 iPad. Pro 11 inch. So I think that's still like the best size for most [00:13:00]people.

For sure. It, I think that the mini is a little small for watching movies and that sort of thing. So again unless you're somebody who's Ooh, I really love the small device, get the air, it's a hundred bucks more, the screen is much larger. It has a better chip. It can run the stage manager.

If you want to do more multitasking again, not that I think that the mini The screen's too small for stage manager to make any sense. Even on the 11 inch, I mostly use most apps in full screen mode. Like I occasionally will do, you know, a little, a little rearranging of things with stage manager, but most of the time it just makes more sense to have everything run full screen.

And then I like that if you are somebody who's Oh, I want a big device, I want a really larger drawing canvas, or I want to use it like a laptop more than, than, you know, I don't, you can get the 13 inch air now, which is, is. You know, it's not cheap. It's 800, but it's 500 cheaper than the iPad pro 13, I believe.

So, again, the pro really is just it's incredible. Like the Hardaware they managed to pull off for that thing is it's bonkers. It's hard to [00:14:00] recommend to a normal human being, unless they're like rich and they just want the nicest thing. That's really

Devindra: it. Yeah. The air is the most sensible one, but it's that darn screen.

I really, I just would love if I'm spending 600, 700 on a tablet. Give me the high refresh. So then it starts to be like, well, maybe just buy an older iPad pro. You know, maybe you don't need the newest one because you'll still get an M series chip. Speaking of the M series chip, I saw people talking about this.

I don't, I don't think it really makes a difference for this machine, right? For the iPad. You're not doing M series work. So it kind of makes sense to stick with at least a cell chip. It could have been this year's. Make sense. Like last year's pro is still pretty fast.

Nate: It's something that you can complain about if you want to find something to complain about.

But like in terms of actual like use case, I can't imagine it'll make any difference. Like I said, a stage manager is restricted to M series. But on an eight inch screen, it's, you're not going to want to have multiple windows going. I did a little benchmark, you know, I geek bench six and the numbers are quite comparable.

I think that the a 17 pro basically netted out as a [00:15:00] slightly better M one. Probably again, that's like rough. I don't have the numbers in front of me, but. You know, again, plenty of power for some, like I said, it's a couch computer. I want to browse. I'm going to message. I want to play some, some games you know, get my Bellotro fix.

And the timing of this was great because Bellotro just hit Apple arcade not even a month ago, I think, and I got the mini and it's just the perfect little device to play on it's a little small on the phone, but it's great on this thing.

Ben: M series chip into one of these things it would be like putting a Ferrari engine into one of those classic Beatles You know the Volkswagen Beatles.

I

Nate: mean we've that's I remember when they put the m series into I think it was, they did it to the pro first, obviously that was the whole discussion was like, wow, this is, this is kind of crazy that they're putting, you know, their laptop class chip into an iPad. You know, I think given the large and the larger screen and the display quality, right?

Pushing more pixels at a higher refresh rate. There's probably some, some logic to that [00:16:00] there.

Ben: Also that's going to be the main machine that a lot of artists. Okay. End up using so if you're doing something that's layers on layers on layers in photoshop or illustrator or something like that You might need that extra processing power.

Yeah, that's a fair point

Nate: for sure again, I wish I could I wish I could push that sort of work workload to some sort of limit but I can, I can draw some stick figures in the notes app.

Devindra: This is me whenever I review anything with a stylist. Like it's not, it's not pretty. I know we shouldn't,

Nate: I think we really need to find a good somebody on staff who has, so I think Valentina has some, some good visual chops.

Devindra: Who's a good drawer. Who's that drawer basically. That's what we get to figure out who's the best drawer. It could be Valentina. I think it is. And

Nate: she reviewed the last mini and she actually, she likes the mini. I'll have to double check her and see exactly what draws her to it. But I think. She likes, likes that it's small, basically, and that it's easily totable.

That's her main, her main concern.

Devindra: This thing is coming in time for Apple Intelligence to really [00:17:00]start to debut. Next week we know that iOS 18. 1 is going to be rolling out to the public. So that is like when some of the basic features will, will get there. We also saw yesterday, The iOS 18.

2 developer beta went live. So if you want to feel a little, you want to be a little risky, you want to try out some of the other stuff that has a Genmoji, visual intelligence, the chat, GPT, Siri features. And I played around a little with that. I don't know if any of these things are going to be super compelling to Apple users.

I think the numbers we saw in terms of like iPhone sales is that Apple intelligence hasn't really been pushing sales also because it's not fully available yet. So, I guess we'll see how that goes. How could it push

Nate: sales

Devindra: if it's not a thing yet? This one I do want to point out I don't, the iPad mini will not be able to do the visual intelligence at least demo on the on the developer beta.

Because I'm seeing from Sherlyn's reporting that only the iPhone 16 and that newer chip is getting visual intelligence. So I do wonder if that feature will eventually come to the older machines on full release. I mean, I feel

Nate: I feel like since this one is [00:18:00] brand new, it's got to support the whole.

The whole gamut of features that's, I mean, I didn't mention this as much, but this is probably why this refresh happened when it did is the mini did not, the old mini did not work with Apple intelligence. Now there's one that does they really want every device that they're selling, like the new current ones anyway, to have that.

So, you know, it makes you wonder what they'll upgrade the base level iPad with, because currently they're selling that when it does not work with Apple intelligence. And this, that it feels like a feature that they are not at all interested in restricting to quote pro level devices. They want that to work on everything.

Oh, yeah. So I would have to imagine. They want you to

Devindra: be fully dependent on the entire Apple intelligence ecosystem. So you have, you know, fewer reasons to leave basically. And you like it on your tablet. You'll want it on your Mac. You'll want it on all your devices in your phone and everything. So.

That kind of makes sense. All right, Nate, thank you so much for joining us on this. Any final thoughts on this iPad mini?

Ben: We have people in chat talking about a mini keyboard for this iPad. I was going to bring that up. I [00:19:00] mean, my, my fingers would just be like knocking into each other. And I'm not a huge guy.

Devindra: We, we used to talk about like the surface even before the surface Neo stuff, the courier device, that whole idea like involved, like maybe having a tiny keyboard I could see being a thing. You know, it could be kind of cool, but now you don't, we're not even going to be typing text anymore, guys, like that, the whole, the whole point about the push towards AI is that dictation is getting better.

Just speaking to your device is getting better. We just saw the thing was it open AI? Or one of the other groups showed off the thing where you could just talk to your computer and their AI tool will like, start doing the things you're instructing it to on the computer. So that's the dream, right?

The dream of the whole thing of like computer interfaces is going to be to the point where we could just ask it to do stuff. My childhood, I remember watching Ghost on the Shelf for the first time, and when that android that does the split finger, I'm typing a thousand words per minute because my fingers can split open.

Oh

Ben: yeah, yeah, that's a very popular gif even now.

Devindra: [00:20:00] It's so cool, but again, we may not need to do that. That may be an archaic way of input. Yeah, that's one of those

Nate: looking to the future things that's.

It's like, how do I advance the thing I know it's like a, it's like a, a better buggy instead of a car, right?

Devindra: I'll tell you guys like when it, are you using dictation or anything on these devices, Nate? Rarely. I don't, I'm

Nate: not interested in talking to computers at this point. Yeah. I will say that I just confirmed on the new iPad mini that it does have the iOS 18.

2 beta with more more Apple Intelligence features. It says that Apple Intelligence is available on iPads with A17 Pro or M1 and later. Which includes the sky,

Devindra: the, I think the, the question is the visual intelligence feature specifically, maybe for this beta, it hasn't been opened up to older devices. I think at least Sherwin called that out specifically.

So that's, yeah, that's that any final thoughts on this iPad, Nate? I would say it's fine. [00:21:00] It's it's,

Nate: it's good. It's, it's, it's, you know, there's good. They're like making iPads that, you know, if you like an iPad, it'll work for you. But I think for most people, I would say go pick up a. A bigger one, pick up the bigger air, see how you feel about it.

If you've never used one before anyway, because broadly speaking, I think more people will prefer the bigger screen that seems to be what life has taught us in the tech world. But if you like smaller devices, there is still this one.

Devindra: And there's also the thing we always recommend when a new device comes out, look out for sales of the old device.

Cause I've already seen the older model of the iPad mini down to 300 at some places, and it's if you don't care about Apple intelligence, that is still a very good tablet that will last you a long time. It won't be the fastest thing in the world, but it'll be. It'll get cheap. It'll get cheaper.

Hopefully.

Ben: Just a couple of days ago. I was thinking, man, I really wish I had something to read this article in bed with because there you go. Too small. Laptop too

Devindra: big. Well, you also did this to yourself, Ben, because you have phone too small. You have the baby. [00:22:00] I

Ben: don't have the iPhone Mini, but yes, I have an iPhone SE, so yes.

It might as well be the iPhone

Devindra: Mini type of deal. Yeah.

Ben: But the article I wanted to read had these big diagrams that went all the way across the page, so I don't think that that would really be remedied by a bigger phone. I think you want a tablet.

Devindra: You, at some point you definitely want a tablet, but let me tell you, The pro max pro max life is, is like you, you go, you go widescreen on that.

And it's I can watch videos in bed. I can watch I dive into like big PDFs when I need to. So that's a whole thing. Anyway, Nate, where can we find you online these days? Yeah, I'm on threads at Nate Ingraham and likewise on Instagram. All right. We should see on blue sky. All the media people are on blue sky, as we'll talk about later.

But yeah, just claim your username. I think I did. And I just haven't logged in since then. All right. Thank you so much, Nate. Thank you.

Let's move on [00:23:00] to some other news and some surprising things we saw this week including Netflix closing it's AAA gaming studio. Which was the story. Netflix had a triple A game studio. They had something. It was known as team blue. You know, Netflix is known as a company that they started doing some games.

They started doing some mobile game stuff. They bought some mobile game studios. And if you look at Netflix on a mobile device, you can get redirected to games that you could play right on your device. And a couple of years ago, there was some news about them. Let me see here. It was two years ago.

Ben: I mean, they were poaching people, especially

Devindra: like known people.

Last year we reported that halo veteran Joseph Staten was joining that studio to make a game for Netflix. So like that was, that's a big deal. So, and they were pulling other people from franchises like overwatch the former boss, the former person in charge of overall overwatch, overall Chaco sunny creative director of.

No, and God of War God of War art director, Raphael Grissetti. So like big franchise people that were [00:24:00]pulling, I think it was happening. First of all, in a lot of our reporting around this, we were like, this is not going to happen. Netflix is wildly over like underestimating how difficult it is to produce expensive games.

The development process, just you know, getting a game out there. Microsoft has learned this throughout this entire like Xbox generation. Did you have any thoughts on this, Ben?

Ben: The fact that I didn't even know that Netflix had a AAA gaming studio probably says something about whether or not the average person would care, because I'm so often the surrogate for the average person on this podcast.

But also this reminds me so much of Stuff that has happened in tech in general. And then also in my little world of podcasts, where a very big multinational company says, Hey, that doesn't look too hard. I think I can do that. And they spend a bunch of money hiring a bunch of people, and they think that they can just buy their way into a completely new like [00:25:00] sector of business.

It turns out it's hard. They don't know what to do. Quite what they're doing. They don't really want to listen to the people who know best. They just want step one, create AAA gaming studio. Step two, question mark, step three, profit.

Devindra: Netflix doesn't even make a profit right now. Like a lot of these companies, it's very little about profit and more about clout and like getting your name out there, or at least associating you.

Like you want people to associate, Oh, you open our app and we get you games. People are pointing out, like they have into the breach on Android and a whole bunch of other games, like into the breach. It's fantastic. Everybody should play that. You could get it as part of your Netflix subscription. That's kind of cool, but also kind of confusing when they started doing that.

So I'm, I'm not too surprised by any of this, but it does follow.

Ben: Yeah. And Jess has been talking for a while about how like games on Netflix are actually good. This is our games reporter, Jess Condit. But. Yeah, maybe not a AAA game, because that can routinely cost, what is it, hundreds of millions of dollars to produce?

It

Devindra: depends on how big, but [00:26:00] yeah, you could go hundreds of millions. Sony's games, their big single player games cost a ton of money, so, and we also saw the report, what was the, the shooter, the shooter that was out for a week? Concord. When you do a game like that, they spent years developing that, reportedly hundreds of millions of dollars and then, you just, that's it, if it doesn't work.

That's a big gamble that's just completely wasted.

Ben: That is 400 million dollars. That is almost half a billy.

Devindra: And Netflix is used to wasting burning money to, to be successful. But also, this whole field for Microsoft I've been thinking about what the hell is going on with Microsoft and Xbox this generation?

And it's just failure after failure. Really, they have never really recovered from the Botched launch of the Xbox one over a decade ago or about a decade ago. So that that's just it. Like they can't produce the games and Sony is producing games, but they're having like even they have trouble, like even they have trouble.

They're not always successful either. Yeah.

Ben: So how can you expect Netflix to just jump in and be successful? Not [00:27:00]surprising

Devindra: there at all. We also saw news that over 10, 500 artists signed an open letter protesting unlicensed AI training that included people like Tom York of Radiohead, Julianne Moore, Kevin Bacon.

A lot of artists, a lot of people from Saturday Night Live too, or at least Kate McKinnon from Saturday Night Live, Rosario Dawson. It's, it's, it's. Kind of referring to a lot of the same things we've talked about before. In the letter, it says the unlicensed use of creative works for training generative AI is a major unjust threat to the livelihoods of the people behind those works and must not be permitted.

So specifically, this is unlicensed use of artist performance or artist work. I think the door is open there for, yes, if you pay us, maybe, maybe we can come to some sort of deal. Have you, have you seen this Ben?

Ben: Yeah, I have a slightly spicy take about this. Just because you signed a petition doesn't mean that it actually does very much.

So this is kind of like the celebrities all singing imagine at the beginning of pandemic lockdown, unless you can really [00:28:00] back it up. And actually, what they should have done was sign their name. And then underneath, they have, you know, their sharkiest lawyer from the law firm that represents them, that would actually carry a lot more weight than just Tom York.

Putting his name down on a list of people.

Devindra: I mean, it's, it's something it's speech rather than action, but maybe it shows that the intent is there and that artists are not still sticking with this. So I think that specifically. Is it's something, but it's just not, it's not going to change anything in the industry.

I also want to talk about this. We missed some of this news, but X was having a bunch of issues when it came to the block function, where they basically changed it so that if somebody blocks you or no, if you block somebody previously, that meant that they could not go visit your profile and see everything.

There have always been workarounds. You could always just open any incognito tab or whatever and go try to see it in private mode. So there have been ways to still access those tweets, but the ease of [00:29:00] doing it was not a thing before. A lot of people were speculating like, Oh, this is a lot of X's changes really feel like they come from Elon Musk's daily usage.

You know, I think the Daily Dot, which we're looking at right here, had even speculated, does he just want to see his you know, his ex wife's tweets because she blocked him? Is this Which ex wife are we talking about? There are many, but I can imagine you know, Elon also, I can imagine his usage of Twitter.

Is part of the reason they were like let's hide the things we like let's hide tweets. We like because Our there's stuff in our histories that we just don't want to go look at so

Ben: I mean He actively wants to be liking more tweets that are about dubious stuff I

Devindra: mean he was publicly liking tweets about like racist and anti semitic, tweets and white nationalists at one point

Ben: Yeah, i've always hated the block behavior on twitter though When people have an argument and then one person just no longer wants to participate in that argument, or there's one person, [00:30:00] you know, that is really carrying it on and their interlocutor is just not responding and blocks them, that person will run all the way around the Metaphorical Twitter playing field being like they blocked me that means that I was so annoying to them that I must have been right So Elon making sure that you can't block people is bad on its own But the behavior around the block function was already bad to begin with

Devindra: I agree I mean, the behavior wasn't good.

I always liked muting people so that they would just like, are you into thin air? But sometimes if somebody is knowing enough, it's yeah, sure. You're blocked and then deal with it. Maybe you'll have your own little celebration, but that's just kind of how I've been going with it. But anyway, because of all this and because of these changes

Ben: Yeah, there's bigger terms of service changes, though, because it also said we could just scrape anything you post on Twitter to be used for generative AI.

And that really messed with the artists, which is super important.

Devindra: That basically pushed a [00:31:00] lot of people, I believe, millions of people away from X in towards blue sky, which is a place I hang out, you know, pretty often. But it's always been like a quiet little home front. It has, it, it lacks the dynamism and spiciness of Twitter.

Sometimes it gets a little weird too. So it not, not always fun ways, but that blue sky starting to feel more like Twitter because people I know from Twitter who were like delaying, making the jump are there and I'm just like recreating my old Twitter feed. So that's kind of a, it's kind of a good benefit, I guess.

Good job, Elon. Good job as always. A masterful gambit, sir. Every change you make is just driving people away. It's amazing.

Ben: Twitter going against the artists and like making it no longer a hospitable place for artists to hang out and post their work and possibly get commissions. Furry artists, especially say that Twitter is fantastic for commissions.

That is one of the ways that you kill the culture of a website. Okay. Who's going to be left on Twitter then?

Devindra: It's just it's going to be [00:32:00] Elon and like all the VCs who are now as maga pilled as he, he is. It seems like it's just them talking to each other and their bots the bots talking to which is

Ben: I guess what they wanted to begin with.

Devindra: That's what they wanted. It's sort of like, I think Elon realized it's sort of like when you realize, oh man, there's maybe some stuff in my browser history. I don't want other people to see. And rather than going to his browser settings and just deleting it for himself, he was like, swipe it for the entire site.

That's, that's the like history. That's why I think the like history thing was happening. The AI tools or at least the AI training based on people's data. That just seems like they're desperate to make money. You know, they're, he's trying to do anything. Cause this is one of the worst investments.

In the, in the history of business, it seems like he is there. Yeah.

Ben: Speaking of making money and various investments, when you have a place like OpenAI throwing, you know, 100 million at the Wall Street Journal or something to use their like whole back catalog for training [00:33:00]AI, isn't that a one time deal?

You're just getting paid a hundred million dollars for that year. That is not an ongoing relationship, because how long does it take to scrape an entire website or an entire archive of a newspaper? It's got to be very quick. So you're making the balance look really bad. Good for the year 2024 for the possibility of really sinking your entire industry in the future.

Devindra: I'm sure they're probably like we've not seen the full terms. These and these companies don't typically reveal the full like extent to their business deals. Usually what we see is the big number. So I would imagine if I were the IP lawyers behind a lot of these companies today. Okay. Train our archive.

this is the payment we want, but also moving forward for new things, maybe it's an ongoing fee at that point because now they need new data. Yeah,

Ben: like a, some kind of a royalty or something, but they might try to like work in something that is like, Oh, well, if we knew we were [00:34:00]using your data specifically in any like generated AI work, then yes, we'll pay you a royalty.

But of course, they'd find a way to make sure that they didn't You can never tell whether or not you're using, you know, the general voice of the Wall Street Journal for generating an AI thing. So there would never be a royalty.

Devindra: Anyway, things are hopping on blue sky now. So if you miss the the glory of early Twitter I would recommend checking that out.

It's a, it's a fun time and good to see like some familiar faces over there. I am like trying to be more engaged there too. So add me an active Indra. Was it at dot blue sky dot social or whatever, but you can, you can search, you can find things. I want to talk about this Ben, because I saw this story and this headline just kind of broke my brain.

Intel sets Boeing made satellite explodes and breaks up in orbit. This is news that happened yesterday. And we have a report up by Steve Dent the U S space force, which is the thing that still exists is tracking around 20 pieces, just, just kind of, this is not technically a Boeing [00:35:00] satellite, but it is a Boeing made satellite for another company.

So. Yet another big miss for them.

Ben: Did a door happen to fly off of it or something? I don't know.

Devindra: We don't know. But clearly it's a sign of their whole how they're actually building things. The U. S. Space Force says it's tracking around 20 pieces that have, quote, observed has observed no immediate threats, end quote, to other satellites so far.

The cause of the explosion isn't known, but Yeah, this, this follows the Starliner issues. The failed test flights, all the problems with the, the seven 37s. I was on a seven 37 max recently. I noticed when I saw when I saw the like airplane thing the little guidebook of the model you're on, I'm like, Oh, these are still running.

This is not, this is not a good sign. Apparently they fixed that. So these things are just kind of floating out there. That's just, it's just a thing that exists.

Ben: It's good that we have some kind of organization tracking the pieces. I think that it could still be NASA. I'm also very curious what the fitness standards for the space force are.

They call [00:36:00] the air force, the chair force. So what would the space force be? Because I imagine most of their work. is being done in front of computers.

Devindra: Most definitely. I mean, that's most of NASA's work too, right? So I've seen enough shows about like NASA and the state of NASA in movies to have a sense.

I feel like Space Force is just like that, but they have a cooler name, you know, or maybe it's not all nerds. Like astronauts are not all nerds. They're like the best jocks in the, in the world end up being

Ben: astronauts. Remember that recently inducted astronaut who was both a Navy SEAL and a doctor.

Good God. Doctor SEAL. Doctor SEAL. Dr. Seale. You'll always be safe with Dr. Seale. Solidus T in the chat says, Space farce.

Devindra: Probably. That's a whole, that's the whole thing. Actually kind of related to this because we were speaking about Mr. Ronald D. Moore.

Ben: I mean, make the connection a little bit better.

Ronald D. Moore, who started For All Mankind, who has

Devindra: since left that show, which is a show about alternate history. It's an alternate history space race thing, which ends up. Kind of being more of a sci fi [00:37:00] show because of that. But also best known as the guy who rebooted Battlestar Galactica and you know, partially changed the face of television with that thing.

I love that show. I remember, I love his work in general. So the news is that he is now show running Amazon's God of War series. Which is a property that is not exciting me very much, but okay. Sure. More Ronald D more shows for all mankind is fantastic. That was like one of the first great Apple TV plus shows.

It takes a little while to get going, but I'd recommend like giving it a couple episodes. He also did Outlander because he read for that book series one day. I was like, this could make a really compelling TV show. Outlander is not. It is sort of sci fi, because it's like an out of time thing. I know people who love Outlander.

It's fun. That's just a fun thing that he did. And it's very not like Battlestar Galactica at

Ben: all. While I was reading up for this, every time I saw For All Mankind, I was like, Oh yeah, that's the thing Damien Chazelle did too, right? He worked on that? No, that is First Man. That's also on Apple TV but it is very different.

Well,

Devindra: maybe they [00:38:00] have it. It wasn't one of their movies. So I think that's just one thing that they are, they happen to be streaming. That was some of the whole, like original moon landing story too, which is, that is a fantastic movie. And both that movie and the for all mankind also get into the dangers and the darkness behind doing something as crazy as space exploration too.

So anyway. Ronald D. Moore is doing God of War. I am, I've played the last God of War. I didn't, or actually, no, I played the rebooted God of War. I never finished the very last game and it's cool. I like the franchise. I like the use of mythology and I love mythology stories in general, but to make a show out of it, that just feels like we're going back to the days of like Hercules and Xena.

It's just, we've seen a lot of this before.

Ben: Yeah. Oh my god, wow, no, and that's really perfect with Ronald D. Moore because he was working during that era with like, all of the Star Trek's of the 80's and 90's. He's the guy who famously killed Kirk, I believe,

Devindra: in the Star Trek movie,

Ben: yeah. But my question to you is you [00:39:00] talk with a lot more showrunners and general entertainment people.

On a big piece of IP like this God of War is one of Sony's biggest things that they really don't want people to screw up or really get too creative with, period. How much of this job is just going to be paint by numbers?

Devindra: It depends. Like it could end up like Uncharted, which is a movie that was in development for years and went through several different writers and directors and just ended up being like a boring pile of garbage.

Or it could end up being something like The Last of Us TV show, Which at times is pretty much a recreation of the game, but then veers off in places or fills in interesting planks. There's probably room for them to do something with God of War. It's just, I am like, I see that. I'm like, Ronald D. Moore, you could do something new and interesting rebooting or doing a God of War show, just.

Isn't it, you know, we have so many of these things right now. It almost feels like it's another thing for Amazon be like, Oh, we want to do a sort of semi fantasy action thing too. They are spending so much money on the Lord of the Rings [00:40:00] show. I could imagine trying to do this as well. And Sony surely would want to get it right.

I just wish it were more exciting. That's just it. But it's Ronald D. Morris. I will certainly check it out. That's like my main takeaway from all that. All right. Let's move on to what we're working on real quick. I'm right now testing the HB Omnibook ultra. Which is, I believe the name of it, this is one of their newest laptops with the fast, new AMD chips.

So keep an eye out for that. I also need to do like a compilation of PCs and copilot plus PCs. Like copilot plus is the thing we're talking about. The AI PCs with the faster MPs and whatnot. We want to do a roundup and collect some of the best ones and best options for people. So. If you have thoughts around that, or questions around Copilot Plus and AIPCs, drop me a note specifically, or just leave us an email at podcastsengadget.

com. Ben, anything? Yeah, what do you work on? Shout out.

Ben: So if you sent us an email months ago asking if folding at home is still relevant, I am working on that. I am Like, knee deep in learning about [00:41:00] protein folding and how AlphaFold by DeepMind by Google has really revolutionized the protein folding problem.

So I'm hoping to bring listeners something cool about that sometime in the next few weeks. So, Dev, what is your pick this week?

Devindra: What is my pick this week? Let me, let me pull up all our notes. By the way related to the whole protein folding thing, I used to run computer labs, you know, back in college, and we could just install whatever we want.

And I had the power to install en masse across hundreds of computers on campus. Oh, I want to do this. I want, when a screensaver happens, I used to do the Windows domain management stuff. And yeah, we put up, we put a protein folding. We occasionally did like the study at home stuff, but we ended up being like, it was a protein folding across hundreds of computers when everything, when nobody was there.

It's a cool thing to see just idle, idle processing of our computers. Yeah. In terms of picks this week, I want to shout out the penguin, which is the offshoot series of the Matt Reeves, Batman movie, which I just didn't really have time for up until now, but I've been binging [00:42:00] it. Over the last you know, over the last week.

And I just want to say it's fantastic, like better than I expected it to be. I love Colin Farrell. I think Colin Farrell is great in everything. And specifically this role was a weird one for him because it's essentially him asking Hollywood to make him, you know, to de beautify him, you know, to turn him into somebody who is, looks very different, does not look like beautiful Colin Farrell.

So I think he he is doing a fantastic job in this. I really liked him in the Batman, but also.

Ben: Oh my god, I've heard so many people say that she really knocks it out of the park in this series.

Devindra: I mean, listen, whenever she appears, and I've talked about her before in some things, but you may remember her from, you know, How I Met Your Mother.

She's been, whenever she pops up in something, it's always it's fun. I'm trying to think, Mythic Quest, the show we've talked about, the Apple TV Plus show, she pops up in one episode. A single episode and it is not tied to the rest of the series at all, but she is just so great in it. And here she has talked about always wanting to [00:43:00]play a Batman villain her entire life.

And here she gets to play a Batman villain in a really fun way. So it is a character that has been referred to in Pat. Like it is a known character with a known villain name, but not the sort of like super villainy stuff. She's just having fun. She's doing really good. I think like she is really compelling and kind of interesting to watch.

So the show is good. It's sort of what if what if Tony Soprano basically it's like the Sopranos meets the Batman universe because it's essentially the penguin being like, you know, a low level, a low level mobster who's trying to build him way, build his way up in a crime family, but it's also shot mostly in New York.

So it has like the grit of Tony Soprano driving around New Jersey or the opening of the Sopranos or something. So there's a lot of that in there. I'm having a lot of fun with it. It's pretty fantastic show, especially if you liked the last Batman movie, which was pretty good. Yeah. Anything from you, Ben?

Ben: Yeah. So, in 1998, after years [00:44:00] of trying to clean up its waterways, Singapore finally got otters again. They started just running around the area near the coast. And in about 2015 or 16, one of my favorite kids was born. college professors sadly left my alma mater and went to the Yale NUS, the National University of Singapore location.

And I was on TED. com just looking around at TED Talks because I hadn't seen any TED Talks recently and I was like, Oh my God, Philip Johns did a TED Talk? And so yes, this is TEDx. This is not the main event. It's a TEDx. That is the joke. This is a quality talk. And Philip is a evolutionary biologist and animal behaviorist.

He taught a really great class in animal behavior when I was in school. And I really think that you should check out this talk that he did. It's about 14 minutes called Otters of Singapore, what [00:45:00]we can learn from urban wildlife.

Devindra: You could also do one about the dolphins of New York too, and the whales of New York, which Started appearing once again the East River once we cleaned it up.

So yeah.

Ben: Yeah, so it's part a history of what Singapore did to bring biodiversity back, and it's also part, you know, his appreciation For Singapore from having lived there for a while So, of course Singapore mentioned only when Sherlyn's not on the show.

Devindra: Such a shame, such a shame I'm sure she's she's feeling the pang of this somewhere.

I also want to shout out real quick something else I saw is the the Shadow Strays, which is a new action movie on Netflix and I've I'm a big fan of the director, Timo Giagianto he has done a lot of great Indonesian action films. I think this is a pretty solid one. I did a full review over at the Filmcast, but it's worth checking out if you like action movies and martial arts films.

If you like Tenchu, if you like the game Tenchu, he essentially made a modern Tenchu movie.

Ben: Thanks [00:46:00] for listening. Our theme music is by game composer, Dale North. Our outro music is by our former managing editor, Terrence O'Brien. The podcast is produced by me, Ben Elman. You can find Devindra online at

Devindra: Devindra on Twitter, Blue Sky, Mastodon, all the usual places. And I podcast about movies and TV at the Filmcast at thefilmcast.com.

Ben: You can find me online at @heybellman, email us at podcast@engadget.com. Leave us a review on iTunes and subscribe on anything that gets podcasts. That includes Spotify. Thanks folks. We're out.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/mobile/engadget-podcast-the-new-ipad-mini-is-boring-and-thats-okay-113045384.html?src=rss

Nintendo Alarmo review: Charming, yet frustrating

Alarmo is the quintessential Nintendo product: It's a fun and quirky spin on a bedside alarm clock (with a motion sensor!) that mines your love for everything Nintendo. It's a $100 device entirely meant to surprise and delight you. But there are also usability issues that make me think the company's engineers haven't encountered any modern gadgets over the past decade (which is how long they've been developing Alarmo).

Here's an example: There's no easy way to input your Wi-Fi password if you ever want to download new themes. Instead you have to patiently spin its bulbous top button until you land on the character you need, then press it down like Mario squashing a Goomba. That may not sound like much of an issue, especially since you may only need to do it once, but it's needlessly frustrating if you have a complex password with multiple letter cases, numbers and symbols. My password is all lowercase letters, thankfully, but it still took me three minutes to punch it in. Instead of getting some rest, it just made me want to throw Alarmo out of my window(-o).

But then I had it lull me to sleep with the sounds of The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild. At 6:30am, rascally Koroks roused me from my slumber and made their telltale noises as I shuffled around my bed. And once I got up, they performed Hestu's traditional celebratory dance, much to the chagrin of my sleeping cats. All was forgiven.

Nintendo Alarmo side view
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

Nobody actually needs Alarmo (officially dubbed the "Nintendo Sound Clock: Alarmo"), but its appeal to Nintendo fans is obvious. It wouldn't be out of place as a prop in Mario Odyssey, with its cartoonishly round, red case, nubby feet and prominent control knob (which glows, naturally). Its 2.8-inch screen is surprisingly small and square, not round like some of Nintendo's promotional videos make it seem, and its speakers are loud enough to fill even large bedrooms with undistorted nostalgia bombs. Controlling it is relatively simple: Twist and push the knob, or use the back button to return to the previous screen. You can also view notifications, like updates on your sleep cycle, by tapping the message button.

I'll admit my bias: I was practically raised on Nintendo consoles, so it's almost as if Alarmo was built specifically for someone like me. I don't really mind that Alarmo's large red case doesn't really fit with the clean aesthetic of my bedroom. But I'm sure it'll be a tougher sell if you're sharing a bed with someone less Nintendo-pilled. (More on that below.)

While Alarmo is mostly pitched as an alarm clock with Nintendo themes — at launch, there are sounds and characters from Mario Odyssey, The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, Splatoon 3, Pikmin 4 and (strangely enough) Ring Fit Adventure — it also adds a bit of Nintendo charm throughout your day. Alarmo can produce hourly chimes, and also play "Sleepy Sounds" related to your theme. For Breath of the Wild, that includes the crackling of a campfire, nocturnal animals and delightful snippets of the game's score. (I could be mistaken, but it also sounds like there's a bit of score from the moments before a Blood Moon arrives. I hope Nintendo snips that out eventually — nobody wants to go to bed dreading a Blood Moon.)

Nintendo Alarmo top view
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

As an alarm clock, Alarmo gets the job done. It managed to wake me up successfully every day over the past week, and it did so far less jarringly than my iPhone's blaring speaker. It simply felt pleasant to be welcomed into the world by Koroks and Mario. Every toss and turn triggered more sound effects, which slowly nudged me awake. In its default "Steady Mode," Alarmo also gets progressively louder the longer you stay in bed, and more nefarious characters like Bowser might make an appearance. But if you just want things to stay super chill, there's also a "Gentle Mode" that doesn't escalate noise. Alarmo also responds to the mere act of getting out of bed with a huge celebration — honestly, it's about time someone recognized the effort.

While Nintendo provides some rudimentary sleep statistics, based on Alarmo's motion sensing and your alarm settings, they're mostly useless. I think my numbers may have been skewed by my three cats, who sleep on my bed for most of the day, and may be triggering the device's motion sensor. I certainly wish I could have slept for the 17 hours it recorded at one point. (I'm lucky to get six hours these days.) Even if Alarmo's sleep-tracking was functional, there's not much you can do with the data, since it's all stuck on the device. That's one of many areas where having a separate app would have been useful. (You'd think it would work with Pokemon Sleep, but no!)

Nintendo Alarmo sleep tracking
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

Another issue? Alarmo's unique motion sensing technology is only made for a single sleeper (just like Google’s latest Nest Hub). If you're in bed beside a partner or unruly kids, Nintendo recommends switching to "Button mode," where you have to tap the top knob to disable the alarm. At least it's easy to change Alarmo's modes, and if you leave the sensor on by mistake, it's not the end of the world when it actually goes off. You'll hear a bit more noise than usual, but you can still hit the top button to quiet things down.

There are only three things inside Alarmo's box: The device itself, a USB Type A to USB-C cable and a small instruction booklet. Notably missing is a USB power adapter. That's something we've grown used to with smartphones and some of Nintendo's handhelds, but not bundling one is still a pain for anyone who doesn't have spare power adapters. I can just imagine a parent trying to set up Alarmo for their eager child, only to be delayed for a day because they need to run out and buy a separate adapter. That's not surprising and delightful, Nintendo. It's just annoying.

The actual onboarding process is pretty straightforward. Once you plug it in, Alarmo teaches you how to use its top dial and button, and explains how the back button works. You can also rotate the dial to adjust its volume and the device directs you to wave your hand in front of it to test its motion sensing. You have to direct Alarmo's orientation towards your bed and make sure it has a clear view of your sleeping area at the edge of a nightstand or table. The motion sensing won't work if it's too high.

Nintendo Alarmo rear view
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

To finish off the setup process, you have to lay down and make sure Alarmo can actually detect your movement. That worked without much fuss on my end, but when it asked me to sit up and lean in a specific direction, there was a delay of a few minutes before it noticed correctly when I was leaning to the right.

At the very least, Nintendo didn't force me to connect to Wi-Fi during the initial setup. Instead, that's triggered when you choose to update its themes, and the entire process required is just frustrating, as I described above. Now, it's not as if Nintendo hasn't learned to use QR codes via websites and apps to simplify logins. You also have to sign in to your Nintendo account once Alarmo is connected to Wi-Fi, but I was thankfully able to use a QR code to do so over my iPhone.

I suppose Nintendo wanted to have a simpler onboarding experience for Alarmo, one that didn't require external authentication or an additional app. But that desire for simplicity still leads to needless frustration.

It would be nice to see a wider selection of themes, as well. I’m not sure many Nintendo fans are clamoring to re-experience the characters and music from Ring Fit Adventure, after all. Where’s Kirby? Where’s Mario Kart? If there’s room for Splatoon and Pikmin, there should be room for Nintendo’s more iconic franchises.

Nintendo Alarmo Super Mario Odyssey Peach alarm
Devindra Hardawar for Engadget

I'm no stranger to tech-infused alarms. My nightstand is already overloaded with gadgets, including an Amazon Echo Dot (which I use to play radio stations), an older Phillips SmartSleep rise light, a Homedics white noise machine, my iPhone 15 Pro Max (charging on a Belkin MagSafe stand) and a Hatch Baby video monitor. As much as I appreciated having bits of Nintendo magic in my bedroom, I didn't love it enough to replace any of the devices I'm already using.

But my daughter Sophia is another story. We've played through most of Tears of the Kingdom together, and I've done my best to teach her in the ways of Nintendo. (I'll save the issues with the company's extreme litigiousness for when she's older.) She's eager to use Alarmo to wake up on her own, without my early-morning badgering. She also loves Koroks, so I'm pretty sure the Zelda theme will be permanently enabled. At least, until Kirby arrives.

I'm not going to try and justify the need for a $100 alarm clock. If you're a big enough Nintendo fan, you've probably already locked in your pre-order. And there's a chance it'll become more compelling over time, if Nintendo manages to add themes and drive down the price. For now, though, it’s a reminder that Nintendo can do more than just churn out consoles and games. There’s still room for the company to take weird swings, it’s just too bad Alarmo is expensive and imperfect.

This article originally appeared on Engadget at https://www.engadget.com/gaming/nintendo/nintendo-alarmo-review-charming-yet-frustrating-194432214.html?src=rss